Ralph Knapp kept his plane down close to the ground while a helper fed seed into a hopper built for the purpose. In five hours the Pocatello pilot scattered 2,500 pounds of crested wheatgrass over 8,000 acres of rough grazing land in Power County, between Arbon and Rockland, which lies in the neighboring valley to the west. It is the earliest seeding from the air near the valley that this site has come across.
The Associated Press put the story on the wire from Pocatello on December 8, 1938, and the Ogden Standard-Examiner ran it on page 3 that same day as “Planting From Air is Newest Farm Wrinkle.” Knapp, the job done, counted it among his “strangest assignments.” The point of it, the story explained, was to hold the soil in place and grow feed for livestock.
The man who leased the land, Carl Rudeen, had the old way to compare it with. Sowing a mere 800 acres on horseback, he said, had once taken two weeks. He praised the seed as “a hardy clump grass good for stock forage,” one that asked for little water, got by in thin soil and caught readily among the rocks.
The grass was not new to the valley, only the scale. In the spring of 1936 the county agent had put in a small crested-wheatgrass demonstration plot on Walt Hayden’s farm, and by 1938 Walt was harvesting the grass, as the Hayden family history tells. Airplanes were not new either. The first one seen over the valley was a mail plane in 1929.
A wheat farmer of long standing
The 1938 story names Rudeen only as the leaseholder. It does not say who owned the range or exactly where the land lay, and it leaves the helper at the hopper unnamed. The older papers show a Carl Rudeen farming in this corner of Idaho from 1909 on. He is very likely the same man, though no article ties the two together.
That Carl Rudeen, then of American Falls, filed a homestead entry on ground south of American Falls on June 7, 1909. In 1914 he published notice of his final proof, the step in “proving up” at which a homesteader showed he had lived on and worked his claim and could take title to it. By 1917 he was also farming on the Fort Hall Reservation, which borders Arbon Valley on the north; Pauline and West Fork lie along its edge. That August the American Falls Press noted that he had driven into town from the reservation on a Tuesday evening for a load of sacks, having started that morning to thresh his Gold Coin wheat on the section he leased there.
He had a tinkerer’s side. In 1925 the same paper wrote up a blade weeder that Rudeen, “Power county farmer,” had patented after four years of trials, a five-section machine 30 feet wide that took eight horses to pull. In March 1927 he sat on the first committee of Arbon Valley wheat growers, with Ed England, William Allard, T. H. Hill and J. H. Keeler, who met at Pocatello to weigh building or buying a community warehouse for their grain. An organizing committee of Arbon Valley farmers in February 1930 listed a “Carl Ru-,” the rest of the name lost from the surviving text, who was probably Rudeen. By 1940 the papers placed him in Pocatello.
The scientists take a look
Fourteen months after the flight, on February 4, 1940, the Ogden Standard-Examiner carried a long piece on bringing worn-out range back across the Intermountain country. Its authors, George Stewart and C. Kenneth Pearse, worked at the Forest Service’s Intermountain Forest and Range Experiment Station. One photograph showed an abandoned dry farm grown up in weeds, which the caption called one of hundreds like it in the region.
Midway through, they came to Power County. Research workers were “watching with interest,” they wrote, the airplane seeding of 8,000 acres near Arbon by Carl Rudeen of Pocatello. To their eye it had been sown far too thin. They put the seed used at about 2,000 pounds, a little under the 2,500 the 1938 story gave, when that much land called for 40,000 pounds or more. That comes to roughly a quarter pound an acre, where their own figure works out to five pounds or better.
The airplane itself won no endorsement from them; one subheading read “Airplane Inadvisable.” It had drawn a good deal of attention as a way to spread seed over open range, they granted, but until more was learned, success would be luck unless the seed got covered. Bare seed lying on the surface had sunk many of the early attempts. The plantings that had worked were put in with drills or other careful methods, at a cost of $2.40 to $6 an acre for seed and labor together. The columns on that page run together in the digitized copy, so the wording and the figures here are assembled from fragments, and the printed page may differ in small ways.
Whether the grass on Rudeen’s range ever came up, no later report has yet said.
Sources
- American Falls Press, March 26, 1914, page 11
- American Falls Press, August 24, 1917, page 5
- American Falls Press, September 17, 1925, page 4
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 8, 1927, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, February 9, 1930, page 17
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, December 8, 1938, page 3
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, February 4, 1940, page 58