Sherm Swim had tried to give up roping, he told a reporter in the summer of 1980, and it had not taken. “I’ve been trying to retire but it’s no use,” the Arbon Valley cattleman said. At 56 he was getting ready to defend his title.
The previous Fourth of July, at the Bannock County Fairgrounds, Swim had won the Old Timers roping, and he meant to enter it again. Betty Hale, a correspondent for the Idaho State Journal in Pocatello, wrote him up for the paper’s Monday edition of June 23, 1980, and the photograph that ran beside her piece carried a caption to the effect that he was not done yet.
Fifty and over
A man qualified as an old-timer at 50, Swim explained. You could tell the generations apart, he said, the moment a roper got thrown, just by watching how quickly he picked himself up and cleared out. He still loved to win. The young hands beat him more often than not now, so each victory came less often and meant more, and he said that keeping company with them made him feel younger than he was.
There was no shortage of chances. By his reckoning a roper could find a contest within a reasonable drive on almost any weekend, and the season ran straight through winter under roofs at Fort Hall, Rupert, Preston and Ogden. Doctors and lawyers showed up in those fields alongside ranchers. A national association of old-timer rodeo hands was just getting organized, with finals planned for Las Vegas for those who qualified locally, and Swim said he planned to go. Someday he hoped to spend a winter roping in Arizona, too.
Herefords and horses
Hale’s piece gave the ranch as much room as the arena. Swim had grown up in Arbon Valley and could not recall a time when he was not riding and roping. Outside of contests he was on a horse every day, running Herefords with his son Kirk. The herd spent the winter in a feed lot, went out to the valley range in spring and stayed there until the fall roundup, while father and son rode out through the summer to check on it. The ranch raised its own grass hay and alfalfa and its own horses as well, and in ground that broken, Swim said, a good horse mattered more than anything. Of all the work, he liked roping and branding best.
He gave the credit to his wife, Rhea, calling her “the real backbone of the outfit,” and said she and Kirk ran the place. The couple also had a daughter and a son younger than Kirk, who ran a dry farm in the valley. Swim’s mother, Mrs. R. H. Swim of American Falls, was 80 and still rode horseback when she came out to the ranch. Fishing, Swim said, could wait until he was too old to sit a horse, and he expected to rope for the rest of his life.
A family from Bannock Creek
The papers never gave more than “Sherm Swim,” but what they did say lines up closely with the Swim family on this site, and he was almost certainly Sherman Hale Swim, born in 1923 to Robert Hale “Bob” Swim and Nell Roper Swim, whose Roper relatives lived at Pauline. Bob had come out from Kansas around 1922, years after his brother Frank homesteaded in 1908 on upper Bannock Creek south of Pauline, in the Pauline and West Fork country at the north end of the valley where the Swims first settled. From the early 1930s Bob rented a ranch on Bannock Creek at the reservation line, and by 1950 Sherm was a stockman there. Bob died in 1971 and Nell was born in 1900, so the 80-year-old Mrs. R. H. Swim was very probably Nell, though the paper did not print her first name.
The Journal had come across Sherm twice before. In May 1978 part of the Caribou National Forest was being opened to Shoshone-Bannock cattle under the Tribes’ treaty grazing right, and he was among the non-Indian ranchers whose stock would have to make room. On the stand in federal court he said 58 head on his permit would be pushed off, that he would sooner sell them than haul them to range east of Henry, and that he ran between 300 and 400 cattle altogether. In June of that year the paper ran a picture of him roping calves at a neighbors’ branding in the valley, the kind of day remembered in a 2010 post on branding.
The calf and the coyotes
The following spring the paper was back. On Thursday afternoon, March 12, 1981, Sherm and Kirk were feeding and looking over their cows when they saw coyotes attack a calf only four days old and tear up its hindquarters. On March 13 the Journal printed Doug Lindley’s photograph of the two of them holding the calf, headlined “Calf Survives Coyote Attack.” Coyotes were better known for going after sheep and lambs than cattle, the caption said, and it was not certain the calf would pull through.
The pages read for this post do not say whether it did, nor how Swim fared at the 1980 Fourth of July roping, nor whether he got to Las Vegas. The 1980 and 1981 stories place the ranch only in Arbon Valley, and the 1978 court report in the Bannock Creek area. The family later ranched on Crystal Creek in the Rattlesnake drainage, though it is not known when they moved.
He did not retire. In 1981, the family history records, he and his neighbor Sod Williams, of the Williams family in the arena, roped as partners at the national old-timers’ rodeo in Vernal, Utah. Sherm Swim died in 2011, and his life was marked with a celebration in his memory.