Tired of writing letters that changed nothing, the Fort Hall tribes rounded up the cattle themselves. On Thursday, March 2, 1972, tribal officials took more than 300 head off reservation range in the Bannock Creek district, the stretch of the reservation along the lower creek where it flows north out of Arbon Valley. The animals were trespassing, the tribes said, and the man they named as owner was D. T. “Sod” Williams, an Arbon rancher. The Idaho State Journal carried a short account on page 2 the next morning.
Readers of the horse-show columns knew the name. Donald Thayne Williams (1922–2001) and his wife, Nelda Ward Williams, kept a cattle ranch at Arbon and bred and trained quarter horses there, and the papers had followed them into the show ring and the rodeo arena for years, as told in Sod Williams of Arbon and his quarter horses and the Williams family in the arena. Nelda came from the valley’s Ward family. The 1972 story used the initials and nickname those columns had always used, so it is plainly the same man.
Acting on their own code
The tribes did not wait on Washington. They acted under the impounding section of their own law and order code, and the head of the Fort Hall Business Council, Kesley Edmo, told the paper they had done it for themselves, within their federal jurisdiction, and were “going to exercise our rights.” The tribal attorney, whom the paper did not name, said outsiders’ cattle wandered onto tribal ground so often that the tribes could not keep paying for it. The herd would stay where it was until the tribes were repaid for the harm to the range and for the expense of gathering and feeding the animals.
Part of the tribes’ frustration was aimed at the Bureau of Indian Affairs, which handled grazing leases on reservation land. When strangers’ stock got onto tribal range, the tribes complained, the bureau’s answer was a letter to the owner and nothing more. Ira Dutton, the acting superintendent at the Fort Hall agency, said that was all federal rules allowed. As he read Title 25 of the federal regulations, the bureau could impound livestock only when lives or property were in danger; for an ordinary trespass, notifying the owner was its whole remedy. The Tribal Council could ask to have stricter conditions written into the leases, he said, and it had been urged to turn to the impounding power in its own code. Of all the districts on the reservation, he said, Bannock Creek caused the agency the most trouble with cattle grazing where they had no business.
A defaulted lease
Asked about the land where the cattle were found, the tribal attorney said the lease belonged to Douglas Reed, who had defaulted on it. The paper did not say how the herd got there or whether Reed had any tie to Williams, and none should be supposed. Reed appears nowhere else on this site.
Range and reservation had long pressed against each other at that end of the valley. The country around Pauline and West Fork runs up to the reservation line, and that line moved more than once, first after the cession of 1898 and again when the government bought out the West Fork farms late in the 1930s. The Williams ranch likely included Thomas D. Daniels’s old Pauline homestead, as the Daniels family page explains, which would have put Williams range close to the line. The 1972 article did not say where the cattle came from. The creek and the district that bears its name have a longer history of their own, told in Pasakwa Huude and other names on Bannock Creek, and a dozen years earlier another valley cattleman had his own quarrel over grass in Lloyd Brower’s small range war.
The article ended by saying the owners meant to fight the tribes’ decision. It spoke of owners in the plural but named only Williams, and it gave no count of how many head were his and no figure for the damages. No later report has turned up, so how the dispute was settled, what was paid and when the cattle went home are still unknown.