Dr. R. F. Noth went to wake his brother on the morning of Wednesday, September 27, 1911, and found the bed empty. He telephoned the Hooker residence, where Mattie Nunnelley boarded, and learned that she too was gone. She had packed her trunks, settled her board and left. Before the day was out, American Falls knew the rest: the two had boarded train No. 6 together, bound in the end for Chicago.
“Surprised Their Friends,” the American Falls Press headed the story the next day. Word was that the couple had got off at Pocatello to be married and then caught another train east. Nobody had been told a thing.
From the homestead to the store
Mattie came from the Kentucky Nunnelleys, whose first winter in the valley is among the site’s Stories. Her father, W. A. Nunnelley, brought the family out to their Arbon valley homesteads on Tuesday, August 10, 1909, the Press reported that Saturday. A few lines away on the same page, it noted that Iva Burrell had given up her place in the dry goods department at the Evans Mercantile company: “Miss Mattie Nunnelley is her successor.” The store was owned by the Evans family of American Falls, who were not the Evans families of Arbon.
So her father and sisters took up land at the south end of the valley, which then lay wholly in Oneida County, while Mattie kept her job in town. By 1911 she was the store’s cashier. That April she was picked as one of the alto soloists when the Episcopal and Presbyterian choirs joined for a Palm Sunday cantata, and in July she went out to Arbon for a visit. In September the paper paid her father a compliment: “Mr. Nunnelly is a successful dry farmer.” The Press spelled the name Nunnelly throughout its wedding story, too.
Herman Noth had been to American Falls before, around 1908 and again in 1910, to see his brother, Dr. Richard F. Noth, a physician there. By 1911 he was working in Oregon for the O.-W. R. & N., the Oregon-Washington Railroad & Navigation Company. He arrived on Friday, September 22, meaning to spend a few days with the doctor before going on to see his parents in Wisconsin. Five days later he left, and Mattie went with him.
“May all the joys of life be theirs”
The paper took the news warmly. It called Mattie one of the town’s most popular young women, “of a cheerful sunny disposition,” and the daughter of “one of the leading citizens of Arbon.” Everyone had expected the two to marry someday, it said; no one had expected it that week. On page 4 the same issue named Roll Evans as the new cashier at the Evans Mercantile and allowed that he “can not hope to be as popular as his predecessor.”
The Pocatello wedding was only something “said,” and the papers read for this post do not show where or when the marriage was recorded.
A ranch at Arbon
In June 1913 the couple were living in American Falls, and Mattie’s sister Virginia, “of the Arbon valley,” came to stay with them for a month. That year Virginia went to Salt Lake City to train as a nurse at the Holy Cross hospital.
On June 30, 1914, word reached American Falls that the Noth brothers’ mother had died at Medford, Oregon. Dr. Noth sent his car out to Arbon for Herman, who was to take her body home to Wisconsin. By December the paper could say he had been farming at Arbon for the past year.
After that the Herman Noths turned up in the South Arbon news from the Highland neighborhood at the south end, where Mattie’s family lived. On September 9, 1915, the South Arbon column reported that Mrs. Gus Brahmstadt had the couple to dinner along with Albert Noth and Mattie’s sisters Mamie, Virginia, Irene and Thelma Nunnelley, and that the doctor and his wife came out from town to spend a Sunday with them. Before Thanksgiving, by the North Arbon column, Herman hauled a load of turkeys to Pocatello. That fall the Highland school was built on Mamie Nunnelley’s land. The same year a new telephone line brought Dr. Noth out to the valley, and in 1916 came the Nunnelley sawmill fire.
In June 1918 Virginia and Mrs. R. F. Noth went out to see Mr. and Mrs. Herman Noth at Arbon, and the Press reminded its readers that the younger Mrs. Noth “was formerly Miss Mattie Nunnelly.” That October, with the doctor sick with influenza, Virginia was called from Salt Lake to help nurse him.
The winter of 1919
On Saturday, January 18, 1919, Herman, Mattie and their son drove down from Arbon to the doctor’s house. Herman went back the next day to see to his stock, and his wife and son stayed on with Dr. and Mrs. Noth. The Arbon column in early February still had Mattie visiting there.
She died at the doctor’s home on Saturday, February 22, 1919, after about ten days of illness, at the age of 28. The paper did not name the illness. She left her husband, two small children, her father and four sisters, Virginia, Mayme (Mamie), Irene and Thelma. All four were nurses, and they had helped care for her to the end. She was a Baptist. Her obituary recalled her years in American Falls before her marriage and the years since, spent with her husband “at Arbon on a ranch.” The funeral was held from the Noth home on the Monday afternoon, and a male quartette sang.
In October the Press reported the funeral of “little Richard Noth,” Herman’s eight-month-old son, who had died at Logan, Utah. Relatives had looked after him since his mother’s death, and he had been ailing for months. He was buried at American Falls. The papers read for this post do not name the couple’s other child or tell what became of Herman Noth and the ranch after 1919.
At Christmas 1913, two years after the couple’s hurried departure, the valley held its own earliest wedding on record. More of Mattie’s people can be found in the Summit area history and the Nunnelley family album. The Press had wished the young couple all the joys of life in 1911. They had a little more than seven years together.
The original article
American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
SURPRISED THEIR FRIENDS
Herman Noth and Miss Mattie Nunnelly United in Marriage
Herman Noth and Miss Mattie Nunnelly quietly packed up and left on No. 6, yesterday morning, their ultimate destination being Chicago. It is said they stopped off at Pocatello and were married taking No. 18 for the east. Their friends were given no intimation of what was coming.
Whn Dr. Noth went to call his brother yesterday morning he found his bed unoccupied. He immediately telephoned to the residence of Mr. Hooker, where Miss Nunnelly was staying and was told that she had packed her trunks, paid her board and left. It was later learned that the couple departed on No. 6.
Miss Nunnelly was one ofthe most popular young ladies in American Falls being of a cheerful sunny disposition, easily making friends. She is the daughter of W. A. Nunnelly, one of the leading citizens of Arbon. She was employed as cashier for the Evans Mercantile Company and has a wide aquaintance.
Mr. Noth is in the employ of the O.-W. R. & N., in Oregon, and came in last Friday for a few days’ visit with his brother, Dr. Noth. He had transportation for Chicago, and was en route home on a visit with his parents, in Wisconsin.
The young people are both popular, and all their friends are ready to extend congratulations at the earliest opportunity. Their marriage was confidently looked to as a future event, but no one expected it at this time. May all the joys of life be theirs.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 14, 1909, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 10, 1910, page 4
- American Falls Press, April 1, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 4
- American Falls Press, September 21, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 28, 1911, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 12, 1913, page 6
- American Falls Press, August 7, 1913, page 8
- American Falls Press, July 2, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, December 3, 1914, page 5
- American Falls Press, September 9, 1915, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 2, 1915, page 3
- American Falls Press, June 21, 1918, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 22, 1918, page 4
- American Falls Press, January 24, 1919, page 7
- American Falls Press, February 7, 1919, page 6
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1919, page 1
- American Falls Press, October 10, 1919, page 5
