Robert W. Sturges came to Arbon Valley in the last week of May 1915 with four months to give and two small churches to fill. He was a student at Union Theological Seminary in New York, and he was there for the summer as pastor of the Congregational churches at Arbon and at Highland. The American Falls Press kept track of him all season, and the next winter he wrote about the valley himself, in terms he did not soften.
Two churches waiting
The Protestant work he inherited was young. A Sunday school had started in 1911, at first in people’s homes, and in July 1913 two Congregational churches were organized: one at the Central school and one at Highland, at the valley’s south end in the Summit area. The site’s Stories pages tell of the first Protestant Sunday school and church and the first congregations at Summit. By the spring of 1914 Highland had a building of its own, on land given by Miss Mamie Nunnelley, and that term the school held classes in it.
A minister had come before him. The Rev. Thomas Dent Fee arrived from Eagle Butte, South Dakota, in April 1914 to serve both congregations. By February 1915, though, a “Rev. Thos. D. Fee,” probably the same man, was pastor of the Congregational church at Rockland. That spring the Sunday school that had met at the Valley View schoolhouse the year before was reorganized as a union school, belonging to no one church, with a Mr. Bramstedt in charge; he was probably the homesteader Gus Brahmstadt. By early June it had closed.
A pastor for the summer
The Press brought the news on June 3, 1915, tucked among items about Turkey red wheat, coyote dens and a new shipment of hats. A pastor had been engaged, it said. Sturges, “of New York City,” would be in Arbon for the next four months; he had come in “Friday of last week” and had already preached Sunday morning at both churches. Everyone was invited, members or not.
The dates in the paper do not quite line up. The South Arbon column on that same page put his first sermon “to his little congregation at Highland” on the morning of Sunday, May 23. That Sunday the Latter-day Saints of the south end held their meeting at E. G. Smith’s home. When he preached at Arbon on the evening of May 30, a large crowd came.
He set to work quickly. On Sunday, June 6, a Sunday school was organized at the Central school, with William Allard as superintendent, Miss Merle Porter as secretary, Mrs. J. E. Keeler as treasurer and Miss Leslie Featherstone at the organ. By July the paper was calling it the Union Sunday school and reporting that it was “progressing nicely.”
At Highland the church got ready for a Children’s Day program on the evening of Sunday, June 27, with Mrs. Emmett Lee in charge of the Sunday school’s part. The crowd overflowed the building, “There not being standing room in the house,” the column said. Songs and recitations came from children of the Stott, Smith, McCauley, Chapman, Nunnelley and Lee families. On a Monday that summer Sturges climbed Bannock Mountain with James Smith, and apparently Charlie Smith too, and from the summit they looked out on Salt Lake and a long reach of the Snake River.
A third Sunday school
Between his two churches he revived the Valley View Sunday school. Its social at the schoolhouse on the evening of July 24 was “largely attended,” and the paper gave the credit to “R. Sturges, pastor of the Congregational church here.” The same day a large crowd gathered at the Pauline L. D. S. grounds to keep the 24th of July, the Latter-day Saints’ Pioneer Day. The Highland Sunday school called its own social at the church for Saturday, July 31, and in August its young people hosted the community’s young people there on a Saturday evening, with games, cake and punch.
On August 2 the south-end farmers started heading their grain, cutting it in the field. The school trustees bought a lot beside the church lot on Mamie Nunnelley’s land, and that fall the Highland school went up on it. By early September there were no more services at the Central schoolhouse, and the paper said Sturges would soon be going home to California. On September 16 it reported him gone “last Monday,” bound for the Panama Exposition with his parents and then back to his studies in New York. The item closed warmly: in his four months with the Arbon and Highland churches, he had “made many friends who hate to see him leave.”
Where leadership is needed
The valley got his verdict in January 1916, when The American Missionary printed his short article “Where Leadership Is Needed,” introduced by an editor’s note as the work of “a theological student who gave his summer vacation to the field.” He laid out his circuit as “two churches, about twelve miles apart, and a Sunday-school half way between.” The Arbon congregation met in a schoolhouse, Highland owned its building and land, and the Sunday school in the middle used the Valley View schoolhouse.
