The buses left the Bannock Hotel in the half-light, around 6:30 on the morning of Tuesday, June 22, 1965, and climbed the Mink Creek road toward the divide. Waiting at Sportsmen’s Park in the canyon was breakfast for more than a hundred people, Pocatello townsmen and the farmers they had come to meet, and beyond it lay Arbon Valley.
It was the opening morning of Farm-City Week, the Pocatello Chamber of Commerce’s yearly effort to bring town and country to the same table. The road they took was an old link between the city and the valley; in the 1920s it had carried the Arbon mail.
Coffee pot and schedule
The Chamber’s agriculture committee had planned the morning. On June 17 the Journal ran a picture of three of its members gathered around a coffee pot: Everett Cole, who chaired the committee; Sam Briscoe, head of its farm-city subcommittee; and Elmer Terry, in charge of the breakfast. Every farmer, the notice said, would be paired with someone from the city, so that each might come away understanding the other’s troubles a little better.
Pocatello firms bought a large advertisement in the Sunday paper of June 20 to welcome the farmers and ranchers, with sponsors running from Bannock Machinery and Pocatello Flour Mills to Idaho Power and Kraft Foods. It laid out the plan: buses from the hotel at 6:30, breakfast up Mink Creek, and then a drive through Arbon Valley and Mink Creek once the plates were empty. The two notices disagreed by a quarter hour on breakfast, the first saying 6:30 and the advertisement 6:45. The week’s main event was to come on Thursday evening, June 24, a banquet in the hotel’s Cosmopolitan Room at 7 p.m. with Charles B. Shuman, head of the American Farm Bureau Federation, speaking on “Agriculture and the Business Community.” Shuman was coming in from a trip through Oklahoma and would stay only that night before going home to Chicago, and farm leaders from the upper Snake River country, Malad and the Magic Valley had already reserved seats.
Into the valley
The weather held clear. The paper thought a meal under the trees gave the gathering just the easy mood it wanted, and Cole called the morning “very encouraging.”
From the canyon the party went down into Arbon Valley, home to most of the farmers who had shared the tables. The first stop was Sod Williams’s ranch. The Journal spared him two sentences: his cattle operation turned a profit, and his quarter horses ranked him near the head of the region’s breeders. No 1965 report gives his full name, but he was almost certainly Donald Thayne “Sod” Williams of Arbon. The nickname, the ranch and the horses all fit the man this site follows through the Utah horse shows of 1956 to 1966 and, with his wife Nelda and their family, in the arena. Nelda was a daughter of Elmer and Susan Ward of the Ward family.
The next stop was Bannock Creek, where someone had proposed a dam. Standing at the site, the visitors heard the case for building it. The paper did not say where the spot was, whose plan it was or who made the case, and no other report of the proposal has turned up, nor any word of what became of it. By noon or so the morning was done. What the Journal counted as the real news was the turnout of businessmen, well above earlier years.
That mattered because the tours had not always drawn a crowd. In July 1958 the annual outing had set off from the summit of the Mink Creek divide, crossed part of the Arbon country and finished at Bannock Creek. Reviewing 1959 in its 1960 Progress Edition, the Journal reported that the agriculture committee had given up the farm tours that year, chiefly because they no longer seemed worth the trouble. Six years on, they were running again. The valley’s dry-farm slopes were changing in those same years, as told in contour strips and hillside combines, and its scattered communities were the farmers’ end of the bargain.
A guest writes in
Eight days later the paper heard from one of the guests. On June 30 the editorial-page column “Buzz of the Burg,” signed Ing, carried a letter from Ed Walter, who had cut out the front-page report and mailed it back. Reading it, he said, made plain that nobody from the Journal had gone along. The story had nothing at all to say about the first stop, the one he felt had taught him the most. He did not name it. The paper had listed the Williams ranch first without saying what was shown or said there, so he may have meant the ranch, but since its reporter never made the trip, he could just as well have meant a stop the paper left out entirely.
Walter described himself as a guest that day, new to Pocatello’s business circles but raised on a farm, and he praised one of the presentations warmly, though the letter as reported does not say whose. He called the paper’s silence “a brazen, ill-mannered oversight.” If he were one of the farmers who had worked to put on the tour, he wrote, he would decline to arrange another one for the businessmen, and the Journal ought to make it up to the farmers of Arbon Valley. Which farmers had organized the morning, the record does not say.
Ing answered in the same column. He had tried to reach Walter and failed, asking the telephone company, Idaho Power, the Chamber and the agriculture committee, none of whom knew where to find him; who Ed Walter was remains unknown. Ing himself had served on the committee for years and usually rode along, but he had been away from town that week. The paper’s reporter had stayed through breakfast and then raced back to the office to make that afternoon’s edition, so he never saw the tour. The column admitted the lapse and allowed that it was an awkward one, coming from a paper that had long faulted Pocatello businessmen for skipping these very tours. Next time, Ing promised, the farm tour would get better coverage.
For one morning, at least, the businessmen had shown up. It was the newspaper that stayed home.