David Dean Woodruff had been in the air for only about half an hour when his Cessna went into a farm field in Arbon Valley. It was close to three o’clock on Sunday afternoon, April 6, 1980, and a storm of hard wind and snow was blowing across the country southeast of American Falls. Woodruff, a 47-year-old pilot from Huntington Beach, California, died in the crash.
He had taken off from the Idaho Falls airport at around 2:30 p.m., as near as a spokeswoman for the Power County Sheriff’s Office could say. Before leaving he had been briefed on the weather for a trip that was to take him to Cedar City, in southern Utah, and on from there to Los Angeles. The paper described his plane only as a Cessna Turbo, giving no model number, and placed the wreck on what it called “the Bunnie Johnson farm.”
Almost all that is known comes from that spokeswoman, by way of a short item the Idaho State Journal printed the following day. Datelined American Falls, it ran on the City-Region page alongside the weekend’s police and accident news. She could not tell the paper what had gone wrong. Something may have failed in the engine, she said, or Woodruff may have become lost in the storm, and she left both possibilities open. Federal investigators had taken up the question and had not finished. The paper printed their agency as the FFA, but it meant the FAA, the Federal Aviation Administration.
A familiar name
The Journal did not say who Bunnie Johnson was or where in the valley the farm lay. The name had turned up in the Pocatello papers eighteen years before. In November 1962 the Journal wrote that Loretta M. Johnson, 16, who went by Bunnie and whose parents were Mr. and Mrs. Frank Johnson of Arbon Valley, had earned a sectional 4-H forestry award and a trip to the National 4-H Club Congress in Chicago. Two months later the Idaho Sunday Journal reported that her special forestry projects, laid out for her by Vernon Burlison, the University of Idaho’s extension forester, had been carried out on her parents’ 2,610-acre farm. Bunnie is not a common nickname, and the farm of 1980 was most likely that family’s, though the crash report does not say so, nor whether the land was by then in Bunnie’s own name. Her father was probably the Frank Johnson of Arbon who died in 2013 and was remembered at a memorial service at the Arbon LDS Church.
Woodruff’s Cessna was far from the first aircraft to come down in or near the valley. Before it came the B-24 bomber of 1944, the Stinson found west of Kinport Peak that same year, the three Pocatello fliers near Rattlesnake Creek in 1950, the pilot killed near Bannock Peak in 1961, the crop duster near Midnight Summit in 1962 and the Aztec on the Hayden ranch in 1963.
The brief item left much untold. It named no passenger, and it did not say who found the wreck, how anyone got to it, or which of the farm’s fields it struck. No follow-up has been found in the Pocatello paper, and whether the investigators finally blamed the engine or the storm is still not known.