Seventy-two Arbon Valley voters went to the polls on Saturday, May 17, 1952, and by a margin of three to one they closed down the road district the valley had run since 1918. Fifty-four ballots favored dissolving Independent Highway District No. 3 and 18 favored keeping it. Power County would now care for the valley’s roads.
The Idaho Sunday Journal, the Sunday edition of the Idaho State Journal, carried the outcome the next morning in a few lines near the bottom of page one, headed “Vote to Dissolve.” The item did not name the polling place, give the number of eligible voters or say who had asked for the election. The next Friday, May 23, the Journal added that the commissioners had checked the returns during the week and found the same 54 to 18. The roads that had been the district’s went to the county highway department.
A district of its own
The district was 34 years old. It came into being at a special election on June 12, 1918, called under the Idaho law of 1911 that let rural areas organize highway districts. County commissioners Walter S. Sparks and R. W. Peterson canvassed the ballots, found not one vote against, and in an order printed by the American Falls Press declared the territory “created and established into Highway District No. 3.” Its boundary, laid out by townships and sections, followed the edge of the Fort Hall reservation and the Bannock County line.
That fall voters in the Arbon and Pauline precincts approved $50,000 in district bonds. The Press reported the Pauline count as 56 for and 10 against. With its own commissioners and its own debt, the district graveled the Bannock Creek road in 1919, as told in A new road in a dry year, and two years later lost its cash when a bank failed, as Arbon’s road money and the wheat haul of 1921 recounts. The first state highway traces the start of the valley’s graveled road, and Arbon describes the country it served.
After that the district surfaced in print only now and then. In March 1938 Willis Bullock, a WPA man said to have been lent to the road crew, sued it and two men for $50,000 after losing a leg while working on a machine that cleared snow from Arbon Valley roads. A Power County jury decided for the defendants.
A petition and a protest
The end began in the fall of 1951. On November 20 the Journal reported that the commissioners at American Falls had a petition before them asking that the district be dissolved. The paper named one signer, Jesse L. Thompson, and counted more than 30 others with him. It gave no hometown for Thompson, but he was likely Jesse Loosle Thompson of Logan, Utah, whose family dry-farmed in the valley, as the Summit century farm tells. The petitioners argued that the county could keep up the roads more cheaply and with fewer headaches, and that a separate district no longer served any purpose. A hearing was set for December 10 at the courthouse.
When the day came, a crowd from the valley filled the room to object, and the Journal of December 12 reported that the district would stay. Its spokesman, whom the paper left unnamed, said an election held so soon would draw too thin a turnout. He promised to resist until the commissioners proved they could do better by the roads than Oneida County, which takes in the valley’s south end, did by its own.
Commissioner LeRoy Lindley answered that Power County had twice as much highway money to spend as Oneida. The paper did not give his home, but he was probably the Arbon farmer of that name, son of the Roy Lindley who served on the district board in 1921 (see Roy Lindley and the golden eagle). A LeRoy Lindley of Arbon ran for the county’s new soil conservation board in 1948, and a LeRoy Lindley still sat on the Power County commission in 1969. The commissioners pointed to Rockland, whose roads had already passed to the county and where, they said, people were far happier with the change. The paper expected another petition by spring.
How the question came back is not in the papers found. No record turned up of a second petition, of who called the May election or of how many could have voted, and nothing was reported about what became of the district’s money, machinery or any bonds still owing. The spring count, though, left no doubt. The winter’s protest had turned into a three-to-one verdict, and after 34 years the valley’s roads were the county’s to keep.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, May 18, 1952, page 1
- Idaho State Journal, May 23, 1952, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, November 20, 1951, page 3
- Idaho State Journal, December 12, 1951, page 5
- American Falls Press, June 25, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 15, 1918, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, March 10, 1938, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, September 27, 1948, page 6
- Idaho State Journal, June 18, 1969, page 8