For a week in October 1925 the federal court at Pocatello worked through a docket of moonshiners, stills and liquor sellers. When the Pocatello Tribune wrote up the week on October 17, it saved two cases from Arbon Valley for the last paragraph. One concerned the man who had carried the valley’s mail. The other concerned the woman who had kept its post office.
A vacancy at Arbon
The first sign of trouble at the post office, among the papers read for this post, was a small notice in the Tribune on September 5. The United States Civil Service Commission would give an examination at Pocatello “to fill a contemplated vacancy in the position of fourth-class postmaster at Arbon, Idaho.” The job had paid $504 the previous fiscal year. Anyone applying had to live in the territory the office served, and the deadline was September 23.
Logans had run the office for three years. In June 1922, with the post office in danger of closing because nobody would take it, Mrs. E. A. Logan was keeping it as acting postmaster, a story told in Who kept the Arbon post office. The site’s reading of the federal register of postmaster appointments has E. A. Logan acting from August 1922, Mrs. Jennie Logan appointed on May 3, 1923, and J. R. Bailey acting from September 22, 1925. That November the appointment went to Edna Bailey, his daughter according to the Bailey family history, and the office was back with the Baileys. The office’s beginnings are told among the valley’s firsts.
In court at Pocatello
On October 17 the Tribune reported that “Jennie A. Logan, former postmistress at Arbon,” had been arraigned on a charge of embezzling $419.06 in post office funds. She would plead on Monday.
The paper gave no husband’s name and never explained the “A.” Still, she was almost surely Jennie Logan, wife of the homesteader Ellis A. Logan. Writing as Mrs. E. A. Logan, she had produced the valley’s first history in 1917, quoted in The squatters of 1892, in Mrs. Logan’s words. The register names Mrs. Jennie Logan as Arbon’s postmaster from 1923 to 1925, and no other Logan woman is known to have held the office.
In the same paragraph was “Thor Daniels,” once the carrier on the rural route from Pocatello to Pauline, who admitted stealing government mail sacks. The next day the paper called him Theodore Daniels and said his route had run from Pocatello to Arbon. Either description fits the star route out of Pocatello through Crystal and Pauline to Arbon, which the American Falls Press had said was let to “Theo. Daniels of Pauline” beginning in July 1922. He was very likely Theodore Daniels (1886–1957), of the Daniels family at Pauline.
His case was settled by the Sunday Tribune of October 18. He was fined $100. The sacks, the paper said, had ended up on his ranch, some holding grain and about a dozen thrown over horses as saddle blankets. The court gave him until Wednesday before the sentence took effect.
No word on the rest
The Sunday paper did not mention Mrs. Logan again. Nothing found so far tells how she pleaded, how her case came out, how the money went missing, or whether she resigned or was put out of the office.
The family did not leave the valley over it. According to her obituary, as quoted on her Find a Grave memorial, the Logans lived at Arbon 29 years in all and moved to Idaho Falls only in 1935. The obituary recalled her three years as Arbon’s postmaster. She died in 1974, nearly half a century after her name ran at the bottom of a column about bootleggers.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, October 17, 1925, page 5. Transcribed from the page scan. Letters broken or dropped in the printing (“given,” “nuisance,” “dismissed,” “consent”) are read from context.
EDWARDS CASE GOES TO JURY AT NOON TODAY
Variety of Bootlegging Cases Before Federal Court—Former Rural Mail Carrier Arraigned
The way of the bootlegger is various and sundry according to the array of cases which have occupied the attention of the federal court for the past week. Many pleas of guilty have been entered by defendants and sentence passed while others, first denying the charges of violation of the prohibition act have changed their pleas and “taken their medicine.” A few have held out for trial, however and will be heard during the coming week. Following the close of the Barney Edwards case in which defendant was charged with manufacturing a still to be used for the purpose of manufacturing liquor which went to the jury at noon today, a demurrer in the case of William Perry charged with immoral relations with a sixteen year old Indian girl was being argued this afternoon.
George Challas, arraigned this morning before Federal Judge Dietrich, plead guilty to possession and sale of intoxicating liquor, other counts being dismissed on motion of the district attorney. He will be sentenced Monday at noon. James Dimas against whom an indictment was returned by the grand jury will plead Tuesday morning. Jerry Woodside, pleading guilty to possession and sale of liquor and also to maintaining a nuisance plead guilty and was fined $100 and given six months in the Power county jail on the first two charges and the same sentence on the nuisance count, the term of imprisonment on the latter to commence immediately upon the expiration of the first. George Goodenough, Dors Jensen, Clyde Clark and W. Southward were arraigned on liquor charges and asked more time to plead. George W. Briggs arraigned this morning charged with possession of property designed for the manufacture of moonshine plead guilty and was fined $100 with a term in the Bonneville county jail as alternative. He was given a stay of execution for ten days. The case of Frank Alfred Jensen who plead guilty to auto theft was removed to the eastern division from the Boise district by consent of counsel.
Thor Daniels formerly mail carrier on the rural route from Pocatello to Pauline was arraigned on a charge of theft of government mail sacks and plead guilty. He will be sentenced later. Jennie A. Logan, former postmistress at Arbon, charged with the embezzlement of postoffice funds to the amount of $419.06 was arraigned and will plead Monday.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, October 17, 1925, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, September 5, 1925, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, October 18, 1925, page 6
- American Falls Press, March 17, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, June 29, 1922, page 7
- Find a Grave, memorial 75611002, Jennie Rust Logan (1888–1974)
- The first written history of the valley, Stories, on this site
