Arbon Valley kept the Fourth of July of 1913 in two places. With the flag flying, the Latter-day Saints met at the Central school house, while the Gentiles, as non-Mormons were then called, climbed to a mountain top eight miles above the post office. A visitor named B. W. Rice wondered why.
When I asked why they did not all go together they smiled and said that each crowd had some ways that the others could not get used to. I didn’t follow up the investigation further, for I have some ways myself that some other folks don’t like.
Rice wrote that the next day, July 5, in a long letter from Arbon that the Pocatello Tribune ran on July 8 under the headline “800,000 Bushels of Grain in Rich Bannock Valley.” He was almost certainly the Rev. B. W. Rice, the Congregational minister who was then starting the valley’s first Protestant churches. A shorter report of his appears in A minister’s portrait of Bannock Valley in 1913. This longer one goes through the valley farm by farm.
A crop with no railroad
He began with the figures. The valley lay 5,250 feet up, with 31 square miles in grain on land that sold for $20 an acre. He looked for about 800,000 bushels that fall, 700,000 of them to be sold. Every one of those bushels would have to go by team to the railroad at 15 cents apiece, a $105,000 hauling bill that came to $280.40 for each person in the valley. In five years, Rice was sure, travelers would be passing through on “the steam cars.” The railroad never came.
By his count the valley held 123 Gentiles and 250 Mormons. When the American Falls Press summed up his report, it put the Mormons at 295, but Rice’s own sums support his figure: $105,000 divided among 373 people comes to about $281.50 each.
Among the Gentile Christians, Mrs. E. A. Logan led the singing and the Sunday school, and Mr. Allard served as superintendent. Farther up the valley Mr. and Mrs. Nunnelly, probably W. A. Nunnelley and his wife, had kept alive “a church sentiment.” How that Sunday school began in 1911 is told in the first Protestant Sunday school and church.
From the cab to the plow
A good many of the farmers Rice met had come off the railroad. E. A. Logan had fired a locomotive until three years before, when he quit to take up 160 acres; no whistle told him when to start work any more, and Rice judged that he “now owns his own soul.” Frank Jones had likewise left a yard engine for a homestead backed up against the foothills. T. B. Evans, “an old timer,” had arrived fourteen years earlier “after finding a short rail on the Short Line,” words the letter never explains, and he now held four quarter sections.
William Allard had been in the valley four years and counted on threshing 5,000 bushels; a year later he ran for the Legislature. J. E. Keeler had his own 160 and another 160 acres of leased state land, all of it in wheat, and by late October he had threshed 4,300 bushels. The men Rice called George and John “Butter” were probably G. S. Butler and John Butler, whom the Press had listed with Allard and Keeler among the newcomers of 1911.
Some of the names in the letter need a little untangling. “Bishop Arbon,” the valley’s leading farmer by Rice’s account, was Joseph N. Arbon, the first bishop. “Donnum Daniels,” who ran a hay ranch beside a mountain spring, was probably John M. “Donum” Daniels of West Fork. “John Bowman,” whose poplars were fifteen years old and whose cellar had held his own apples the winter before, was probably D. J. Bowen, who planted his poplars in 1895. Mr. Lindley, “the Mark Twain of the valley,” who umpired the ball game on the Fourth, was probably B. D. Lindley, father of Roy Lindley. A few others, Frank Jones and Mr. Van Horn among them, cannot be identified any further.
Two churches in a week
Eight days after the letter was written, on Sunday, July 13, Ludwig Thomsen, superintendent of the Congregational church in Idaho, “instituted two new churches” in the valley, according to the Tribune. A resident pastor was expected soon, and church buildings would follow later: one about six miles above the Arbon post office, the other probably in the village “sure to follow the advent of the new railroad.” Until then the congregation three miles below the post office would gather in the new Central school, where the basement held a hall 60 feet square. People of several denominations, the paper said, had come together in “one society of worship.”
On August 6 the Tribune reprinted an unsigned letter from the Boise Statesman. It was probably Rice’s too, since it describes the same sample of wheat. This one guessed lower, at 600,000 bushels and “a $90,000 winter job” to haul them. Thomsen had brought an evangelist with him, it said, and the Mormons came to the meetings in large numbers. Its 158 heads of wheat from a single seed, at 40 grains to the head, make the 6,320 grains that both papers printed, which suggests the Press figure of 168 heads was a misprint. The writer also grumbled that the reservation stood between the valley and the railroad towns, and he described its people in the disparaging language of the day, which is not repeated here.
A year later the two congregations were made official. On Thursday, June 25, 1914, the Arbon and Highland Congregational churches met together in the Highland church’s chapel, where Thomsen and two delegates from the Pocatello church received them into the Idaho Conference of Congregational churches and Thomsen extended “the right hand of fellowship.” Their pastor, the Rev. Thomas Dent Fee, had come that April. In 1915 a seminary student looked after both churches, and according to the Summit area history the Highland church was given up in the early 1920s.
Rice’s words outlasted his visit. When Mrs. Logan wrote her history of the valley in 1917, retold in The squatters of 1892, in Mrs. Logan’s words, she borrowed whole passages from his letter and from the Statesman piece: the finger on the map at Pocatello, Evans and his short rail, her own husband the fireman, the sunsets at the Daniels ranch. Where Rice had put “John Bowman,” she put “John Bowen.” Of Rice himself the papers found say nothing more, not even how long he stayed, but for one summer he had written down the valley name by name.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, July 8, 1913, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan.
