Under a big boulder in the Bannock Creek district of the Fort Hall Reservation, a skeleton lay with an old long rifle beside it. In the spring of 1960 a Pocatello man offered a name for it: Old Yank, a trapper who had lived alone up the creek about a century before.
The Idaho State Journal put the question in a short item atop its front page on Wednesday, May 4, 1960, and Verla Ranstrom’s full story ran on page 14. Bannock Creek starts at the head of Arbon Valley and flows north past Arbon and Pauline, then on across the reservation, where the district along its lower reaches carries the creek’s name too.
Found on a rabbit hunt
Wilson Jack, a member of the tribes, was hunting rabbits in the summer of 1959 when he stumbled on the bones. He did not stop to look them over, and he said nothing about them until winter. Then he told his friend LaSalle Pocatello, also a tribal member, who passed the word to Willis Pankey, the Interior Department’s special agent at Fort Hall.
The first try at reaching the spot ended in deep snow. On Friday, April 29, 1960, reservation policeman John Moss went in with three other men and made it. The paper leaves the three unnamed, though Jack, Pocatello and Pankey seem the likeliest. The bones lay in a natural shelter, a hollow left where one large boulder had come to rest across other rocks.
The long rifle was with the skeleton. A little way off lay a rusted lever-action repeater. Worms had bored into the wood of one stock and eaten some of it away, but the repeater’s lever still worked and its brass receiver still shone. The men also picked up a powder horn, empty but with its tip still stoppered, a few glass beads, two large steel fish hooks with barbs, and scraps of leather and coarse cloth.
A trapper who would not leave
Harold E. Anderson of Pocatello took his idea from Trails of Early Idaho, the book his uncle, Ambrose C. Anderson, set down from the memories George W. Goodhart dictated to him. Old Yank turns up often in its pages. As the Journal summed up the book, he had trapped for the Hudson’s Bay Company and then spent many years alone up Bannock Creek, living “by a big spring in a big grassy flat.” Neighbors helped him out now and then, but none of them ever learned his real name. When they asked, he told them “Old Yank suits me fine.” The nickname was said to come from his northeastern way of talking, and people supposed he hailed from Maine.
When Goodhart saw him for the last time, the trapper was old and sick. Goodhart urged him to come back to the fort, and he would not go. He meant to die in that country, he said, and had his grave already dug on the hillside near his home, under a big tree.
Anderson leaned on the rest of the book’s picture. It describes a frail man who sometimes could not kill enough game to eat, so cut off that months could pass with no one coming by. A man like that, Anderson reasoned, might have felt death coming and crawled into the cave to meet it. The book’s own account points elsewhere, though, since the grave Old Yank chose was on a hillside, not under a rock.
The paper said nothing of whether the bones would be examined, and no later report has turned up telling whether they were identified or buried again. Nor did it say where in the district the cave was, how far up the creek the trapper’s spring and flat lay, or which fort Goodhart meant. Trails of Early Idaho itself has not been checked for this post, so all that is told here of Old Yank comes second-hand, through the 1960 story.
Names along the creek
The two tribal members likely turn up in other papers as well. A Wilson Jack spoke at a Christmas party at the Bannock Creek school in 1948, and when water ran over the Arbon road near Fort Hall in February 1963, the Journal counted the Wilson Jack place among those flooded. A LaSalle Pocatello chaired the tribal council in 1948. The names and the district match, though no report ties them together.
The creek has older names as well, gathered in Pasakwa Huude and other names on Bannock Creek. The reservation land along its lower course is the subject of When the Bannock Creek lands were allotted, 1911–1922 and The reservation next door. Travelers crossed the valley early, as told in Brigham Young’s company crosses Bannock Valley, 1857, and the valley’s own histories, among them the Buist account, have trappers and mountain men moving through Bannock Valley before any homesteader came.
Most of them moved on. If Goodhart remembered rightly, Old Yank stayed, by a spring somewhere along the creek that still carries the valley’s old name, whether up in the valley or down on the reservation no one can now say.