In September 1843 an exploring party came down out of the Great Salt Lake country, crossed a high divide and followed a creek north toward Fort Hall. Its leader, John C. Fremont, called the stream the Pannack river. Today it is Bannock Creek, which heads at the top of Arbon Valley and flows north through the valley and the Fort Hall Reservation to the Snake. A century later, which pass Fremont had used to reach it became a quiet quarrel in the pages of the Pocatello Tribune.
A history in the Buzz column
In 1945 the Tribune’s “Buzz of the Burg” column was printing a serial history of Bannock County written by Dr. Minnie F. Howard of Pocatello. Fremont arrived in its fifty-fifth installment, on December 27, 1945.
Howard began that day with a roll of the figures she thought mattered most to Old Fort Hall. On the American side she listed Bonneville, Nathaniel Wyeth, Jason Lee, Marcus Whitman, John Sutter and Fremont. For the Hudson’s Bay Company she named Francis Ermatinger and Captain James (Johnnie) Grant, whose time at the post she put at 1843 to 1846. When Grant left, she held, an era closed. Until then neither Washington nor London ruled the Fort Hall country, and whatever law it had came from the company’s charter.
Fremont, a Georgian born at Savannah in 1813, was then on the second of the three journeys he led to the Pacific. President Tyler, Howard wrote, had sent him to learn the most practical routes to Oregon and to California, which was still Mexican soil, and Kit Carson was his guide. By her account the party rode behind that year’s great emigration as a kind of rear guard as far as Bear Lake, then split off to see the Great Salt Lake. Coming back north through Cache Valley, it crossed at Garden Creek Gap, followed Bannock Creek down and forded the Portneuf at Swanson’s ranch for the final miles to the fort. It never used the Portneuf canyon. Since Fremont described the fort’s white walls gleaming in the sun, Howard judged that he rode in before noon.
What Fremont wrote
Fremont’s own report, which the government printed in 1845, is generous with dates and stingy with place names. After fording a stream he named the Roseaux, the party worked up a long ravine to a pass on the divide between the Bear River and Snake River drainages. On the far side lay a valley four or five miles across, where a branch of the Pannack spread out into swamp, and they made camp there as night fell.
Around midday on September 17 they came to what he took for the main fork and followed the Pannack down through a valley about a mile and a half wide. His observation that night put camp at latitude 42° 44′ 40″. If the figure was close, they were on the lower creek, a good way north of present-day Arbon and Pauline.
Next morning, seven or eight miles on, they came out onto open plain with the “Three Buttes” in view some 45 miles off. Reaching the Portneuf, they looked down on a green, lightly timbered valley, and about four miles off, the white walls of the fort were “glistening” below them. On September 19, with snow coming down, Fremont rode in and bought horses and five oxen from Grant, the man in charge. Howard quoted that purchase under September 18, but the printed report puts it on the 19th.
The rest of her installment followed the party out. Fremont sent eleven men home from the fort, she wrote, because he doubted they would last through the coming winter. The others crossed the Portneuf in a downpour with the water up to the axles. Those axles belonged to the howitzer the expedition was dragging west, not to any wagon, and Fremont would leave the gun in the snow in country she placed in northern California. Her last point concerned wheels. None had yet gone on from Fort Hall toward California, she wrote, and the only wheels the fort had seen arrived with the emigrant train Whitman traveled with, a month before Fremont.
Roads to California
Howard had already gone beyond what Fremont put on paper. Ten days earlier, on December 17, she wrote that the Hudson’s Bay men at the fort wanted American wagons pointed toward California instead of Oregon, and she named the routes they favored: Raft River in 1843, then Bannock Creek in 1844 and 1845. On December 28, giving no year, she traced the course she said California wagons soon took out of the fort. They forded the Portneuf at the dugway below W. P. Havenor’s ranch, went up Bannock Creek, crossed a corner of Utah, struck the Humboldt in Nevada and finished beyond the Sierras at Sutter’s Fort. She cited no source for it, and nothing else we have read puts wagons on Bannock Creek in 1844 or 1845.
Havenor himself, the Bannock County surveyor, took up the story in the column on January 9, 1946, writing on the site of Old Fort Hall. He counted Fremont’s seven or eight miles as miles down Bannock Creek and set Fremont’s first sight of the fort on the bluff west of the Portneuf, along the trail coming over from the creek. Pairing that with Howard Stansbury’s view from much the same spot, which Havenor dated September 22, 1850, he concluded the fort could not have stood at the old stage station, printed as “The Dobles.”
A reader’s objection
N. S. Coffin of Lava Hot Springs, whose parents had taken up land in Marsh Valley in 1871, answered in a letter the paper ran on June 25, 1946. His main complaint was that Howard’s list of the county’s great roads had skipped the Sublette road. In passing he took on her gap. No traffic used Garden Creek Gap before 1912, he wrote, and until then people around there said not even a crow could get through it. On “all available evidence,” Coffin argued, Fremont had come over the divide into Hawkins Basin, a short way south of the gap.
He also handed on what Albert (Dock) Boyce, a freighter born in 1854, remembered of the Sublette road, the old emigrant route. By Boyce’s account it climbed Hawkins Basin to the divide, dropped to Rattlesnake Creek in the Crystal country, crossed to Bannock Creek and went west through Moonshine to Raft River. The Crystal area history tells more of that country, and the Summit area history covers where this site places the Hudspeth Cutoff. Coffin added that Mormon settlers traveling to and from Fort Lemhi between 1855 and 1858 had used the Malad and Bannock valleys.
Bannock Creek did become a highway in time. The Tribune recounted in 1944 and 1946 how freight wagons and stages running from Utah to the Montana mines came by way of Malad and down the creek toward Fort Hall, until William H. Murphy’s toll road through the Portneuf canyon opened a shorter, lower route in the middle 1860s. The creek has carried other names as well.
Still unsettled
Fremont never named his pass, and his account fits more than one way into the Bannock Creek drainage. Howard’s gap and Coffin’s basin were both guesses made a hundred years after the fact. The valley keeps a third version. The Arbon area history on this site, drawn from Laurie Jean Ward Call’s book Bannock Valley, has Fremont camping at the spring just north of Andersen Lane, and dates his visit to 1846, though his published report places his ride down the Pannack in September 1843. The newspapers never decided which crossing was his. The creek he followed down to the Snake runs the same way it did that September.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, December 27, 1945, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, December 17, 1945, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, December 28, 1945, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, January 9, 1946, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, June 25, 1946, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, June 6, 1944, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, July 1, 1946, page 4
- John C. Fremont, Report of the Exploring Expedition to the Rocky Mountains, Oregon and North California, 1845, journal for September 1843