In the summer of 1967 Arbon Valley sent out word that it wanted its people back. A brief item in the Logan Herald Journal on Monday, July 10, asked everyone who had once lived in the valley southwest of Pocatello, and everyone whose mother or father had, to gather in the Arbon Valley chapel at 7:30 on a Friday evening. Supper would be barbecued beef “and all the trimmings,” for a modest price.
That Friday was most likely July 14. The machine-read (OCR) text of the notice runs together with wire copy, so nothing further can be pulled from it, and no account of how the evening went has turned up. Forty-three years on, in 2010, an Arbon Reunion once more invited anyone with roots in the valley. Whether any were held in the decades between, the papers read do not show.
The 1967 notice named nobody. Yet obituaries and profiles from 1966 through 1969 trace five families who had taken up valley land before 1920, and they show how some scattered far and others never went very far at all.
From Crystal to Pocatello
Herbert Culbertson turns up first in the Crystal news of the American Falls Press in November 1917, when he and his wife called on her mother, Mrs. Hottel. By August 1918 his name stood on Power County’s Red Cross honor roll of men in uniform. In September 1925 the county listed H. H. Culbertson’s Crystal township land for unpaid taxes, a few years before drought and debt emptied most of Crystal and Buist.
He died in a Pocatello hospital on November 6, 1966, at 77. The Salt Lake Tribune called him Henry H. Culbertson and wrote that he was a native of Muncie, Indiana, that he had married Jaretha Hottel and homesteaded in Arbon Valley, and that, so far as the garbled text can be made out, he worked for the Pocatello schools until 1941 and then at the Naval Ordnance Plant until retirement. The first name does not match, but the initials, the Crystal land and the Hottel bride make it very likely the same man.
A farmer and musician
Lorenzo H. Bailey, whose life is told in his family history and among the Bailey family, once stood to lose much of his land. In the fall of 1923 the American Falls Press carried the sheriff’s notices of a mortgage foreclosure sale of land belonging to Lorenzo and Chloa Bailey, among it 480 acres and three shares of Arbon Irrigation Company stock. How the sale came out the papers read do not say, though in 1925 land under his name still appeared on the county’s list of delinquent taxes.
He died in a Pocatello hospital in May 1967, at 87, and the Deseret News and the Salt Lake Tribune remembered him as a onetime Arbon Valley farmer and a musician. By then his sons lived in Nampa, Lava Hot Springs and Arbon Valley, his daughters in Pocatello, Idaho Falls and other Idaho towns, and there were 35 grandchildren. Both obituaries put his birth in 1879, on December 13 by the Deseret News and December 12 by the Tribune; the family history has December 12, 1880.
The bishop’s son
Milton M. Evans was a son of Lorenzo B. Evans, once bishop of the Arbon ward, and his wife Anna, part of the Evans family whose story is told under Lorenzo Bowen Evans. In March 1920 the Central school notes in the American Falls Press reported a debate among the seventh and eighth graders over whether the barnyard wasted more than the kitchen. A Milton Evans, very probably this one, argued alongside Edna Bailey, Fern Bullock and Willis Bullock for the barnyard, against Margaret Allard, Constance Evans, Earl Ripley and Walter Evans, and his side carried it.
He married Mary Dalpino on December 15, 1928. When his father died in May 1934, the Pocatello Tribune counted nine children, four of them at Arbon, four in Pocatello with Milton among them, and one in Malad. Milton died in a Pocatello hospital on September 10, 1968, at 63. The Deseret News gave his birth as November 4, 1904, at Arbon and said he was shop foreman for J. R. Simplot’s in Pocatello. His brothers and sisters had spread to Bannock Creek, Pocatello, Lava Hot Springs and as far as Nevada, but one sister, Anna, Mrs. Arch Orison, still lived at Arbon.
A cabin southwest of Arbon
In November 1917 the American Falls Press’s traveling farm correspondent, who signed himself “the Pilgrim,” visited R. Thyberg on a quarter section five and a half miles southwest of the Arbon post office. Thyberg told him that five years before he had felled the logs, hauled them in and raised his cabin by himself, while his wife and children stayed in the cabin of her brother, Richard Iverson.
Devere Thyberg, born at Arbon on September 23, 1913, to Rudolph and Martha Jane Iverson Thyberg, very probably grew up in that household. The Deseret News of October 8, 1969, reported his death in a Pocatello hospital at 56 after a long illness. He had worked for Hawkes Transfer and for the P.F.E., probably the Pacific Fruit Express refrigerator-car line.
From Buist to Bountiful
In October 1911 the Logan Republican noted that Charles Hughes and a Miss Hughes had left for their homesteads at Buist, Idaho, most likely meaning Charles W. Hughes of Mendon. His son H. Preston Hughes was born that year. A 1969 profile in the Davis County Clipper recalled the family’s “true pioneer life” on the Arbon homestead, where Preston had three horses in his sole care before he turned twelve and the children rode four miles on horseback to an old schoolhouse of two rooms. Another son, Austin, was born at Arbon on November 2, 1918.
Around 1923 the family went home to Utah. On August 14, 1935, Charles W. Hughes, 54, was hit and killed by a Bamberger electric train south of Farmington. The Logan Herald Journal wrote that he had lived at Arbon before his twelve years in Centerville, and that his widow, Lettie, and the children Owen, Herman, Preston, Lois and Austin survived him.
Austin L. Hughes flew as a pilot in the Second World War and in Korea and later worked as a field superintendent for a construction firm. A heart attack took him on July 2, 1966, at 47, and Hill Air Force Base provided military rites at his burial in Bountiful. By 1969 Preston sat on the Bountiful city council and, as a bishop, had organized the Bountiful Sixth Ward.
Only for the Hughes family do the papers read give a clear date of leaving, and for none of the five do they give a reason. The 1967 invitation asked for neither. It wanted only that those who had gone, and their children, come back for one evening.
Sources
- Logan Herald Journal, July 10, 1967, page 2
- American Falls Press, November 30, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, August 23, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, September 17, 1925, page 6
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 9, 1966, page 30
- American Falls Press, October 4, 1923, page 7
- Deseret News, May 10, 1967, page 48
- Salt Lake Tribune, May 10, 1967, page 37
- American Falls Press, March 12, 1920, page 2
- Pocatello Tribune, May 31, 1934, page 5
- Deseret News, September 13, 1968, page 20
- American Falls Press, November 9, 1917, page 3
- Deseret News, October 8, 1969, page 49
- Logan Republican, October 21, 1911, page 5
- Davis County Clipper, November 21, 1969, page 20
- Logan Herald Journal, August 14, 1935, page 1
- Davis County Clipper, July 8, 1966, page 7