Twenty Arbon Valley farmers reckoned that between them they raised about 155,000 bushels of wheat a year. On a Saturday in February 1930 they took that figure to Pocatello, hoping it was enough to win them a place in a new federal plan for selling grain.
The meeting was held on February 8 in the hall of the Pocatello chamber of commerce, where Power County’s wheat growers had gathered to hear their county agent, L. E. Tillotson, explain how a district could form a local unit and join the Federal Farm Board’s marketing system. The Arbon men left with an organizing committee of their own, charged with writing resolutions and a constitution. The valley then lay mostly in Power County, its home since 1913, when it was taken out of Oneida County; the south end around Buist remained in Oneida.
Hoover’s half-billion-dollar fund
The Farm Board was only months old. Congress had created it in the Agricultural Marketing Act of 1929, President Herbert Hoover’s answer to sliding crop prices, and handed it a revolving fund of half a billion dollars. For wheat it did not deal with farmers one by one. It worked through co-operatives the growers ran themselves, with a local in each district tied to a larger regional association.
The Salt Lake Tribune carried the Pocatello report the following morning, and printed seven names for the Arbon committee: Lester Hubbard, Joe Evans, a Carl whose last name falls across a broken spot in the scan, Ed Davis, Joe Arbon, William Allard and Roy Linden. The surviving letters read “Ru-” at the foot of one column and “ble” at the head of the next, and a further name may have dropped out at the same tear. No Carl Ruble appears in the valley’s records. The man may have been Carl Rudeen, who in March 1927 sat on a committee of Arbon Valley growers that met in that same chamber of commerce, with Tillotson in the chair, to talk over a community wheat warehouse. “Roy Linden” may be Roy Lindley, who farmed at Arbon, though the paper does not say so.
Nor does it say which Joe Evans or which Ed Davis served, and the Evans and Davis families each counted more than one man by those names at Arbon. Joe Arbon was most likely Bishop Joseph N. Arbon, of the Arbon family the valley is named for; the family history describes him as a wheat-committee man.
A Farm Board man, Leo Stuhr, was speaking to Twin Falls County farmers the same week, and his advice ran on the same page. A local, he said, had to organize on its own, line up storage and show real results before it could look for a federal loan. Southern Idaho’s wheat moved to market at Ogden, through the region’s long business ties with the Utah terminals, so he thought growers there belonged in the intermountain regional association rather than the more distant one in the Pacific Northwest.
“Two typical groups of heavy producers”
Ten days on, on Tuesday, February 18, directors of the Intermountain Grain Growers, Inc., gathered at the Bannock hotel in Pocatello. They hired W. H. Barrett of Salt Lake as general manager and sent him and the company’s secretary, J. W. Wade, out to organize locals in every Utah and Idaho county that grew enough grain to count. No local had yet been accepted, Wade said, but he expected many within weeks.
How much wheat a local needed would differ from place to place. Some groups already had pledges of 100,000 to 200,000 bushels, and Wade pointed to Arbon Valley as one of “two typical groups of heavy producers.” The other district’s name has been lost from the scan.
The harvest came that summer. On August 8, 1930, the Tribune reported from American Falls that truckloads of wheat were rolling into the warehouses there, with cutting well along in the Arbon Valley, Rockland and Pleasant Valley districts. The variety the paper called “Power county red,” “the favorite plant of the wheat farmer in this section,” was showing little smut or other disease, and the elevators were grading around the clock in three shifts.
Whether the Arbon Valley local was ever accepted, how much of that crop passed through it and how its members came out have not turned up in the papers found so far.
The New Deal committees
In 1933 the Farm Board gave way to the Farm Credit Administration. That May the Agricultural Adjustment Act set up the AAA, which paid farmers to leave part of their land unplanted, and in the valley it was run by committees of local farmers. Several of the 1930 names came back. The Arbon family history lists the wheat-allotment committees from 1933 onward: Roy Lindley, J. N. Arbon, John Anderson (probably John C. Andersen) and Ed Davis for Arbon, and E. C. England, William Allard and M. V. Tallon for Pauline. Allard also chaired the committee that organized the Grange in 1933, and a Pauline 4-H club dates from 1932, as the Stories entry on the first 4-H club and Grange records.
Those were the years when drought and debt emptied Crystal and Buist and federal land purchases took in much of the south end, a story told in Drought and debt empty Crystal and Buist and in the Buist area history.
With the county line still running through the valley, its farmers answered to two county seats. By May 1937 Oneida County’s agent, J. W. Webster, had set up committees to run that year’s soil conservation program, and the community chairman named for “Arbon and Buist” was A. M. Orrison, probably Archie M. Orison of Arbon. In October 1939 the Oneida committee called Arbon and Buist farmers to the Arbon school house to elect their AAA committee.
On the Power County side, the committees chosen in November 1939 for the 1940 conservation program put C. C. Payne at the head of Arbon’s, with E. C. England as vice chairman, Ray O. Burge as third member, and Charles Allard and S. Keeler as alternates. Chester Smith led Crystal’s. Each community sent its chairman to the county meeting at American Falls to elect county officers, and Payne was by then vice chairman of the county committee. The site’s family histories say he became county AAA chairman in 1941 and War Board chairman in 1942.
Ten years after the Arbon growers tallied their bushels in Pocatello, the valley’s farmers were still meeting in committees, now to decide how much of its wheat land would be planted.
The original article
Salt Lake Tribune, February 9, 1930, page 17. Transcribed from the page’s OCR text, which drops punctuation and paragraph breaks; these are supplied.
PLAN OF GRAIN UNIT OUTLINED
Pocatello C. of C. Pledges Aid to System Under Federal Marketing Act
POCATELLO, Idaho—Wheat growers of Power county met in the chamber of commerce hall Saturday to hear County Agent L. E. Tillotson present the plan for formation of a local unit to work in the proposed regional system of the federal farm board marketing act.
The farmers from Arbon valley in Power county appointed an organization committee to draw up resolutions and a constitution for the group. Lester Hubbard, Joe Evans, Carl Ru-[illegible]ble, Ed Davis, Joe Arbon, William Allard and Roy Linden were named committeemen.
From an estimate of the 20 growers it was estimated that 155,000 bushels of wheat was grown by that group annually. From this group it was believed that enough grain was grown to allow the forming of the local unit of the regional.
POCATELLO, Idaho—Board of directors of the Pocatello Chamber of Commerce met in the Bannock hotel Saturday noon and voted that the agricultural committee of the chamber should cooperate with all local units of cooperative marketing formed under the federal farm marketing act.
This aid will be given by way of formulating resolutions and conditions that should be presented to the federal farm board. Consideration of the proposed regional setup at the central point of production was discussed and it was agreed by the directors that this fact should be presented to the farm board.
Sources
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 8, 1927, page 11
- Salt Lake Tribune, February 9, 1930, page 17
- Salt Lake Tribune, February 19, 1930, page 24
- Salt Lake Tribune, August 8, 1930, page 20
- Salt Lake Tribune, May 10, 1937, page 13
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, October 23, 1939, page 7
- Salt Lake Telegram, November 4, 1939, page 19
- Wikipedia, “Federal Farm Board”
- Wikipedia, “Agricultural Adjustment Act”