In 1988 signs warning hunters away went up across Arbon Valley until most of it was closed. A year later, Idaho’s governor stood before an international audience and called the valley a model.
Gov. Cecil Andrus made the point on Tuesday, August 15, 1989, in a speech to an international conference on how landowners and hunters get along. The two camps could reach a fair balance, he told the delegates, but only once each conceded that the other side had real grievances. For an example he reached for the farm country southwest of Pocatello in Power County. A United Press International dispatch from Boise carried his remarks, and the Logan Herald Journal ran it the next day.
Signs on every fence
The report put the valley at some 80 miles in length and about 4 miles across, land that was at once “prime deer habitat” and heavily farmed ground. In 1988 the posted signs had multiplied. Farmers were tired of strangers hunting their land without asking, of hunters driving across their fields and of damaged crops. Feelings ran so high that most of the valley was closed to hunters.
The Idaho Department of Fish and Game then brought both sides to the table, and the talks ended in what the report called a “balanced and reasonable” outcome. That fall 2,663 hunters came into the area and took 1,760 deer. The scanned page is a jumble, with lines from other stories run through it, and its timing is loose. Written in August 1989, its talk of the past summer and fall most likely means 1988. It does not spell out the terms of the agreement or name the landowners who took part, and no later paper read for this post says whether the peace held.
Andrus called it a small story, but one that showed what could come of everyone with a stake sitting down together to work a problem through.
Lions and calves
Eight years later the valley’s quarrel was with a different animal. In February 1997 the Associated Press sent out a story datelined Arbon. Dozens of ranchers in southeastern Idaho, convinced that cougars were taking too many of their animals, opposed a study the Fish and Game Department had in mind. To learn how mountain lions affected the deer, the department proposed to allow just one lion to be killed each year for five years in certain hunting units. The ranchers met with two Fish and Game commissioners, Roy Brown and Fred Wood, and pressed for a bigger lion harvest instead.
One Arbon Valley rancher told the reporter that he and his neighbors had no wish to wait out the study “worrying about our livestock and fearing for our children.” Over the past four years, he reckoned, lions had cost him an average of 12 calves a year. The Ogden Standard-Examiner of February 16, 1997, printed his name as Barr Williams. That page clips the final letters off several other words as well, so the rancher was most likely Barry Williams, who ran cattle in the valley and was a son of Donald “Sod” and Nelda Williams, though the article alone cannot prove it. None of the papers say how the commission ruled on the study, or whether the ranchers got their larger hunt.
A cougar on the porch
On New Year’s Day 2000, a cougar came calling at the Arbon Valley home of Donald and Nelda Williams. It killed the couple’s blue heeler and then went after the cats along the front porch. Nelda Williams picked up her rifle and shot the animal, a male. A wildlife biologist told her that cougars were ordinarily protected, but that she had done nothing wrong. The Associated Press carried the story, and Betsy Marston, editor of High Country News, retold it in a column the Park Record printed on February 19.
She was 76 that winter. Her age and her husband’s name fit Nelda Ward Williams, born into the Ward family and married to Sod Williams. Her own account of the hard winter of 1948–49 survives, and the site’s Stories pages tell that winter too. A surprise party marked her 90th birthday in 2013.
A news photograph of her with a .22 rifle found its way to Susan J. Tweit, a Colorado writer, who began a column about mountain lions with it. The Logan Herald Journal ran the piece on May 11, 2000. Tweit granted that most western states let a person kill a lion that threatens people, livestock or pets, so the law was on Williams’s side, and then asked at once whether she had the moral right as well. Williams, the column reported, said she fired because the lion had “got in her face” when it killed her dog. Tweit was not persuaded. People who make their homes in lion country, she argued, have to learn to share it. Voters in several western states had already put limits on lion hunting, she noted, so the ranchers of one Idaho valley had stepped into an argument that ran the length of the West.
Between the deer, the hunters and the lions, the people of Arbon Valley kept finding that the wild country around them was everyone’s business.