Arbon had two teachers’ jobs, 20 pupils and a hard time keeping anyone in either job. Of the four teachers the district had hired in the past two years, only one was still there. So when the State Board of Education met in Boise at the end of November 1979, an Arbon trustee came to ask that the district be allowed to keep a man who did not hold a valid certificate. The board gave him one year.
The Idaho State Journal reported the decision on Sunday, December 2, 1979. Arbon was not alone. Challis and Bear Lake, two other small rural districts, had made similar requests, and the department’s Professional Standards Commission had turned all three down. On Friday the state board overruled the commission and granted each district emergency permission.
Low pay and hard posts
The three districts gave the board much the same reasons for coming up empty. Salaries were small, the work was difficult and remote, and there were not enough teachers to fill every opening.
Steve Lusk, one of Arbon’s trustees, spoke for the valley. Teachers of both sexes, he told the board, tended to meet someone and leave; in his words, “they seem to get married and run away.” Nor had a certificate guaranteed anything. Several of the district’s recent teachers had held full credentials, he said, and had still not done good work.
The man Arbon wanted was Lloyd Christensen of Pocatello. That September the district had given him two of its elementary grades. He was 11 credits from a bachelor’s degree and was finishing it part time at Idaho State University. He had held a certificate once, Lusk said, but it lapsed in 1950, and he had been out of teaching since. Lusk mentioned as well that Christensen’s wife, Ruby Christensen, was in charge of one of the Pocatello district’s elementary schools.
Challis and Bear Lake went home with approvals as well. The Challis superintendent said four teachers had been offered his district’s special education job and every one had said no. At Bear Lake, the board cleared two teachers to teach subjects outside their certification. When the three votes were done, board member Janet Hay of Nampa moved twice more: first, that the Department of Education find a way to look over uncertified teachers before their cases reached the board, and second, that it bring all emergency requests to the board each September.
The paper called Lusk only a school trustee. He was most likely Stephen T. “Steve” Lusk (1946–2025) of the Lusk family of Pauline and West Fork, Arbon’s highway foreman for nearly 47 years, whose father, David Wayne Lusk, was chairman of the school board for many years. No other Steve Lusk is known in the valley.
A different answer in 1971
Eight years earlier the state had said no. At its meeting in Twin Falls, the Associated Press reported on November 5, 1971, the board voted 4 to 2 against late requests from two schools, Arbon District 383 and a Friends academy at Greenleaf, for emergency teaching certificates filed after the deadline. Dr. John Swartley of Boise, who made the motion, said turning them down was how the board would learn “if we have any clout.” John Peacock of Kellogg voted no. The report gave no names for the Arbon teachers and did not say how the district managed afterward.
That same year Arbon’s very existence had been a subject of other boards’ meetings. The district, numbered 383 in Power County, ran the Arbon school in the Pauline area. On August 25, 1971, the Journal reported that William Thomas, superintendent at American Falls, had warned his trustees that legislative committees were pushing hard for a minimum of 1,800 students in every district statewide. The state education department, he said, already pictured a day when Arbon would be joined with Rockland, American Falls, Aberdeen and part of Snake River. The American Falls board chose to open talks with Aberdeen and reach its own terms before the state set them.
At that meeting American Falls also did Arbon a good turn. Arbon could not provide certain services alone, among them testing and treating children for speech and hearing problems, and the American Falls trustees agreed to furnish them. Arbon would pay the mileage and the cost of any substitute teachers.
Five days later, on August 30, the paper covered a joint meeting of the American Falls and Aberdeen boards at Aberdeen, where Arbon and Rockland came up as possible members of a combined district. The state hoped to cut Idaho’s more than 100 districts to about 40, the trustees heard. Nothing was decided. No merger had been proposed, the paper said; the trustees were only planning ahead, and any merger would likely combine just the high schools, leaving elementary and junior high pupils at home.
Sharing instead of merging
By the spring of 1980 the conversation had moved from merging to cooperating. One line in the Journal on April 9 reported that the American Falls trustees had sat down with boards from Arbon and Rockland to look at ways the three districts might work together and save money. The papers do not say what came of it.
In June the Journal, writing about teachers’ contracts, held up Arbon to show how hard it was to compare the region’s districts. Arbon now counted only 15 pupils, but it had $130,000 in land value behind each of them, against $9,000 a pupil in Pocatello.
These reports leave a good deal unsaid. They never name Arbon’s other teachers of the decade, whether Lloyd Christensen stayed beyond his year, or where the valley’s high school students went to class. Valley families will remember much that the papers missed.
The district came through, and through the next threat as well, a 1982 tax dispute over a church-owned farm that put the school in danger. Schools of Arbon Valley has a photograph of the Arbon school from about 1980, and Pauline and West Fork tells more of its neighborhood. In 2016 its 16 pupils were saving up for a new concrete playground, and in 2018 its notices still carried the name Arbon Elementary School District #383.