Early in September 1911, E. E. Zaring brought a sample of alfalfa into American Falls from W. A. Nunnelly’s ranch at Arbon, as the paper spelled the Nunnelley name. It was second cutting, grown on dry land, and it stood thirty-three inches tall. The American Falls Press called it the finest dry-land alfalfa seen in town that year and declared that Nunnelley was “certainly entitled to the blue ribbon on dry land alfalfa.”
It was the kind of proof the town had been asking the outlying districts for since 1908, when it held its first Farmers’ Day.
A show for newcomers
Each fall from 1908, American Falls put on Farmers’ Day, a display of the district’s crops meant to show newcomers what the country could grow. Arbon lay some thirty miles southeast by the roads of the day. Both places were then in Oneida County; Power County was not created until 1913. Most of Arbon’s wheat was dry-farmed, raised without irrigation, and from the first show dry-farm products competed for a prize of their own.
The first Farmers’ Day came on September 30, 1908. The Press promised about $200 in prizes, a speech by Senator Heyburn, a steer roasted in a pit, and sports running from broncho busting to a greased pig. Arbon had a hand in the judging. Joseph Arbon of Arbon, one of the Arbon family, was among five grain judges, and Mrs. David Bolingbroke of Arbon was among five women picked to judge dairy products, preserved fruits, pastries and house plants. She was probably Mary Ellen Thomas Bolingbroke of the Bolingbroke family. Homer Pease of Rockland took first prize for wheat.
Not a single product
In June 1909 David Burrell, the United States commissioner at American Falls, agreed to assemble a showing of the district’s dry-farm products for the Dry Farming Congress at Billings, Montana, in October. Arbon was among the places asked for samples, and the Blackfoot Idaho Republican printed the appeal as well. Arbon was slow to answer. In August the Press, still calling for products for a permanent display in Burrell’s office, named the districts that had sent nothing at all: “Up to the present neither Rockland, Landing, Neeley nor Arbon have a single product on display.” Before long, it warned, there would be nothing left growing in the country to see, and a community without an exhibit “will suffer in comparison with others that have been more thoughtful.” Whether any Arbon samples ever reached Billings is not known.
That September Farmers’ Day got a permanent association, and T. B. Evans of Arbon, of the Evans family, was one of its five vice-presidents. He held the place again in 1910, with E. E. Zaring of American Falls as president. In August 1910 the association offered prizes for displays from whole districts, if enough districts cared to compete, and the Press pressed the Arbon valley to put together “a creditable display.”
Twenty-seven inches, then thirty-three
By 1911 the valley had something to show. In July the Press asked Arbon and the other districts to set aside grain samples for an exhibit train touring the East, “to show that good grain is the rule, and not the exception.” On August 8, samples came into town from W. S. Hays’s ranch at Arbon: alfalfa from a spring seeding on dry land that measured twenty-seven inches, and wheat at thirty-one. The paper took the alfalfa as “its own evidence of the fertility of the soil and its capacity to store and retain moisture.” The grower was probably Willis S. Hays, whose homestead toward the south end of the valley was patented in 1912.
Nunnelley’s sample, a month later, was taller still. The Press noted that both growers had come into the valley within the past three years, and it saw in their hay “possibilities along the feed line that were little dreamed of a few years ago.” The Nunnelley place, the paper said, was about average for the valley: high ground with no swampy land, and water some hundred feet down. The sample was to go into a permanent exhibit, and the Caldwell farm paper, the Gem State Rural, reprinted the item on October 1.
W. A. Nunnelley had moved his family onto homesteads at the Summit end of the valley in August 1909, and by the family’s account they came through a hard first winter. In September 1911 his barley looked good for a little over forty bushels an acre.
The fourth Farmers’ Day was called for September 28, 1911, in the Odd Fellows hall at American Falls, with a premium for the best showing of dry-farm alfalfa. The Press reported that Ellsberry’s store would give a Star hat for the best dry-land alfalfa, though the paper’s own list of special prizes put the hat under fruit. Such shows, it wrote, had given “object lessons which homeseekers could not ignore.” Whether Nunnelley or Hays entered is not recorded.
