Two guests nobody was expecting turned up at the Carl Wrensted farm on the Crystal route out of Arbon one Thursday in the summer of 1947. They were Mrs. Jeanette Pocatello and Mrs. Margaret Lavatta Calvin, and before they left they had told their hosts that the creek carrying the road over from Pocatello was named for Jeanette’s grandfather.
Mrs. Carl Wrensted thought the afternoon worth sharing. She wrote it up in a letter to “Buzz of the Burg,” the Pocatello Tribune column signed by Ing, and the paper ran it on Tuesday, August 19. The Thursday she had in mind was most likely August 14. Her letter is the only account of the visit that has turned up, so all that follows about the two women is what she heard and set down.
A long-promised trip
Jeanette had said for years that she would make the trip, but until that summer she had never come into Arbon Valley or over the hills that ring it. Mrs. Wrensted counted the surprise a welcome one. The guests were taken with the wheat, which stood heavy that year, and with how well the fields looked all around.
Both women were fresh off travels of their own. Mrs. Calvin had been up near Pinedale, Wyoming. Jeanette had gone to the Teton country with Mr. and Mrs. William Lipps, a region the letter describes as the home of her forebears. Still, each told the Wrensteds she was glad to be back in Idaho.
Old stories and new names
Before long the conversation came round to the beliefs and old tales of the women’s own people. They spoke of the Sun Dance, which Mrs. Wrensted explained to the paper’s readers as a ceremony of prayer for health and good fortune.
They also had an answer for why so many people on the reservation went by English names. When the first census was taken there, they said, the counters had no way to spell what they heard, so they wrote down English names that came near the sound. The case they gave was a Shoshoni chieftain known as Gub Shan Zhak, who went into the record as Gibson Jack. A creek near Pocatello bears that name as well, though the letter makes no mention of it.
Mink’s house at the canyon mouth
The story that touched the valley most nearly was Jeanette’s own. Mink Creek, she said, was named for Mink, her grandfather on her mother’s side. The canyon of that creek was the way between Pocatello and the Crystal end of the valley, the route traced in mail, grain and the Mink Creek road. Coming through it on this trip, she found the house Mink had lived in, near where the canyon opens out, still there, and Mrs. Wrensted wrote that it pleased her to see it. The letter does not give the canyon’s name or place the house any more exactly, and no other record of Mink or his home has been found.
The letter named each woman’s father as well: Chief Pocatello was Jeanette’s, and Rafael Lavatta was Mrs. Calvin’s. Mrs. Wrensted said nothing more about either family, and those statements have not been checked against other records. She did reckon that with such parents the two must know a great deal of the old lore. The reservation beside the valley is the subject of the 1898 cession and a borrowed wagon, and tribal names for places along Bannock Creek are gathered in Pasakwa Huude and other names on Bannock Creek.
The hosts
The letter never gives Mrs. Wrensted’s own first name. Her husband, Carl, had filed on land north of Crystal in 1913, and his homestead cabin appears in a valley of log cabins, 1917; the settlement around it is described in Crystal, the hidden settlement up Rattlesnake Creek. In March 1940 he sat on the Arbon-Crystal program planning board, and in April 1950 the Idaho State Journal ran his photograph as the Power County commissioner from Crystal.
How the visitors got there, how long they stayed and what more there was to the Lippses, the letter does not say. Nor is it known whether the women ever came back. Mrs. Wrensted closed by hoping they would, and that they would bring more stories of “how our Indian neighbors lived.”