Sherm Swim and Melvin Neaman both ran cattle along Bannock Creek, the stream that flows north out of Arbon Valley past Pauline and onto the Fort Hall Reservation. In May 1978 they sat in the same federal courtroom in Pocatello, on opposite sides of one lawsuit, and each said that if the ruling went the wrong way he would have to sell cattle.
The case was about who would graze part of the Caribou National Forest that summer. Judge Marion J. Callister heard it over two days, Tuesday and Wednesday, May 9 and 10, and the Idaho State Journal carried it on its front page on the second day.
An old right on ceded land
The quarrel went back eighty years. In the agreement of 1898, which Congress ratified in 1900, the Shoshone and Bannock people gave up the south and east of their reservation. That cession opened Crystal and the country around it to homesteaders in 1902, as an earlier post in this series tells. The Journal reported that the Tribes kept a right to run livestock on the land they gave up, and part of that land later became the Forest Service’s Pocatello District.
For years the allotments in question had gone to non-Indian ranchers, who held Forest Service permits and paid so much a head to use them. In 1978 the agency agreed to open some of those allotments to Shoshone-Bannock cattle. The tribal stock would graze free, owing only the required improvements, and 522 head would go on. To make room, the same number of the permit holders’ cattle would have to come off.
The permit holders wanted the change put off a year and asked Judge Callister for an injunction. Everything turned on a $15 million settlement the Tribes had received in 1972 for the ceded lands. Max Whittier, the ranchers’ attorney, argued that the payment had covered the grazing rights, and pointed out that timber was the only right named as reserved. Karl Shurtliff, the U.S. attorney for Idaho, spoke for the Forest Service. In his view the Tribes had held back the grazing right for themselves in 1898, so the 1972 money never reached it. The ranchers, he added, had been warned in good time, and the agency had searched hard for other range.
The ranchers’ side
Four operators stood to lose forest range: Robert Swanson of Michaud Creek, Russell Hebdon of Chesterfield, the King Creek Cattle Association and Sherm Swim of Bannock Creek. Hebdon put the cost of hauling at $1.50 a mile for every loaded truck and told the court that cattle take two years to learn a new range. Swanson said his family had run stock on its Midnight Creek range since 1903 and had cleared no profit in recent years. For King Creek, Orville Demick said the association would lose forest grazing for 140 of the 214 head it usually ran.
Demick and Swim both spoke of the added expense of trucking cattle to range far from home. Swim’s permit carried 224 head, and 58 of them were to be moved. The new range offered was near Tincup Creek, east of Henry. Rather than truck them there, he said, he would sell the 58. All told he ran between 300 and 400 head.
The Tribes’ side
Neaman, 24, was a Shoshone-Bannock stockman from the Bannock Creek country in the southwest corner of the reservation. When he learned that tribal cattle would be allowed onto the forest, he borrowed from the tribe that spring and bought 60 head. His family’s 138 cattle grazed private and trust land. An injunction, he told the judge, would leave him no choice but to sell the 60.
Barbara Neaman, his sister-in-law, said the family was depending on forest range to grow its herds. To apply for it she had to give up the grazing permits she held from the Bureau of Indian Affairs.
When the testimony was done, Judge Callister gave both sides a week to file written briefs and five days more to answer each other. The papers read for this post do not say how he ruled, or whether Swim sold his 58 head.
The rancher from the reservation line
The 1978 story names him only as Sherm Swim of Bannock Creek. The details fit the Swim family so closely that he was almost certainly Sherman Hale Swim, born in 1923 to Bob and Nell Roper Swim. Bob Swim rented a ranch on Bannock Creek at the reservation line from the early 1930s, near Pauline and West Fork at the valley’s north end, and in 1950 Sherm was a stockman there.
Seven weeks after the hearing, on June 30, 1978, the Journal printed photographs of a branding at Sod and Nelda Williams’s ranch in Arbon Valley, and Sherm Swim was roping calves. In June 1980 the paper called him a 56-year-old Arbon Valley rancher, born and raised in the valley, running a Hereford operation with his son Kirk. He died in 2011, as the Stories page records. Melvin and Barbara Neaman are known to this site only from the 1978 article.
Before the court of appeals
The case outlived that spring. In January 1983 the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals decided appeals in Swim v. Bergland, named for Sherman Swim and for Robert Bergland, the Secretary of Agriculture. Swim’s name led a long list of non-Indian permittees, among them Michaud Creek Ranches, Russell and Sara Hebdon and the King Creek Grazing Association, and the Shoshone-Bannock Tribes joined as intervenor. The opinion begins by casting the appeals as a question of what grazing rights the permittees and the Tribes held on the Caribou National Forest under the treaty of 1868 and the agreement of 1898. This site has read only that opening and the list of parties, not the decision itself, so the outcome is not told here. The list also names a Norman Davis, a William T. Evans and a Calvin A. Munn. Those are valley surnames, but the court did not say where the men lived, and they are not identified here.
Bannock Creek has other stories, among them the names along the creek, and the valley had seen a fight over forest range before, in Lloyd Brower’s small range war. This one began with two neighbors from one creek, each hoping not to sell his cattle.