The first step was a purchase order. On the day before Thanksgiving, 1937, the Pocatello Tribune reported that Bannock County had spent $1,977 on culvert and pipe for the Mink Creek road, the valley’s short way north over the range to town.
The commissioners wanted the road, which the paper called the Bannock highway, moved onto a new line that could be kept open through the snow, so that Pocatello and Arbon Valley would never be cut off from each other. Two firms shared the order. The R. Hardesty Manufacturing company was to supply 1,516 feet of culvert for $1,008. A Pocatello firm, the Clark Concrete Construction company, would furnish 1,700 feet of concrete pipe at 57 cents a foot, or $969, which brings the two orders to the full sum. The valley was not the only place to gain. The short item, run under the heading “County Purchases Road Materials,” also counted the forest service’s Mink Creek station in the Cache National Forest and the new winter sports grounds. It named no county official and set no starting date.
Over the next nine months the Tribune followed that road and a second one, the route east through Garden Creek Gap toward Robin. Both were straightened and regraded in the same seasons, each under its own arrangement.
Three partners on Mink Creek
The road had already served for years as the valley’s mail route to town, as an earlier post tells, and its canyon stretch lay in Bannock County. On December 7 the plan reached the Tribune’s front page. County Commissioner W. H. Jensen called it a joint undertaking of the county, the forest service and the state. Work would begin at the road’s first ford of Mink Creek and head south. The county would handle the groundwork: culverts, changes to the ditches and a first coat of surfacing. The state would lay the finished grade and maintain the road once it was done.
Plenty of people besides valley farmers drove it, the paper observed. Skiers bound for the new winter sports area at the forks of Mink Creek used the road, as did Boy Scouts and Girl Scouts heading to camp and picnickers at several smaller recreation spots up the forks.
By February 1938 crews were realigning the section between the canyon mouth and the forest boundary. The Tribune columnist who signed as Ing wanted more than that. In the “Buzz of the Burg” column of February 9, Ing asked for an oiled surface at least to the Power County line, complained of summer dust and of repairs forever put off until the following year, and reminded readers that no route from the valley to town was shorter.
The Sunday Tribune-Journal checked in on July 3, by which time the work was described as a three-mile realignment. A. G. Nord, the Logan man in charge of the Cache National Forest, pledged continued help from his service. The labor now came from a Civilian Conservation Corps camp, and four forest service tractors were roughing out the new line. The state highway department had taken on everything else on the Bannock County section, from buying right-of-way and setting culverts to fencing, grading and surfacing. Nord said 2.3 miles of rough cut were finished and expected the rest before the end of July. That division of the work differed from the one Jensen had laid out in December, and the papers never explained the change.
Wheat waiting at the head of the valley
On July 25 Jensen took up the cause of the farmers at the upper end of the valley, most likely the Crystal and Rattlesnake Creek country, though the paper did not say so. The high basin there is described in the Crystal area history. Jensen had discussed a better link to Mink Creek with Claude Bistline, head of the Pocatello chamber of commerce, and with W. L. Hansen, the district forest ranger, who promised to take the idea to Nord. The trouble was mud. The stretch the paper called an extension of East Fork canyon could not be traveled when wet and needed chiefly grading and gravel, and Jensen offered the county’s road machinery to do it.
There was little time. Growers up there expected to start trucking some 40,000 bushels of wheat within about a month. If the Mink Creek link was not ready, they could use the unfinished Garden Creek Gap road or drive 20 miles of dirt across the reservation to the Pocatello–American Falls highway at Schiller. The valley’s long fight over that reservation route is the subject of another post.
Cutting through the gap
The Garden Creek Gap news ran on that same July page. County surveyor W. P. Havenor said the job was nearly done. The road was one of the valley’s main connections to Portneuf Valley, and the gap’s scenery drew hundreds of sightseers a year. The heavy work of cutting rock and building fills was largely behind the crew, Havenor said, and what remained was widening the roadway and knocking down a few high places. The foreman’s surname was Hall; his first name is illegible on the page.
On August 12 the crew was building a dirt fill, and Havenor, by then called county engineer, expected cars to be crossing it in seven to ten days, with finishing work to follow for some time. He counted it among the best WPA jobs in the county. A mountain range divides Arbon Valley from the Robin district, and the road runs along a fault line that cuts through it. Thousands of tons of rock had been pulled off the slope, by Havenor’s estimate, to flatten the grade and take out the curves.
None of the reports named a single valley resident, and the pages read for this post do not say when either road was finished, whether the state took over the Mink Creek road as promised, or whether the East Fork stretch got its gravel before the 1938 wheat moved. The canyon road had a hard history of its own; the Arbon stage in Mink Creek recalls a 1925 wreck on the old line. And the gap stayed a winter hazard, as skis and a weasel at Crystal shows with a Rattlesnake rancher snowed in there in 1949.
Not long before, there had been no road through the gap at all. In a 1946 letter to the Tribune, N. S. Coffin of Lava Hot Springs wrote that no one passed through it before 1912, when the saying went that “a crow couldn’t fly through the Garden Creek gap.”