A cold wind kept a good many people home from the Golden Spike National Livestock Show in Ogden on Sunday, November 18, 1956. Those who came saw the finals of the Intermountain Quarter Horse Association show, the main event of the third day, and in the working cow horse class, where judges watch how a horse handles cattle, the second-place ribbon went to an Idaho entry. Marlowe Cropper of Deseret, Utah, took first with Angus Joe. Close behind was Poco Star, owned by Donald T. Williams of Arbon.
It was the first of many times over the next ten years that the Utah papers would print the name of the Arbon Valley cattle rancher known as Sod, and the names of his horses.
A show in its 38th year
The Golden Spike show was 38 years old that fall, and its horse classes had pulled in entries from across the West. The quarter horse exhibition had opened on Saturday night with a session that ran past midnight. The best halter horses came from far off. Jay Parsons and his wife, of Cody, Wyoming, showed the grand champion stallion, J B King, and the top mare was L M She’ll Do, led by Noyes Evans for Mr. Davidson of Albuquerque, New Mexico. Volney O. Hildreth of Aledo, Texas, judged the horses.
Archie Anderson of Ogden won contest roping on Dick, Mr. Jones of Salt Lake City won western pleasure on Little Penny, and a colt belonging to Mr. and Mrs. Milton Bowman of Soda Springs, Idaho, won its class. Idaho stockmen did well in the barns, too. Von Robbins of King Hill had the grand champion purebred Aberdeen Angus female, Matthews Brothers of Ovid showed the reserve champion Hampshire ram, and Chadwick Guernsey Farm of Ogden swept the Guernsey awards.
While the horses were judged, hundreds of visitors walked among the cattle, sheep and hogs inside the coliseum, and the outdoor pens were full. Show president Rulon P. Peterson and secretary-manager Rudy Van Kampen called the crowd “highly gratifying” even with the weather. They looked to the auctions to carry the show through its last day, Wednesday.
The mail carrier on horseback
Readers of this site already know Donald Thayne “Sod” Williams. In the winter of 1948–49 he carried the Arbon mail on horseback, and his wife Nelda left her own account of that hard winter. Nelda was a daughter of Elmer and Susan Ward, of the valley’s Ward family. In March 1961 the Deseret News livestock columnist, who counted the two as friends, wrote that raising and training quarter horses on their Arbon cattle ranch was what mattered most to them.
Poco Star wins at Tremonton
Poco Star kept winning. At the association’s show in Tremonton, Utah, on May 23 and 24, 1958, the horse took both working cow horse and reining, a class in which the rider puts the horse through a fixed pattern of circles, spins and stops. The Tremonton Leader listed the owner as D. T. Williams of Arbon, and as Sod Williams in the stallion race, where Poco Star came in third. On the night of November 20, 1959, at the association’s yearly fall show, Poco Star was first in working cow horse, beating entries from Payson and Bluebell, Utah, the Ogden Standard-Examiner reported the next day.
Nelda competed as well. At the 1960 Labor Day rodeo at Plymouth, Utah, she won the barrel race and Sod was fourth in bell roping, the Leader said on September 8.
Elected a director
In November 1960 the association’s show at the Golden Spike Coliseum drew upward of 380 horses from nine states, and its officers thought it might be the largest quarter horse show held anywhere in the country that year. Sod rode Poco’s Herfie, second in working cow horse and third in reining by the Tribune’s count. After the Saturday night performance on November 12, the members held their annual meeting and put Donald T. Williams of Arbon on the board. He sat with the other directors in Salt Lake City that January when they laid out the year’s plans. By then the association drew members from Utah, Idaho, Wyoming, Montana and Oregon.
Directors were expected to teach. The first spring clinic of 1961 was set for Blackfoot, Idaho, on March 29 and 30, with three of them giving demonstrations: Roy Corbett of Grace on cow cutting, Oren Morrison of Arimo on judging, and D. T. “Sod” Williams of Arbon on how to rein a horse properly.
At the Golden Spike show that November it was the Williams’ son Barry who rode into the results. He won junior calf roping on Poco’s Herfie, and after the closing performance on November 19 he received the youth performance trophy. The show’s manager judged the crowds and entries large enough to make it likely the biggest quarter horse show yet seen west of the Rockies.
A clinic at BYU
At the Utah State Fair in September 1963, Donald T. Williams of Arbon seems to have shown the reserve champion quarter horse stallion, though the garbled results leave the horse unnamed. In November his entry took junior reining at the Golden Spike show. For the association’s December convention in Salt Lake City he and William F. Greene were chosen to lead the show and contest committee.
The association promised a free clinic at Brigham Young University in Provo for March 21, 1964, and the Lehi Free Press billed Sod’s part as its centerpiece. He would lead a session on four performance classes, western pleasure, western riding, working cow horse and reining, and he would ride green, barely trained horses on purpose, so that every mistake a rider or trainer could make would show plainly. Afterward people in the seats would be invited to a microphone to question him.
Ches A Luck
That year a new name turned up in the results, a gelding called Ches A Luck. At the State Fair in September it was reserve champion gelding and won working cow horse. At the association’s three-day fall show in the State Fairgrounds Coliseum, which closed October 10, it won junior registered reining and placed second in junior registered western pleasure. The Tribune printed the name as “Charles A Luck,” likely the same horse.
The Deseret News account of that show is scrambled in the scan, but it seems to say Sod Williams of Arbon received an award named for Laurel J. Brown, given for youth work, for outstanding service to the horse business and for a third quality the scan cuts off, and that his horse was chosen performance horse and junior horse of the show. Only the page image could settle the details. Brown, of West Jordan, had been elected the association’s president in 1960 and again in 1961, and had since died.
In November 1964, at the 46th Golden Spike show, Ches A Luck won junior reining once more and was second in working cow horse. Nelda rode it to second place in a class the scan leaves unreadable.
Reining and bitting
The last trace in the papers comes from April 1966. A quarter horse clinic was set for Saturday, April 9, in the George Nelson Field House at Utah State University in Logan, for horse people from Utah, Idaho and the states around them. Among the afternoon sessions on the program was one on reining and bitting, to be given by D. T. (Sod) Williams of Arbon Valley.
Because the clinics are known only from notices printed ahead of time, the papers never say how the demonstrations went. Nor do they say whether these horses were foaled on the Williams ranch, or what became of Poco Star. At home he had valley business too: in 1965 he raised subscriptions in the drive to bring dial telephones to Arbon. In the show ring, though, he was the rancher from Arbon who came south with a good horse and, more often than not, went home with a ribbon.
Sources
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 19, 1956, page 22
- Tremonton Leader, June 5, 1958, page 8
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 21, 1959, page 12
- Tremonton Leader, September 8, 1960, page 12
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 11, 1960, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 12, 1960, page 8
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 14, 1960, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 15, 1961, page 36
- Deseret News, March 21, 1961, page 7
- Salt Lake Times, March 24, 1961, page 2
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 19, 1961, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 20, 1961, page 25
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 17, 1963, page 24
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, November 11, 1963, page 20
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 1, 1963, page 50
- Lehi Free Press, March 12, 1964, page 6
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 22, 1964, page 32
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 24, 1964, page 62
- Salt Lake Tribune, October 11, 1964, page 110
- Deseret News, October 13, 1964, page 24
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 16, 1964, page 17
- Logan Herald Journal, April 8, 1966, page 6