800,000 Bushels of Grain in Rich Bannock Valley
Bumper Yields Assured This Year in Fertile District Naturally Tributary to Pocatello—Without Railroad, It Will Cost $105,000 to Haul the Crop to Nearest Shipping Point—Ex-Railroad Men Making Good as Grain Growers and Building Up Big Country.
(By B. W. Rice.)
Arbon, July 5.—Here in Bannock valley, 5250 feet above sea level, live 123 Gentiles and 250 Mormons and at present 31 square miles of splendid grain, on land that can be bought for $20 per acre. Five years from now we will be riding through here on the steam cars pointing out to companions this place and that place that could have been bought now at a poor man’s figure, but cannot be bought then for $7000 for the quarter section.
From a line through the center of the valley lengthwise there is ample wood and good timber within four miles. Two saw mills supply the lumber at $20 per M.
Grain is making a fine crop. Wheat will crowd 25 bushels; barley 45, and oats 50. That means 800,000 bushels of grain here in this beautiful mountain valley. Seven hundred thousand bushels of this will be for sale, and will cost 15 cents per bushel to haul to the railroad, which means $105,000 team work, which is $280.40 for every human being in the valley. The grain itself is worth three times that sum, so that a young man and his wife who can hold themselves up one year here can earn $1400 with four horses and a quarter section. It will cost him $400, besides what he uses that he raised. They can have good food and clothing, pie three times a week, cake four times, hot biscuits every morning, ice cream occasionally, a water melon now and then, etc.
I find good gardens everywhere in the valley. Yesterday Mrs. Rust fed us fine new ptoatoes and elegant new peas. There are no radishes anywhere else like they have here and even the guineas have an extra twist on their song.
Yesterday with the stars and stripes flying, the Latter-day Saints met in the central school house and the Gentiles gathered on the mountain top eight miles above the postoffice. When I asked why they did not all go together they smiled and said that each crowd had some ways that the others could not get used to. I didn’t follow up the investigation further, for I have some ways myself that some other folks don’t like.
Not many people are sickly here and not many die, for it costs $35 to get a doctor from Malad and $50 for a Pocatello physician.
Mrs. E. A. Logan, a young woman of religious turn, came in here three years ago and has been leading the Gentile christians in song and Sunday school, while Mr. Allard has been the superintendent. These two persons assisted by the partners of their life’s sorrows and joys, have kept up a Sunday school in the middle lower valley, while in the middle upper end Mr. and Mrs. Nunnelly together with friends have kept alive a church sentiment.
Of course the Latter-day Saints maintain their regular church services and work together superbly.
E. A. Logan, a locomotive fireman, quit his job three years ago and took up a splendid 160. He now has great fields of fine wheat and barley and oats, a big potato patch and a good garden, and there is no whistle tooting around telling him when to go to work. He doubtless works harder than a fireman, but then he now owns his own soul.
William Allard, a four year old comer, has all his quarter section under cultivation, a big barn, a good house, a windmill and a splendid outfit of implements and machinery, and will thresh 5000 bushels of grain this fall. He is now instituting a fine cement water plant for the premises and will soon turn a faucet and out comes the aqua.
Frank Jones quit a yaid engine three years ago and paid Uncle Sam $16 for one of the most picturesque homesteads in all the valley or all Idaho. Laying back against the foothills next to the mountains, free from frost, fine rich soil, a warm canyon breeze in winter, a cool, bracing zephyr in summer, cool, sweet spring water to drink, and a delightful view of 12,000 or 15,000 acres of grain and hay. Nobody, not even a wife to call him up on the carpet for finding the short rail.
George Butter came in four years ago and now owns a quarter section and is prosperous. John Butter has over 300 acres of wheat and is looking for 25 bushels. Morris Johnson has a good 160, all under cultivation and well improved. He is getting his third profitable crop this time.
J. E. Keeler has his 160 in splendid condition and has 160 acres state land leased and in wheat, on which a delightful crop is growing.
T. B. Evans, an old timer, came here fourteen years ago after finding a short rail on the Short Line, and now owns four 160’s and has regained his health, is rugged and strong.
John Bowman has a grove of poplar trees fifteen years old. He has vegetables, fruit trees and several sorts of berries nicely bearing. He had his own apples in his cellar last winter.
Bishop Arbon has a fine place. His four 160 acres are in splendid shape and he is the leading prosperous farmer of the valley.
Donnum Daniels with his fine hay ranch is making money. His residence is near a big mountain spring on the head of a trout stream. Here as nowhere else in the valley, the splendid sunsets behind the western mountains are only equalled in inspiration by the inspiring hour of a sunrise over the eastern hills.
Mr. Lindley, the Mark Twain of the valley, came in from Washington and intends to spend the remainder of the journey right here. He took your corresondent through barley that he swears will make 75 bushels. He is one of the leading boosters of this region. On the 4th he was umpire for the ball game and his fines amounted to $1800. His good home nestles on the eastern foothills two miles above the postoffice and on either side of him is a son with a 160. His good wife with a well-filled larder got us up a splendid dinner in about 30 minutes. She says she never went to a cooking school, but its a caution what she can do with the fat of two or three chickens. She kept the chickens themselves out for the big lunch at the picnic on the 4th.
Mr. Van Horn, a neighbor of Mr. Lindley, is highly pleased with his home and is getting on his feet in fine shape.
Mr. Smith is coming along nicely, getting ahead year by year. Scores of farmers are making good living and the valley has a bright future.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, July 8, 1913, page 4
- Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, July 12, 1913, page 6
- Pocatello Tribune, July 15, 1913, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, August 6, 1913, page 6
- Pocatello Tribune, July 7, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, August 7, 1913, page 6
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 23, 1913, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 26, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 2, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, April 30, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, page 7
