Eight airline passengers needed a ride to Salt Lake City, and two Pocatello pilots took the job. By Sunday morning, March 24, 1963, one of those pilots and his passenger lay dead beside a burned plane on the Ben L. Hayden ranch north of Crystal, and the other pilot was missing somewhere in the storm.
A blown tire at Pocatello
It started with someone else’s bad luck. Western Air Lines Flight 23, a Douglas DC-6B bound from Great Falls, Montana, to Salt Lake City, burst the tire on its nose wheel as it set down at Pocatello on Saturday, March 23. Eight of the stranded travelers hired Airways Inc., a Pocatello flying service, to finish the trip, and the company sent two planes south with four passengers in each.
Allen J. Manning, the president of Airways Inc., flew the bigger of the two, a twin-engine Piper Aztec with six seats. The Salt Lake Tribune described him as “a prominent Pocatello mortician,” and the United Press International wire story printed in the Provo Daily Herald and the Logan Herald Journal said he had once been Bannock County coroner. The Logan paper added that his brother, Representative Darrell Manning, a Bannock County Democrat, was his partner in the flying business. Riding along with Manning, just for the trip, was Wayne Koch, a gas pipeline company employee. Wayne L. Carter, another Pocatello pilot, took the second plane, a five-place Piper Apache.
Manning reached Salt Lake Municipal Airport first, and Carter touched down a few minutes after him, at about 8:40 that evening. Neither lingered. Each had his passengers off and was in the air again, pointed home, within ten or fifteen minutes; Carter made the return flight by himself. Federal Aviation Agency officials at Pocatello said one of the planes called in its position at 9:32 p.m. and the other gave the same report a few minutes afterward. Then came a message from Manning: ice was building on his plane, and he had dropped 600 feet. According to the Tribune, nothing more was heard from either pilot.
Found at first light
Planes went up early Sunday and spotted the Aztec from the air, and men on foot then reached it. It had come down on the Hayden ranch, about 13 miles from Pocatello, at the end of a round trip of roughly 200 miles. In the wire service’s words, it had “pancaked into the earth” in the Arbon Valley. The wreck was partly burned. Manning and Koch had been thrown clear and died at once, and their bodies lay close to the plane. The papers put Manning’s age at 38 or 39 and Koch’s at 31, though Koch’s obituary, as the Stories entry notes, gives his birth year as 1922.
The ranch very probably belonged to Ben Lynn Hayden, a son of the homesteader John Hayden, who had taken over the Hayden family farm at Crystal when his brother Norman died in 1950. The Tribune’s front-page story carried a Pocatello dateline and a map of the planes’ routes. Its byline is garbled in the scan, but it seems to read Carl Hayden, Tribune staff writer. That was most likely Carl E. Hayden, Ben’s older brother, raised at Crystal and for years the paper’s roving correspondent. If so, he was writing about a plane that had fallen on his brother’s land.
Hunting the Apache
Carter was still unaccounted for. Chet Moulton, Idaho’s director of aeronautics, ran the search. UPI quoted him as saying about 25 planes were up on Sunday afternoon; the Tribune put the number at better than 30, which it said “braved severe turbulence,” and noted that Col. Dwight Shaw, commander of the Idaho Civil Air Patrol wing, had flown down from Boise to help. Farm families had said they heard an airplane overhead on Saturday night. That lead went nowhere, and the searchers shifted to the Rattlesnake Creek country, near where the Aztec lay. Rattlesnake Creek is one of the two main streams of the Crystal basin that drain to Bannock Creek, country the Crystal area history describes. It was also near Rattlesnake Creek that a Pocatello flight instructor and two students had died in the 1950 crash.
Moulton promised the flying would start again at daylight Monday, and the parties left Pocatello at dawn. The UPI report that day pulled in two directions. Accounts of a flash and an explosion late Saturday night had led the coordinators to wonder whether Carter overshot Pocatello in the storm, and a fleet of 25 small planes moved to the country northwest of the city. The same dispatch, though, had the second day’s search working the Rattlesnake Creek area of Arbon Valley, some fifteen miles southwest. On Monday afternoon Carter’s scorched plane was sighted in the Deep Creek Mountains, about sixteen miles southwest of Pocatello, and his body was brought out, as the Stories entry records. The reports do not make clear whether that spot is within the valley.
Fifty years on
On May 24, 2013, fifty years after the crash, visitors from a website that catalogs aircraft wrecks in the West walked the Aztec site. Their short page says the plane went down in a snowstorm that evening because ice on its wings would not let it hold altitude. By that telling, the pilot tried for an emergency landing but could not read the snow-covered ground; the plane struck a low hill, carried across a ravine and burned in a farm field. The page names neither pilot nor passenger and cites no sources, and the 1963 papers say nothing of any landing attempt.
The landowner walked the visitors to the place where he had come upon the wreckage the morning after, and he shared pictures he had taken that day in 1963. Every piece of the plane has since been hauled away, and nothing shows on the ground. The page leaves the landowner unnamed but credits the photographs to Hans Hayden, most likely Ben Hayden’s son Hans, who farmed the old Hayden homestead at Crystal with his brother Twain.
Nothing of the Aztec is left in that field now. What remains is in the pictures a Hayden took the morning after it fell.