Farmers’ Fair
In August 1912 the American Falls Board of Trade renamed the association the Farmers’ Fair, made David Burrell president and picked a director for each farming district. Arbon’s director was a Ripley, printed H. H. Ripley one week and B. Ripley the next; most likely he was D. B. Ripley, whom the Press placed at Arbon in 1911 and 1913. Crystal’s director was W. C. Snyder, whose homestead at Crystal had been patented in 1910. The fair, the Press explained, was “not alone a contest to see who can raise the biggest pumpkin or cabbage, but rather a get together party.”
After the fair in late September, the paper listed the district’s delegates to the International Dry Farm Congress at Lethbridge, Alberta, that October. Joseph Arbon, a grain judge at the first Farmers’ Day, was one of them. In September 1913 Governor Haines named him among Idaho’s delegates to the following congress, at Tulsa, Oklahoma, and named Mrs. Joseph Arbon to the International Congress of Farm Women meeting alongside it. No report of whether they made the trip has been found.
Nor has any record turned up of an Arbon grower taking a ribbon at the show itself. The prize reports found for these years name winners from Rockland, Landing, Igo, Pleasant Valley and around American Falls, but the fuller lists printed after most shows are missing. The earliest prize this site has found for valley wheat came later, to John H. Bullock at the Idaho Seed Show in December 1914, as told in the first valley wheat at a world’s fair. In the paper’s columns, though, Nunnelley had already earned his blue ribbon in 1911, with second-cutting hay that stood thirty-three inches on dry ground.
The original article
American Falls Press, September 7, 1911, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
[illegible] SECOND CUTTING
Sample of Second Cutting Sent in from [illegible] Thirty Three Inches.
The finest sample of dry land alfalfa which has been seen here this year was brought in from W. A. Nunnelly’s ranch, at Arbon the last of the week, by E. E. Zaring. It is second cutting, which makes it a particularly fine sample. It measures thirty three inches in height, the color is perfect, and the plant vigorous and healthy in every way. It is the second splendid sample of dry land alfalfa which Arbon has contributed this year, both by people who have gone into the valley withi the past three years, and indicate possibilities along the feed line that were little dreamed of a few years ago. One cutting of such hay as the sample would justify every dry farmer in the valley to seed a good acreage, and when two cuttings can be secured it makes the most profitable crop he can grow. Mr. Nunnelly is certainly entitled to the blue ribbon on dry land alfalfa. The sample will be added to a permanent exhibit and may possibly result in doing the section where it was grown a great deal of good. The Nunnelly place represents about an average of the Arbon valley. It is high and contains no swampy land, and the distance to water is in the neighborhood of 100 feet.
Sources
- American Falls Press, September 19, 1908, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 21, 1908, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 19, 1909, page 1
- Idaho Republican, July 30, 1909, page 6
- American Falls Press, August 14, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 14, 1909, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 4, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 13, 1910, page 1
- Gem State Rural (Caldwell), September 1, 1910, page 18
- American Falls Press, September 10, 1910, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 11, 1911, page 6
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, August 10, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 7, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 14, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 21, 1911, page 1
- Gem State Rural (Caldwell), October 1, 1911, page 32
- American Falls Press, August 15, 1912, page 8
- American Falls Press, August 22, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 3, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 3, 1912, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 11, 1913, page 8
- Idaho Republican, September 26, 1913, page 3
- Homestead patent to William C. Snyder, March 10, 1910 (IDBL 0002301)
- Homestead patent to Willis S. Hays, December 7, 1912 (IDBL 0005950)
- Homestead patent to Walter A. Nunnelley, July 7, 1915 (IDBL 0005798)
- Homestead patent to Mamie Nunnelley, July 7, 1915 (IDBL 0005799)
