To Roy Lindley of Arbon, no cougar or coyote in Idaho did as much harm to the game herds as the golden eagle. In the spring of 1937, when the state’s new game warden stopped a campaign to cut the birds down, Lindley put his objection in a letter. A Pocatello dispatch in the Salt Lake Tribune of April 30, 1937, carried the news and gave a good share of what he wrote.
The quarrel was between two wardens. Amos Eckert, who had held the office for years, had heard that eagles were going after mountain sheep, mountain goats and deer, and he set a crew to work thinning them out. William McIntyre, who followed him into the job, withdrew the order.
Lindley did not defend everything Eckert had done. The old warden may well have made plenty of mistakes, he wrote, but the eagle drive had been a genuine help to Idaho’s sportsmen. Lambs and kids of the mountain sheep and goat come into the world on steep, broken slopes where almost nothing can get at them, he explained. The eagle can. Against the young of those animals, he said, the bird “makes the cougar and coyote look like pikers,” meaning small-timers, and dropping the fight against it “falls little short of a crime.”
He said he had arrived at that opinion over many years, from what he had seen with his own eyes and from talking with people in the Salmon River country of central Idaho. The digitized copy of the article is hard to read at this point, but he appears to have warned that unless the eagles were very nearly wiped out, the hunters who came after him would have no sheep or goats left to hunt.
His answer was a bounty. Put a price on the eagle, he argued, and every prospector, woodsman and hunter, and anyone else carrying a gun into the hills, would be on the lookout for one. Failing that, he wanted the state or the federal government to pay seasoned hunters to do the job.
A hunter from the east bench
The Tribune called him simply a sportsman of Arbon who knew the bird’s damage well. Valley readers knew him better than that. The writer was very likely the same Roy D. Lindley who had been the valley’s member of the Power County commission, probably from 1929 to 1935, and whose place in the valley’s line of commissioners is told on the Evans family page. The Lindleys are among the families found in land records on the Arbon area history.
The American Falls Press had found him with a rifle in hand twenty years before. In the fall of 1917 the paper’s traveling farm writer, who went by “The Pilgrim,” stopped at Roy Lindley’s ranch home, five miles southeast of the Arbon post office, and sat down to a dinner of elk. Roy and his father had just returned from hunting elk on the South Fork of the Snake, close to where Idaho meets Jackson’s Hole, and Roy had also brought back a native trout 20 inches long.
That November the Pilgrim wrote that father and son farmed 1,200 acres on the valley’s east side, on ranches reaching well into the foothills. Through the winter they hunted and trapped coyotes, which paid in pelts and made good sport besides. He described one of them, likely Roy, though the column names only “Mr. Lindley,” as a fine shot with a rifle who took a great many coyotes that way and kept a line of traps too. More than once the winter before, all four traps had held a coyote by morning, and by the howling at night the hills still had plenty of “chicken thieves” left.
In November 1921 the Arbon News column of the Press reported that Roy Lindley had gone into Bull Canyon with a doctor visiting from American Falls, and that the two came home with their limit of deer.
The parts of the 1937 letter the Tribune printed are about the Salmon River country, not Arbon Valley, and they say nothing of eagles on the Lindley place. It is not known where Lindley sent the letter or whether it ran in full anywhere. The papers read for this story carry no reply from McIntyre or his department, and no word on whether the eagle drive ever started up again. As far as the record goes, the rancher had the last word.