Just before Christmas in 1951, a Power County delegation went to Boise with one thing to ask. They wanted the state highway commission to place the Arbon Valley road on the federal secondary system. That rating would mark it as a farm-to-market road and could bring federal dollars to build it, with the state left only to advise.
The Idaho Sunday Journal reported the trip on December 23, 1951, under an American Falls dateline. The delegation was C. C. Thornhill, LeRoy Lindley, H. Irvin Moss, State Senator Ray Alexander, State Representative E. G. Commons and Vard W. Meadows. Across the table were the commissioners, the state highway engineer E. V. Miller, his assistant C. W. Short and other officials. Two Boise men joined the talks as well: H. C. Allen, a former American Falls resident then with the Public Utilities Commission, and Edward Woozley, the state land commissioner. Lindley was probably the LeRoy Lindley of Arbon who had stood for the board of the new soil conservation district in 1948.
Twenty-five miles of the road ran through the Indian reservation, and the meeting agreed that the Indian department ought to build that part.
Oneida County had sent people of its own that week, after a different road. They wanted State Highway 27 extended from Roy across the pass to join what the paper called Highway 30 south. Power County had wanted that connection for years, the paper said, around Rockland most of all, but the international situation had put the work on hold.
Three ways out
The trip to Boise was one more turn in a campaign that had been going since the war ended. Roads left the valley in three directions. Northeast, one climbed over the Mink Creek summit and down to Pocatello. The state road reports of 1946 and 1950 list a “State Route 38, Arbon Valley,” which very probably means this road, though they never trace where it ran. North, a road followed Bannock Creek across the Fort Hall Reservation to Highway 30 and the railroad, the way the valley’s wheat had long gone out. And at the south end, around Buist, the valley belonged to Oneida County, and its road went on toward Holbrook.
Fair to the summit, poor past it
Conrad Kelly, the district highway engineer, graded Route 38 on December 30, 1946: fair up to the summit, poor on the other side. On January 6, 1947, a group from the valley came before the county commissioners, with Kelly present, to ask that the Mink Creek road be fixed. Board chairman W. H. Jensen answered that the road belonged to the state, not the county. Kelly said it was already among the state’s secondary road projects and that he looked for some grading and straightening on it during 1947.
Two years later the roads on the reservation side were still poor. In 1949 William Hess of American Falls, who sat on the state road commission, wrote to Senator Glen Taylor to ask about federal help for the roads near Arbon. Valley farmers wanted roads a car could travel, Hess explained, and what they had were “little more than trails,” mostly on reservation land. Taylor’s reply, published October 13, 1949, held out no hope. The Bureau of Indian Affairs told him it had nothing planned near Arbon, either for the next year or beyond. Congress had allowed the Indian Service under $300,000 for roads across the whole country, too little even to replace its collapsed bridges, and nearly all of the 1950 money would go to maintenance.
The south end
Oneida County was already putting crews to work on the lower valley, and the work had a cost. On April 23, 1948, Harold Grant Moss, 24, was alone under a dump truck greasing it when the lift gave way and the bed came down on him, killing him.
In May 1950 the Oneida County commissioners took about 35 farmers to Boise to see John R. McKinney, the state public works commissioner. They asked for state help in building and keeping up seven miles of the Arbon Valley highway, which on that stretch was a county road, and on May 10 McKinney said he would consider it. In December eleven contractors bid for 7.481 miles of what the paper named the Bannock highway, from Holbrook junction to Arbon within Oneida County. Parson & Fife Construction of Brigham City, Utah, was low at $63,662.50, and every bid fell below the $95,799 estimate. The two reports very likely describe the same stretch, though neither one says so. The papers read for this post do not say whether McKinney ever granted the request or whether Parson & Fife built the road.
Snow on the summit
Weeks after the Boise trip, the Mink Creek road showed why the valley kept asking. In a storm on January 16, 1952, a snowplow was out trying to break it open to Arbon Valley. That April a Journal columnist wrote that the Bannock County stretch, from a little beyond the East Fork turnoff up to the summit, was in bad need of repair and still carried plenty of snow on top.
Eight miles of blacktop
By February 1954 Lindley was chairman of the Power County commissioners, and the board sent a formal application to what the paper called the Department of Indian Affairs, asking that eight miles of the Arbon road be improved. The year’s plan called for eight miles of new bituminous surface, running toward Arbon from the highway district line about nine miles out from Highway 30. Federal funds would pay roughly 80 per cent and the county the remaining 20. In April, Commissioner Thornhill listed a start on the Arbon road among the county’s goals for the year when he spoke to the American Falls Chamber of Commerce.
Whether the road ever won its federal secondary rating, and whether the 1954 application was approved and the surface laid that year, the pages read here do not tell. Nor do they record what the Shoshone and Bannock people of Fort Hall thought of a highway through their reservation.
The earlier fight over the north road is told in Arbon’s wheat road across the reservation, and mail, grain and the Mink Creek road follows the Pocatello road through the 1920s. The Buist history and the Pauline and West Fork history describe the two ends of the valley, and the first oiled road sorts out the claims for when paving arrived. At the south end, at least, the wait ran long. As Buist remembers it, the gravel road up from Holbrook was not oiled until about 1959.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, December 23, 1951, page 9
- Pocatello Tribune, December 30, 1946, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, January 7, 1947, page 1
- Ogden Standard-Examiner, April 24, 1948, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, April 25, 1948, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, September 27, 1948, page 6
- Idaho State Journal–Pocatello Tribune, October 13, 1949, page 8
- Idaho Sunday Journal, April 9, 1950, page 3
- Idaho State Journal, May 10, 1950, page 3
- Idaho Sunday Journal, December 17, 1950, page 15
- Idaho State Journal, January 16, 1952, page 1
- Idaho State Journal, April 17, 1952, page 4
- Idaho State Journal, February 10, 1954, page 3
- Idaho Sunday Journal, April 11, 1954, page 28