Some fields along lower Bannock Creek never got a drop of water in the summer of 1935. On August 1 the Fort Hall agency answered by sending orders up the creek: the white settlers at its head were to quit taking water that belonged to the Indians below them.
Bannock Creek starts in the hills of Arbon Valley and flows north past Pauline onto the Fort Hall Reservation, where families of the Bannock Creek district farmed its lower reaches. One stream had to serve both ends, and that hot year it fell short.
The quarrel was an old one. Early in the century the United States had sued the upstream ranchers on the Tribes’ behalf, and the decree handed down on April 9, 1907, in United States v. Daniels confirmed that the Tribes held the earliest priority and fixed how much each settler ditch could draw. The 1935 orders never cite that decree, but the older rights they rested on were very likely the ones it laid down. The site’s Stories entry notes that the decree still governs the creek.
Planning for a fair share
The season opened hopefully. On Sunday, March 31, 1935, the creek’s water users gathered at Frank Fisher’s home and, with help from district farm agent C. S. De Armond, organized themselves; the Tribune gave the new group’s name as the “Bannack Creek Waterusers’ Association.” Mike Pocatello became president, Pierce Yupe vice president and Jack Ramsay secretary, and a second meeting was set for April 12 to work out a rotation for the water.
A rotation mattered because the reservation’s part of the creek had no reservoir. Those farms depended on the natural flow, which came from snowmelt in the high country where the creek rises. The snowpack from the winter of 1934–35 was reported as roughly normal, and the irrigators hoped that careful sharing would carry them through to harvest. The paper did not identify Frank Fisher. A man of that name was among the new settlers of Arbon in 1912, though nothing ties the two together.
On Wednesday morning, May 15, Superintendent F. A. Gross of the Fort Hall agency toured the Bannock Creek district to look at irrigation. With him went T. C. Guyn, the engineer over the irrigation project; Charley Peterson, who chaired the tribal council; Ralph Dixey of the advisory committee; and several others. Gross came away expecting the district’s farms to have enough water and to raise good crops.
A crop all but lost
By the first of August that outlook was gone. Gross’s office mailed its orders to the upstream settlers that Thursday, and a short dispatch from Fort Hall carried the news into the Tribune the same day. The agency stood on priority: the Indians along the creek held the senior rights, and the upstream users were to give back whatever part of that water they had been taking.
H. A. Ireland, the agency’s extension director, explained why. Some ground on the creek had gone the entire season unwatered, he said, and other fields had received so little that their crops failed. Heat and short water together had left the district’s grain very nearly a total loss. The paper closed with a secondhand report, credited to no one, that the settlers at the head of the creek had been taking two-thirds of its flow. Who measured that, if anyone did, was not said.
No settler was named, and the article counted no farms at either end of the creek. Under the 1907 decree the settler rights belonged to valley families on upper Bannock and Rattlesnake creeks, the Daniels, Lusk and Bolingbroke families of the West Fork and Pauline end among them, but the reports found do not say who was actually irrigating in 1935. Nor do they say how the orders were to be enforced, how the upstream users responded, whether more water came down the creek after August 1, or what the Bannock Creek harvest finally amounted to.
The quarrel had deep roots in the valley’s history, from the 1898 cession and the valley’s first irrigation ditch to the allotment of the Bannock Creek lands. In these same years Arbon farmers were also hauling grain over a wheat road across the reservation. More about the upper end of the creek is in the history of Pauline and West Fork.
The following spring brought shovels instead of orders. On March 12, 1936, the Tribune reported that Emergency Conservation Work crews at Fort Hall, together with the Indian irrigation service, would ready four small reservation irrigation systems before the season opened. Bannock Creek was one of them, and its ditches were to be cleaned and its headgates mended in time for the next year’s water.