The crew rolled out of their bedrolls at 3:30 on a Thursday morning in September 1957 to find snow coming down on the camp below Bannock Peak. From Pocatello the mountain wore only a light coat that day. On the west slope, where some twenty riders were saddling up in the dark, it was a genuine storm.
It was the second day of the fall roundup on the Bannock Creek side of the Fort Hall Indian Reservation, range just north of the reservation line at Arbon Valley’s north end. The Bannock Creek Cattlemen’s Association ran it, and its members were Indian and white stockmen both. From Wednesday, September 18, into Monday, September 23, they gathered roughly 1,200 head off the summer grass. One of the riders, Merle Meyers, carried a camera and later wrote the whole thing up for the Idaho Sunday Journal, which ran his pictures and story on September 29.
A family on horseback
The paper called Meyers a Pocatello real estate man raised at Crystal. He was very likely the Merle Meyers of Arbon listed as a son when John H. Meyers, the Crystal rancher and stockman, died in 1953, though the 1957 story never names his parents. By the time of the roundup he had moved his wife, Dorothy, and their children Jerry, Jay and Judy onto the reservation along Bannock Creek, into a rented house that had once belonged to an Indian extension agent. Every one of the five could ride, and they kept seven horses between them.
He rode with Sherm Swim, Laris and Edgar Ellison, Sod Williams, Averal McNeil, Orval and Norman Davis, Vern Munn and Turner Wood. Swim, who the paper said also had a house on the reservation, was almost surely Sherman Swim, whose father Bob had rented a Bannock Creek ranch at the reservation line since the early 1930s, as told in the Swim family history; the site also records his death in 2011. Sod Williams was almost surely the Arbon cattleman whose quarter horses the Utah papers were following then, the same family later seen in the arena. His small son Brad came along too, and Meyers captioned him “the littlest cowboy on the roundup.” The two Davises were probably Orval Davis, a son of Ed and Esther Davis of Arbon, and his son Norman (the Davis family), but the paper does not say. Nothing more is given about the Ellisons, McNeil, Munn or Wood. The story says only that the white range users made their homes on Bannock Creek or at Rockland.
Pies from an old stove
Jim and Stella Simitsy had gone up ahead and pitched the camp on a stream the article calls Squaw Creek, at the foot of Bannock Peak, and the riders moved in on Wednesday. Stella, a full-blood Indian by Meyers’s account, cooked for everyone, and he wrote warmly of the pies and biscuits she turned out on an aging camp stove. The couple had a daughter of their own and had raised seven orphans besides.
That snowy Thursday the riders were out before daylight and worked in the storm until noon. Meyers had come without overshoes and learned that chaps and a slicker would not keep a man’s feet warm or dry. After dinner at camp they went out again. The Indian riders packed rifles and kept an eye out for deer, and several were shot on a ride that took the party across what Meyers called the Rocky range, far enough over that Rockland came into sight.
The water froze overnight, and Friday brought more snow. Leonard Mosho, the Simitsys’ teenage stepson, killed two deer, loading the first onto his horse before going back for the other. At some point in those days, Meyers does not say when, the crew rode nearly to the top of Bannock Peak and could see for miles.
A roadside full of watchers
The storm had blown out by Saturday. The day turned hot, and the cattle came down out of the west fork of Bannock Creek in heavy dust. On Sunday the herd, about 1,200 head, was held at the mouth of Starlight Creek, right beside the main road, and the riders spent the afternoon cutting each owner’s animals out of the bunch. So many cars stopped to watch that Meyers compared the shoulder of the road to a parking lot. Dark fell before the sorting was finished, and it went on into Monday.
Meyers ended by explaining how the range was shared. It was Indian land, but the Indian owners ran only about 500 head, not enough to use all the grass, so seven white users put roughly 700 more on it. Together those figures account for the 1,200 gathered at Starlight Creek. The Fort Hall Agency oversaw the grazing season, which ran from April 15 to about October 1 on ground rising from 4,500 to 8,600 feet, and the Indians could hunt and fish there in any season. An older chapter of the same story is told in when Bannock Valley was cattle range, and the reservation’s range units of today appear in names on Bannock Creek.
No other account of this roundup has been found. Meyers left the seven white stockmen unnamed and did not say how long the association had been riding together, though the headline called the roundup an annual one. He summed the week up as “a very delightful way to pass a week,” snow, dust and wet feet included.