A little boy from Arbon Valley left his parents’ pickup in the dark early on Tuesday, October 3, 1967, and walked out onto Highway 30. He was two years old, and he did not live to see the morning.
He was LaGrande Shay, and his parents were Mr. and Mrs. Larson Shay, an Arbon Valley couple. The family had stopped at the Pilot House Cafe, about three miles west of Pocatello, and left LaGrande sleeping in the truck. State Policeman Jim Finch, who gave the Idaho State Journal its account, believed the child woke up on his own and wandered to the road with no one beside him.
At 12:40 a.m. Homer Watkins Jr., 30, of Pocatello, heading east, hit him with his car roughly 200 feet west of the cafe. Watkins told officers he had been going about 55 miles an hour and never saw the boy until he was standing in the middle of the pavement, too near to stop. His tires left skid marks 118 feet long. LaGrande was taken to St. Anthony Hospital in Pocatello, where he died of head injuries at 2:05. No charges were filed.
The Journal put the news on its front page that same afternoon, sharing a single story with a second death. On Monday afternoon Jose Aguirre, 17, of American Falls had been riding in a car that struck the right side of a half-ton truck from behind on Benton Street in Pocatello. Police said the truck had pulled out of one private drive and was turning into another a short distance along the street. All four people in the car, every one of them from American Falls, went to St. Anthony with injuries, and the paper listed head injuries as the cause of Aguirre’s death as well.
On October 6 the Journal ran a brief tally of Idaho’s latest traffic deaths. The boy is there as La Grande Shay, two, of Arbon Valley, with the Larson Shays as his parents, killed on Interstate 30-N west of Pocatello. With those deaths the state had lost 199 people on its roads in 1967, a dozen fewer than at the same point a year earlier.
Those two short reports are the whole of what the papers we have read tell about the family. They do not say where in the valley the Shays made their home, how long they had lived there, what took them out on the highway past midnight, or where LaGrande was laid to rest. The name Shay turns up in the valley’s records in other years, but nothing we have seen ties those people to this family, so we have not linked them. Anyone in the family or among the old neighbors who can fill in more is welcome to write through the contribute page, and the valley’s other losses are remembered on the Tragedies page.
For now, the record of LaGrande Shay is two newspaper columns and one line in a state count.