Lloyd Brower said he would not keep the senator long. He had come to Twin Falls on January 29, 1960, with one grievance, and he got it said in a couple of minutes: a few years earlier he had given up a fight over his own range on the strength of a promise from the national forest, and now the forest meant to cut his cattle by 40 percent.
He was one of a long line of stockmen who testified that day before the Subcommittee on Public Lands of the Senate Committee on Interior and Insular Affairs. The hearing, printed afterward as Grazing on Public Domain Lands, was called because Senator Frank Church of Idaho had heard a flood of complaints the fall before about smaller grazing allotments. Church could not come. Senator Frank E. Moss of Utah presided and was the only senator in the room, and Church’s administrative assistant, John Carver, read his statement, which said the cuts fell hardest, in proportion, on the small users of the range.
The rancher from Crystal
Brower gave his name to the subcommittee by his initials, J. L., and said he came from Arbon Valley. The site’s family records fill in the rest. Joseph Lloyd Brower was born at Idaho Falls on December 10, 1905, a son of Ariah Brower, who took up land in 1907 on the Hawkins side of the Bannock Range. Lloyd married Hannah Blair in 1924. From 1930 he ranched in the Crystal district, the high basin of springs and creeks where the Bradley ranch lay, and by 1940 the place was his own.
He was a big enough farmer by 1946 to appear in an oil company’s advertising. A Conoco advertisement in the farm magazine Wallaces Farmer that December put him at “1,340 acres of wheat and alfalfa near Arbon, Idaho,” with more than 300 cattle, worked by himself, his wife, two daughters and hired hands. It counted off his equipment as well: a pair of heavy-duty trucks, two tractors, a Massey Harris combine and a Delco light plant. The ad’s purpose was to sell lubricants, but it shows the scale of the ranch. Eight years later, in October 1954, a Lloyd Brower, very likely the same man, was one of two deputies sworn in for the Arbon and Crystal Valley Vigilantes, a patrol the ranchers formed against thieves.
Caught in the middle
At Twin Falls the Pocatello Cattlemen’s Association had its turn in the morning. Leavitt Taylor, speaking for the group, said its members faced a 40 percent cut on the forest and had already appealed twice. Leigh Gittins read the association’s proposals and Ross Gibson, its secretary, said his piece. Then Taylor handed the floor to Brower, who sat on the association’s board.
Brower described himself as a fairly small operator. For years, he said, he had grazed his cattle on deeded land of his own, and that had worked well enough. The trouble was where it lay, wedged between farmers and sheepmen beside the national forest. The result, as he put it, was “a small range war.”
Everyone with a stake, he said, came together on his ground: the Taylor grazing people, the cattle association, the forest and the sheepmen, and he seemed to be the one in the way. Taylor grazing was the stockmen’s shorthand for the grazing districts on the open public domain, managed by the Interior Department under the Taylor Grazing Act of 1934, while the national forests answered to the Department of Agriculture. Cattle and sheep strayed onto his land, Brower said, and his strayed onto theirs. One sheepman made up his mind to buy him out or be rid of him by some other means. They wanted him off that range.
So Brower went to the forest and asked whether he could count on footing there that would keep him in the cattle business. The answer, he said, was that it looked “as good as deeded.” He was pleased with that. He struck his bargain with the sheepman, moved out of his way and onto the forest, and said he was glad to do it.
The cut he protested
His herd was not large, Brower told the subcommittee, but it was a good one, and it had come down off the range in fine condition that fall, as it had each autumn since he began running on the forest. He called the Pocatello Forest one of the best ranges in southeast Idaho, a judgment others who had ridden it with him shared, and said he saw no justification for a 40 percent cut. His farm, he added, sat on the far side of the forest from the city where the stockmen did their business. He thanked the room, Senator Moss thanked him, and no one asked him a question. Noah Myers, who had bought a ranch at Arimo, was called next.
Brower named nobody in his account, neither the sheepman nor the forest officers, and dated the quarrel only to a few years before. He did not say where his deeded range lay, what he gave or got in the trade, how many cattle he ran by 1960 or how many the forest permitted. Nor does the hearing record say whether the cut went through.
His family went on in the valley. His daughter Berna Deane married into the Lusk family, and the Bradleys counted the Browers among their neighbors; the Brower family on the valley timeline follows them further. What the printed hearing keeps is a few minutes of a valley cattleman, in his own plain words, explaining how the old contest of cattle, sheep and plowed ground had played out on his own range, and what he thought a promise from the government ought to be worth.