Ten days before the election of 1914, a party of Republican candidates set out from American Falls for three nights of meetings in the farm country to the south. At Crystal the local leaders had a basket lunch waiting, and the dancing went on until the small hours. At Arbon about sixty turned out. At Pauline there were perhaps fewer people than at Crystal, but its interest, the American Falls Press judged, was every bit as keen. When the votes were counted, the man Power County sent to the Idaho House of Representatives was one of the valley’s own: William Allard, a homesteader from Arbon.
He was the county’s first. Until 1913 Arbon had been a precinct of Oneida County, run from the courthouse at Malad. That year it became part of the new Power County, with its seat at American Falls, and the election of November 3, 1914, was the first general election the new county ever held.
A league for Borah
The campaign opened in the spring. On April 9 Republicans from every precinct gathered in the American Falls auditorium and formed a Power County Borah League to back Senator William E. Borah, resolving to put “aside petty factional differences.” Each precinct chose three committeemen. Arbon sent J. W. Butler, T. B. Evans and J. R. Dawson; Crystal sent L. F. Moench Jr., S. R. Phillips and W. C. Snyder.
The Progressives meant to compete for the valley as well. On June 24 four of their men, W. O. Lloyd, Henry Rock, O. C. Hall and R. O. Jones, headed out to Arbon to organize.
Near the end of June J. E. Keeler of Arbon brought discouraging word to town. A frost two weeks or so before had hurt the crops so badly, in his judgment, that perhaps a third of the Bannock Valley acreage would ever reach harvest. He announced as well that he would run for county commissioner as a Democrat, saying his neighbors had long been pressing him to. Keeler and Allard knew each other from valley business. In September 1913, when settlers met at the Central school to form a telephone company, they made Allard its secretary and Keeler one of its directors.
Primary day
Voters went to the primary on Tuesday, September 1, though few of them did so beyond American Falls and Rockland, the Press grumbled. P. A. Anderson’s name had appeared alongside Allard’s for representative on the Republican side of the official notice, which makes him the likely opponent. With two precincts yet to report, Allard led him 210 to 91. Once everything but Crystal was in, the paper set out the November tickets. For the House, Wm. Allard of Arbon would run as the Republican, Thomas R. Guy of Landing as the Democrat and W. O. Lloyd of Rockland as the Progressive. In the Second District race for commissioner, J. E. Keeler of Arbon carried the Democratic banner against M. E. Walker and Henry Rock, both of Rockland.
T. B. Evans carried the Arbon returns over himself. Jewell Horton of Arbon and I. W. Phillips of Crystal took places on the Republican county central committee, and the nominees sat down with its officers to lay out “a thorough campaign throughout the county.”
Three nights in the valley
That campaign reached the valley in the third week of October. John Richter and W. D. Barnhart went ahead as advance men, scrambling because the meeting dates had been shuffled. D. W. Davis of American Falls, back only that week from two weeks on the stump in northern Idaho, continued on to Crystal for a speech billed for the evening of Thursday, October 22.
Crystal gave the visitors their best night. Both the lunch and the attendance drew the paper’s praise. The next evening at the Arbon schoolhouse the turnout fell to about sixty, because the date had been moved just two days ahead of time and not everyone had heard. Pauline, at the valley’s north end, met on Saturday, October 24. Its date had been moved too, and its crowd may have been smaller, yet the Press put it nearly level with Crystal’s for interest. The candidates came home “feeling well paid for their hard trip.”
The paper never named who made that trip. Allard does turn up two days after Pauline, on the evening of Monday, October 26, giving one of the short talks at a Republican rally in Rockland’s brick hall. The Progressives, meanwhile, had booked the Crystal schoolhouse for October 26 and the Arbon North End and South End schoolhouses for the two following nights; no report of those meetings appeared.
The Press backed the Republicans, and in its October 29 issue it profiled their candidates for the board and the legislature. Its verdict on the man from Arbon:
William Allard, of Arbon, for the lower house is one of our new settlers, a farmer, well educated, a good speaker, and a good thinker. In every way he is entirely worthy.
New he was. He had filed on his homestead on April 13, 1909, and the patent to it was signed only on March 7, 1914. The Allard family photographs show more of the family.
Election and after
The county voted on Tuesday, November 3. The official returns ran in the November 12 Press, but the scan of that page is too garbled to read the numbers. The same issue settled the question another way: it noted that Allard, “the first representative in the legislature from Power county,” had been in American Falls on business on Tuesday, November 10. The following week the paper’s statewide roster of the new legislature listed William Allard, Republican, of Arbon, for Power County.
Keeler lost his race. M. E. Walker of Rockland won the Second District seat, and by May 1915 the Press was addressing him as “Commissioner.” No valley man is known to have sat on the county board before Gus Brahmstadt of Arbon in 1917.
On Sunday, January 3, 1915, Allard set out for Boise and the session with his wife and daughter. The Press saw him off:
Mr. Allard has been a resident of what is now Power county for five years, is a man of very high character and is capable. He has a farm in Arbon valley.
He tried for the Republican nomination once more in 1916. The paper said he had served “with credit,” but when it printed the ticket that September, Andrew May of Rockland was the party’s choice for representative. Allard’s time in Boise was not over. He returned to the House in 1919, this time as a Democrat, a turn told among the valley’s firsts.
The original article
American Falls Press, October 29, 1914, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
REPUBLICAN CANDIDATES HAVE SUCCESSFUL MEETINGS
Candidates Visit Crystal, Arbon and Pauline and Are Well Received.
The Republican candidates who visited Crystal, Arbon and Pauline last week are profuse in their praise of the reception they received. At Crystal the leaders prepared a sumptuous basket lunch, and after the meeting was through the lunch was served and dancing was enjoyed until an early hour. The attendance was splendid and a thoroughly good time was enjoyed.
The following evening a meeting was held at the Arbon school house. The attendance was not so good here, owing to a change in the date of the meeting only two days before the meeting, word of the change not reaching everyone. About sixty were present at this meeting.
Saturday evening at Pauline there was held a splendid meeting, rivaling in interest the one at Crystal, although possibly not so many attended. The date of this meeting had also been changed. The interest was good and the candidates returned feeling well paid for their hard trip.
Sources
- American Falls Press, June 12, 1913, page 5
- American Falls Press, September 11, 1913, page 1
- American Falls Press, April 16, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 25, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, July 2, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 27, 1914, page 3
- American Falls Press, September 3, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 10, 1914, page 3
- American Falls Press, September 17, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 15, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 22, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 29, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 29, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, November 12, 1914, page 2
- American Falls Press, November 12, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, November 19, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, January 7, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, May 20, 1915, page 5
- American Falls Press, August 10, 1916, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1916, page 4
