Joe Arbon already had what the Pocatello men were after. In the last week of January 1938 he told a chamber of commerce committee that a well on his Arbon Valley farm was putting water on 100 acres. The committee hoped to do the same on a far bigger scale out on the Michaud Flat, the dry stretch north of Arbon Valley between Pocatello and American Falls.
A committee of landowners
The plan came before the board of the Pocatello chamber of commerce on Monday, January 31, 1938, when the chamber’s reclamation committee met with the directors. F. M. Bistline, a Pocatello lawyer, led the committee. The paper named six other members, each of them an owner of ground on the flat: Postmaster Ambrose McGuire, Judge I. E. McDougall, Nicholas Ifft, Elmer Smith, Ben Davis and L. A. “Dutch” Lehrbas. Two Power County men sat in with them. One was Roy Lindley, chairman of the county commissioners. The other was Joe Arbon, a “prominent Arbon valley farmer,” as the Pocatello Tribune put it in a brief front-page item that same day. Pumped water, Arbon said, had served his valley farm well. Six days later the Sunday Tribune-Journal supplied the figure of 100 acres.
The Michaud Flat ran to something like 20,000 acres of sagebrush. About 9,000 of them had once been Indian land, bought by white settlers who counted on the Fort Hall irrigation project to reach them. The project came up short, the water never arrived, and the buyers were, in the Sunday paper’s phrase, “left holding the bag.” Those owners were the committee’s first hope for money, since water would lift the value of what they held. Bistline pointed to the country north of Pocatello for proof: its farms had been bare sagebrush until irrigation reached them.
Down to 500 feet
Eight wells had already been sunk on the flat, four of them by the government. They ran from 80 feet at the municipal airport to 128 feet at the Bannock Creek siding, and in none of them, Bistline said, did the water stand deeper than 43 feet. The committee planned a 20-inch well to about 125 feet, with a six-inch test hole bored from its bottom on down to 400 or 500 feet.
The job would cost from $750 to $2,000, to be paid with gifts from flat landowners and from any person or company willing to give. Bistline put the yearly price of water at $2.50 to $5 an acre. He made no promises. He called the venture “a big speculation” and said the committee hoped no one would come out behind if the well came up dry.
Which Joe, and what well
The papers never said which Joe Arbon spoke. Joseph N. Arbon, longtime bishop of the Arbon Ward, was 62 that year. His son Joseph G. Arbon was 30 and, by the family’s account, had worked the ranch beside his father and lived in his parents’ house since marrying in 1929. “Prominent” sounds more like the father, but either man could have spoken for the farm. The site’s pages on the Arbon family tell more of both Joseph N. Arbon and Joseph G. Arbon.
Water was nothing new on the ranch. The family says George Arbon and his son Joe helped dig the first irrigation ditch out of Knox Canyon in the 1890s, and the land records show that the 320 acres Joe entered under the desert-land law in 1902 became the irrigated heart of the place. A well was another matter, raising water from below ground instead of bringing it down from a canyon. Of this one the papers told nothing more: not where it stood in the Arbon area, how deep it reached, what powered the pump, when it went in or what the 100 acres grew.
The commissioner
The papers called him simply Roy Lindley of Power County. He was almost certainly Roy D. Lindley, who homesteaded south-east of Arbon and got his patent in 1914; this site has found no other Roy Lindley in the county. The site’s story of his 1937 letter about golden eagles puts his commission years at probably 1929 to 1935, yet the Tribune still called him a commissioner in February 1936. That month a member of an Arbon Valley road crew was injured, and Lindley hauled him six miles out by sleigh, then borrowed a mail truck to get him the rest of the way to Pocatello. By January 1938 he chaired the board.
Water in 1939
The Tribune had the result on its front page on April 7, 1939. A new well on the flat was giving 600 gallons a minute, Bistline said, enough by his reckoning for 60 to 65 acres. The paper credited three men with pushing the project through the past year: Bistline, Lindley and Paul Evans of American Falls. Nothing links this Paul Evans to the Evans family of Arbon, and the April report can be read as placing Lindley at American Falls too, so whether he still lived at Arbon is unclear. The papers do not say where the well was drilled or how deep, or state outright that it was the test well planned in 1938, though it most likely was. Its backers hinted at more wells to come, and the paper repeated a guess that the flat might one day support 2,500 families.
Lindley explained why they had expected water, and his reasoning led straight back to Arbon Valley. Government reports the men had gone over with care, he said, showed water gathering underground beneath the flat, draining north into it from the Bannock Creek and Arbon Valley country. He weighed what came off those two watersheds against the rise of the American Falls reservoir and concluded that little of it ever reached the Snake River. The remainder, he reasoned, was stored under the flat. In 1939 that land was good only for grazing stock, but Lindley believed full development could someday make it worth as much as $500 an acre.
What came of the Michaud Flat plan after that spring lies beyond these papers. The water the Pocatello men went looking for, by Lindley’s account, had come from Arbon Valley in the first place, the same valley where Joe Arbon was already pumping it onto his fields.