For a weekend on the gold-rush trail, the Idaho State Journal told its readers on Friday, August 3, 1973, there was no need to leave the county’s back door. Two hours from Pocatello, past Pauline and Arbon, lay Twin Springs, a run-down Forest Service campground with the wagon ruts of the Hudspeth Cutoff of the California Trail cutting straight through it.
The piece opened “Exploring Idaho,” a new series of weekend outings, and Arbon Valley was its first stop. Peter Maupin, who edited the paper’s ENJOY magazine, wrote it and took the pictures.
Over Mink Creek and down the valley
Maupin’s route left town on the Old Bannock Highway and climbed by the Mink Creek Road. Partway up he pointed out beaver dams on the creek, where the animals were protected on national forest land. Over the top, that summer’s wheat fields rolled down toward Bannock Creek and the valley, and he thought the same slopes would suit skiers and snowmobilers once winter came.
Pauline and West Fork, where the road came into the valley, offered a traveler little. There was no store at the junction; the closest was a mile or so north. The drive swung south past Arbon on pavement all the way to Holbrook, where State Highway 37 turned back north to the camp. Drivers who did not mind gravel could cut the trip short. A few miles beyond the first square corner in the road, two gravel roads headed off toward the hills to the west. The second reached the highway in about 17 miles. Maupin had tried the first and ended up in a farmer’s field.
The only water for miles
He set the springs in a little hollow about 10 miles north of Holbrook. The state historical marker there named it a major gold-rush camp, and Maupin explained why. A wagon party coming west out of Hawkins Basin had to climb around the flank of what he called Mt. Elkhorn and cross the upper end of Arbon Valley, and until it reached Twin Springs it found no water that lasted through the summer. Outside of wet years, the marker said, the stretch to the east was dry for 22 miles, and parties often drove on well after dark to reach the camp.
The Buist and Summit area histories on this site trace the cutoff more closely. Opened in 1849, it came down into the valley at the Summit end, followed the valley floor south and bent west through Bull Canyon to the springs.
Older settlers knew it by another name. The Pocatello Tribune noted on June 6, 1944, that Hudspeth’s cutoff was sometimes called the Sublette road. Two years later, in a letter printed June 25, 1946, N. S. Coffin of Lava Hot Springs set down how the freighter Albert (Dock) Boyce, born in 1854, recalled it. In Boyce’s telling, the road crossed Marsh Valley close to where Arimo stands, topped the low range a short way below Garden Creek Gap, came down into Hawkins Basin, rose to the divide and dropped to Rattlesnake Creek. From there it went on to Bannock Creek and west to Raft River by way of a place he called Moonshine. That was probably the same high ground west of the valley that later carried a short-cut road to American Falls.
A history of Fort Hall in the Journal of July 13, 1973, agreed that California travelers came to skip the fort by a cutoff through Hawkins Basin and Arbon Valley, though it put the change in the late 1850s, some ten years after the cutoff actually opened. Another Journal story, on November 24, 1972, had the California party of John Chiles, better known as Joseph B. Chiles, leaving the main trail at Soda Springs in the 1840s and following the east ridge of the future Arbon Valley. That was probably a mistake: the accounts found have Chiles crossing with the Bartleson-Bidwell party in 1841 and again in 1843, when he split his company at Fort Hall, and neither brings him along the valley.
Maupin also wrote that John C. Fremont’s party went up Bannock Creek in September 1843, on the way from Salt Lake to Fort Hall, as the July 1973 history did. The site’s Arbon area history dates Fremont’s visit to 1846.
A camp in Bannock Valley, 1857
The road north from Malad to Fort Hall passed this way too. On October 30, 2020, the Journal printed parts of the 1857 diary of William Knox, with an introduction by his great-great-granddaughter, Elayne Bybee. That September, as a federal army marched toward Utah, Knox signed on in Salt Lake City for a mission to the Blackfoot Fork of the Snake River. A church history Bybee cites counts 43 in the company, led by Captain Andrew Cunningham, with orders to start a settlement near the deserted Fort Hall and, less openly, to keep an eye out for the army.
On October 8, with new snow on the mountains, Knox wrote “We are camped in Bannock Valley.” The company lay below the ridge that splits the Great Basin’s drainage from the Pacific’s, roughly three miles shy of where the Malad rises. That would put it near the head of the valley, though he gave no landmark. The next night they camped on Bannock Creek itself. As Bybee related the diary, the weather turned cold with a little hail, ice a quarter inch thick formed in the water bucket, and the animals had good feed. On October 10 they traveled some seven miles on the Fort Hall road, turned onto the Oregon road and made camp at Ross Fork.
Brigham Young’s company had come over into Bannock Valley from Malad that spring, as another post in this series tells, but no account of that trip says where it stopped for the night.
A wagon wheel in the pass, 1969
Four years before Maupin’s trip, Boy Scout Troop 876 of McCammon went looking for the same road from the other side. Working toward the Historic Trails Award, the Scouts hiked what the Journal of May 7, 1969, called the “old Sublette Trail west of Arimo.” Erastus Capell, Owen Marley, Len Hickman, Jack Alvord and Rex Hickman shared what they knew of it, and Rex Hickman walked the route with Scoutmaster Don Aslett.
The troop’s marker was an old wagon wheel with a plaque welded on, set in concrete on a hilltop in what the paper described as “the main pass between Marsh Valley and Arbon Valley.” Ernest Garrett thought of the monument and Bill Murphy built it, the paper said. Martell Gunter freighted the wheel and the cement in along the trail, and the boys packed part of the load. They camped a cold night at the old springs with snow on the ground and explored the following day. Afterward the troop met at the wheel, and each Scout set down a rock bearing his initials.
The paper did not give the plaque’s words or the exact place. If the trail was the one Boyce remembered, the pass was most likely the climb from Marsh Valley into Hawkins Basin, on the basin’s east side rather than at the rim of Arbon Valley. No later mention of the wheel has turned up.
The ruts today
Twin Springs sat right on Highway 37, the fastest road from Utah to American Falls Reservoir, yet in 1973 Maupin found the campground little used and badly kept. Brush had grown in around all five campsites. There was a hand pump for water, covered tables and pit toilets, and no Forest Service worker came by to collect a fee while he was there.
The old road was the real attraction. From camp, the wagon tracks showed on the hills both east and west. Westward they could be followed for nearly three miles over rolling ground until a plowed field wiped them out, a walk or a four-wheel-drive trip, Maupin warned, and no place for a family car or pickup. For the first half mile a Bureau of Land Management road kept about 30 feet south of the ruts, and beyond that the two merged.
To come home a different way, he suggested following Highway 37 north through Roy to Rockland, and he told readers to carry their own gas and food, since none could be bought anywhere on the loop until Rockland. The valley timeline marks the trail’s place in Arbon Valley’s story. East of the springs, more than a century after the gold seekers passed, farm traffic was still driving in their wheel tracks.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, August 3, 1973, page 20
- Idaho State Journal, May 7, 1969, page 8
- Idaho State Journal, November 24, 1972, page 27
- Idaho State Journal, July 13, 1973, page 21
- Idaho State Journal, October 30, 2020, page 182
- Pocatello Tribune, June 6, 1944, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, June 25, 1946, page 4
- Wikipedia, “Joseph Chiles”