Writing for a missions audience, he was blunt. He reckoned the valley “about sixty per cent. Mormon,” a share he saw slowly falling as Protestant farmers came in, and he noted that Latter-day Saints mixed with Protestants in everyday life but rarely attended their services. He thought poorly of the schools, believed that education would lead most Latter-day Saints to drop or reshape their faith, and was glad of that year’s teachers partly because they were not Latter-day Saints. Those were one visitor’s views. The Press columns that summer had set the gatherings of both faiths next to each other and passed no judgment on either.
His own flock fared little better in print. The Protestants, he wrote, “are also indifferent,” busy homesteaders “quite apt to work on Sunday, especially in harvest time,” lacking education, their children without good schools. What the valley needed most from a missionary, in his view, was a “really capable school teacher.” Yet he also allowed that “The people are hospitable, and respond fairly well to good leadership.”
Off to war
Three years later the Press had news of him once more. On July 26, 1918, it reported that he had married Miss Merl McClees at Seattle on June 22. He had been in training at Camp Lewis since the September before, and a card from him had arrived on June 25 from Fargo, North Dakota, as he traveled to New York; he was believed to have sailed for “over there,” the war overseas. His bride returned to California to wait for him.
The Highland church outlasted his summer by only a few years. According to the Summit area history, the community church there was given up in the early 1920s. The building where the crowd had once found no standing room stood empty after that, a shelter for the horses children rode to school.
The original article
American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan.
CENTRAL ARBON NEWS.
Andy Olafson, who has a homestead here, returned a few days ago from Logan, Utah, where he has been for several months. He has a fine stand of Turkey red wheat on his farm.
Frank Swim has gone to Twin Falls and district surrounding in search of a stock ranch. He has a valuable farm here, which he has leased to Mr. Johnson, a recent arrival from Kansas.
Many of the Pauline and Central Arbonites attended the ball game last Sunday.
We are still having rainy weather. It has rained considerable the past week and hay crops are looking better.
W. E. Titus of Pocatello was a visitor in the valley Friday, returning to Pocatello Saturday.
There are a few new homesteaders who recently filed on land in Knox canyon, that are building on their land. Even the mountain ranges are being homesteaded, which is gradually crowding out the sheepmen.
John Payne and Mr. Thyberg went to Pocatello last week on business.
Mrs. Evans has a few hats left yet and expects a new shipment soon.
Clifford Gerkings is busy these days turning the sod over for Mr. Porter.
Mr. Porter has leased the old Rodema place and expects to commence breaking on the place this summer.
Mrs. D. B. Evans was a Malad visitor the last of the week.
A pastor has been engaged for the Congregational churches of Arbon valley. Mr. Robert W. Sturges of New York City, a student in Union Theological Seminary, will be in Arbon for the next four months. Mr. Sturges arrived here Friday of last week and held services Sunday morning at the Highland Congregational church and also at the Arbon Congregational church. Everyone is cordially invited to attend the services, whether you are members or not. Come and bring your friends. Time and place of meeting will be published elsewhere in the Arbon items.
There has been several coyotte dens found this spring and many of the pups have been killed, which makes them that many less for the chickens.
The Parma Brothers, well drillers, completed a well for Peck Winnet and Albert Poppy recently.
Mrs. Sherman Randall who has been ill, is improving.
Mr. Lorenzo Lovin and J. R. Bailey were in Malad Tuesday on business, returned home Wednesday.
Mr. Porter was also a Malad visitor during the week.
George Williams, a resident and mayor of Pocatello, came out with a party of business men a few days ago to look after the interests of Mr. William’s mining claim here. They report fine prospects for crops here this year.
Sources
- American Falls Press, April 2, 1914, page 11
- American Falls Press, April 30, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 4, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, April 29, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 3, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 17, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 8, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, July 15, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 29, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 12, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 2, 1915, page 8
- American Falls Press, September 16, 1915, page 2
- The American Missionary, January 1916, page 612
- American Falls Press, July 26, 1918, page 3
