Max Pope heard the motor first. Shortly before eight on the rainy night of Thursday, November 2, 1950, the farmer near Rattlesnake Creek caught the sputter of a small plane somewhere overhead, then the engine roaring up for perhaps three seconds before it hit the ground. Neighbors heard it too. Two of them, Leonard Judkins and Ben Hayden, set out to find it, but in the dark they could not. All three men aboard were already dead, and no one would see the wreck until morning.
Rattlesnake Creek runs out of the Crystal area at the upper end of Arbon Valley, a high basin whose springs feed two main creeks, Midnight and Rattlesnake, as the history of Crystal explains. The Deseret News put the creek about eight miles north of Arbon. The Ben Hayden who went searching was very likely Ben Lynn Hayden of the Crystal Hayden family, who took over the family farm after his brother Norman died that year.
Three young veterans
The plane was a single-engine Cessna with four seats, owned by the Wilson Flying Service of Pocatello. At the controls was Gene Armstrong, 26, a commercial flight instructor. With him were two of his students, Paul Shepherd, 28, and Shirley Webster. The papers call Webster “Mr.” and name his widow, so readers today should know that Shirley Webster was a man.
All three lived in Pocatello, all were in their twenties, and all had served in the Second World War. Armstrong had flown with the army air forces in the South Pacific and had both night and commercial hours in his log. Shepherd, an Idaho State College graduate who worked at the Utah Oil Company’s distributing plant, had spent the war with the air forces in Iceland. Webster had been a navy man and was learning to fly under the G.I. Bill.
What sort of trip it was depends on which paper you read. The Deseret News described a round trip to Salt Lake City with the instructor and his two students, “a night training flight to Salt Lake City.” The Salt Lake Telegram thought it had likely been a “pleasure flight,” since no one had entered it at the airport as a commercial one. A day later the Deseret News added that the men had filed no flight plan.
The departure time and field differ a little too. The Deseret News had the Cessna leaving the Wilson Flying Service field soon after 7:30 p.m., while the Salt Lake Tribune had it taking off from Phillips field, Pocatello’s municipal airport, a little before 8. The Telegram and the Deseret News agreed that it was down within minutes.
A night of searching
When the plane failed to reach Salt Lake, highway patrolmen on both sides of the Utah line looked for it through the night, and somewhere between fifteen and twenty aircraft joined in. On Friday morning, 55 minutes into the air search, Bob Fields, who flew for the Pocatello Flying Service, picked out the wreck on a hillside among the low mountains at the head of Arbon Valley. He radioed the CAA, the federal Civil Aeronautics Administration, at Phillips field, and his report was brief: “It doesn’t look too good.”
Not every account credits Fields. The next day’s Deseret News, in damaged type, gives the sighting to a pilot whose name reads as Sokolik, and the Tribune, in a hard-to-read passage, says Max Pope was the first to see the wreckage on the ground. By morning farmers had gathered at the site, and Power County deputies drove out from American Falls. Arbon had belonged to Power County since 1913.
Under full power
There had been no fire, but the Cessna was destroyed. It had struck the slope so hard that the tail was crumpled forward to within eight feet of the nose. W. E. Thurman, chief of air communications at Phillips field, judged from the damage that the plane had gone in at full power. By the Tribune’s account, the nose was driven two feet into the plowed ground of a winter wheat field, and the men’s watches had stopped close to eight o’clock, just when the farmers heard the crash. The Telegram named the place the Norman Grover farm and the Tribune the Milton Grover farm; neither paper said more about who owned it.
The weather carried most of the blame. The Telegram reported that a hard, driving rain and fog were the tentative cause. The Tribune, in a partly garbled passage that mentions Malad, Crystal and Arbon Valley, said conditions had looked ideal, except that a band of rain and mist was crossing the upper valley and the plane was caught in that rough air when it fell. An agent from the CAA district office found nothing mechanical wrong on Friday. The investigators settled on poor visibility, most likely from cloud, on an “exceptionally dark” night. No inquest or later finding on the cause has turned up.
The families left behind
Armstrong was survived by his father in Portland and a brother in Missoula, Montana. Shepherd left his wife, Mabel, his mother and a brother. Webster left his wife, Rene, his parents at Preston, Idaho, and five brothers and two sisters.
The news traveled well beyond the valley. An International News Service item datelined Arbon, November 4, told of three men found dead in a wrecked plane eight miles northeast of the town, and the New Castle News in New Castle, Pennsylvania, ran it the same day. Most accounts put the crash fifteen to twenty miles south or southwest of Pocatello, though the Tribune printed southeast. Read together, they point to the upper end of the valley, in the Crystal area. The Stories page records the crash in brief.
The upper valley would hear another plane come down. In March 1963, thirteen years later, two charter planes were lost in a snow squall, and one of them fell on the Ben L. Hayden ranch north of Crystal.