For some time the sheep had been disappearing from the range around the Rudeen ranch near Bannock Peak, the 8,256-foot summit on the edge of the Fort Hall Reservation, and a mountain lion was getting the blame. On Saturday, January 26, 1963, four men from Bannock Creek went after her and came home with the cat.
The hunting party was Merle Meyers, his sons Jerry and Jay, and Kenneth Pevoe. Most of the work fell to Meyers’s dogs, a set of pups just ten months old, which ran the lion onto a rocky ledge and kept her there until the men came up and killed her. She was a female, and a large one. Meyers measured her at 7 feet 10 inches from nose to tip of tail and put her weight near 130 pounds. The paper guessed her age at three or four, without saying whose guess it was.
The Idaho Sunday Journal had the news the next morning, four brief paragraphs on page 2 under the headline “Bannock Hunters Kill Big Lion.” It could not settle on a spelling and gave the family name as both Myers and Meyers in the one short item. It also left a good deal out. It never said which of the four fired the shot, how long the pups trailed the lion, where on the mountain the ledge lay, what happened to the hide or whether anyone collected a bounty, and no later report of the hunt has been found.
A family on Bannock Creek
Journal readers had met Merle Meyers before. In September 1957 the paper ran his own account of the fall roundup on the reservation range along Bannock Creek, illustrated with photographs he took himself. The editor’s note introduced him as a man who grew up at Crystal and now sold real estate in Pocatello. He and his wife, Dorothy, lived with Jerry, Jay and their daughter, Judy, on Bannock Creek inside the reservation, renting a house that had once been home to an Indian extension agent. Every one of the five could ride, and they kept seven horses.
He was very likely a son of John H. Meyers, an Arbon Valley rancher and stockman listed at Crystal as far back as 1917. When John died in October 1953, his obituary counted among the survivors a son, Merle Meyers of Arbon, and a daughter, Mrs. Willard Higdon of Pocatello. The lion story makes no such link, but the name and the Crystal boyhood both fit.
Jerry was in the paper again a little more than two months after the hunt. The Idaho State Journal of April 3, 1963, reported that the American Legion had chosen him and two of his American Falls High School classmates for Boys State in Boise that June, naming him the son of “Mr. and Mrs. Merle Meyers, Bannock Creek.” He was the Fourth District High School Rodeo Association’s president, a seven-year 4-H member and a wrestler on the varsity team.
The Rudeen name
The 1963 item said nothing more about the ranch than its name, but Rudeen was a familiar one in this country. By 1931 Carl Rudeen was raising wheat on a big scale in the valley. That January he told the Pocatello Tribune he held some 3,500 acres in Arbon Valley and had come to terms on taking over a sheep outfit, which brought with it several thousand acres of range next to his dry farms, some to be bought and some leased. The way out of the wheat farmer’s troubles, he said, was to rotate crops and keep livestock along with the grain. In 1938 he held the lease on the range between Arbon and Rockland that was seeded to grass from an airplane, and a 1948 Tribune story had him running both wheat and stock in Power County. None of the sources read for this story says whether the ranch by Bannock Peak in 1963 belonged to him or to his family.
Not the first lion
Lions had come to grief in these hills before. In the fall of 1922 the American Falls Press noted in a single line from Arbon that a sheepherder had killed one in Bull Canyon, south of town, a week earlier. That lion also turns up in Keeping the sheep out of the canyons.
In 1933 a sheepman, W. G. Ward, took three cougars on three straight days, August 25, 26 and 27, on the grazing land between Elk Meadows and Midnight Creek, most likely the Midnight Creek in the Crystal basin. Each of the three measured over six feet, nose to tail. The Pocatello Tribune said the chief deputy game warden had heard of no other cougars killed in that part of Idaho that year, and that the state paid a bounty on them for the damage they did to game, sheep and cattle.
The cats never left for good. Mountain lions were still making valley news in 1997 and 2000, long after a team of ten-month-old pups held one on a ledge near Bannock Peak.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, January 27, 1963, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, April 3, 1963, page 11
- Idaho Sunday Journal, September 29, 1957, page 18
- Idaho State Journal, October 11, 1953, page 12
- American Falls Press, July 10, 1917, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, January 7, 1931, page 2
- Pocatello Tribune, August 1, 1948, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, September 6, 1933, page 8
- American Falls Press, November 2, 1922, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, June 3, 1981, page 23