They were born ten weeks apart in 1875, one in Utah and one in Iowa, and both ended up farming the valley southwest of Pocatello that came to carry the Arbon name. In 1972 and 1973 they died in Pocatello within eight months of each other. Joseph N. “Joe” Arbon, the valley’s first Latter-day Saint bishop, died on September 23, 1972. William Allard, the first valley man found in the Idaho Legislature, followed him on May 6, 1973.
The bishop
Joe Arbon was born at Snowville, Utah, on September 25, 1875, a son of George and Sarah Nicholas Arbon. In the early 1890s he and his father came into what people then called Bannock Valley. Melinda Campbell’s Joseph Nicholas Arbon, his family’s account, tells his whole life, those first winters included. On November 23, 1898, he married Elizabeth Davis in the Salt Lake Temple.
When Mrs. E. A. Logan wrote a long history of the valley’s settlement for the American Falls Press in March 1917, she listed J. N. Arbon among the original pioneers who still lived there, along with D. J. Bowen, J. R. Bailey, E. H. Davis, L. B. Evans and “the Anderson boys.” She praised his farm as one of the best kept in the valley and ranked him with its leading farmers. She also called him Bishop, though church records show his first term had ended in 1914. He was called to the office again in 1925, saw the ward through the building of its 1928 meetinghouse and served on into the 1930s. The first bishop sets out those dates.
The homesteader who went to Boise
William Allard was born in Dallas County, Iowa, on December 5, 1875, to Nathaniel and Emma Wilhelm Allard. He married Matilda Dundore at Perry, Iowa, on September 15, 1897, and reached the valley some years after the Arbons. On April 13, 1909, he filed a homestead entry on a quarter section in township 10 south, range 33 east.
Proving up meant showing, with witnesses, that a settler had lived on the claim and farmed it for the years the law required. In June 1913 the American Falls Press ran Allard’s notice that he would make his final proof on July 23 before the U.S. commissioner at American Falls, and all four of his witnesses were Arbon men. His patent was signed on March 7, 1914.
The valley belonged to Oneida County until 1913, when it was taken into the new Power County, and Allard went to the Idaho House for Power County in the 1915 session and again in 1919–20. The story is told in the first legislator from the valley. Mrs. Logan’s 1917 history recalled his election two years earlier, judged his service in the lower house a credit to him and said his neighbors held him in high regard. The Stories pages also find him on a night rescue on the Pauline road in 1919 and at the founding of the Arbon Valley Grange in 1933.
September 1972
Joe Arbon died at his Pocatello home on Saturday, September 23, 1972, after a lengthy illness, two days short of his 97th birthday. The Salt Lake Tribune and the Provo Daily Herald both ran his obituary on September 26, the Provo paper pointing out that his daughter, Mrs. Delta Harmon, lived in that city. Elizabeth had died in January 1957, and in February 1958 he had married Arvilla Hughes McKay. She survived him, as did his sons, Joseph G. Arbon of Pocatello and Dr. Harold D. Arbon of Salinas, California; his daughter, Delta; a foster daughter, Ora Darling; and stepchildren.
Both obituaries placed the Arbons among the first five families to settle the valley. James R. Bailey’s family account on this site agrees, counting the Arbons among “the first five families” along with the Baileys and the Andersens. Exactly which five is still an open question, and the 1917 history had named a longer list of first settlers. Both papers also gave him 26 years as bishop of the Arbon Ward, but the church records behind the first-bishop story show fewer.
He was buried in Pocatello’s Mountain View Cemetery after a funeral in Pocatello on Tuesday, September 26.
One mourner’s trip made the news nine days later. Ada Bailey wrote the Clifton column for the Cache Citizen, from Franklin County, Idaho, and on October 5 she reported that she and her daughter, Mrs. Dorothy Owen, had gone to Pocatello that Tuesday for the services. She called the dead man “Bishop Joe Arbon,” and explained that he had been her bishop in Arbon. Ada was a daughter of John C. Andersen and grew up in the valley. As the Andersen family history records, she married Charles Kerr Bailey in 1928, and the couple lived at Arbon until they moved to Clifton in 1940; Joe Arbon was bishop for at least part of that time. Thirty-two years after leaving, she still gave him the title.
May 1973
William Allard died of natural causes in a Pocatello hospital on Sunday, May 6, 1973, at 97. Matilda had died in 1951, and on August 12 of that year he had married Lettie Rice. He belonged to Central Christian Church in Pocatello, and the Deseret News notice of May 8 set his funeral there for Tuesday afternoon, with burial in Mountain View Cemetery, the same ground where Joe Arbon had been laid eight months before.
The notice summed him up in two terse lines: “Pioneer Arbon Valley farmer. Power County legislator 2 terms.” The state’s record of his service, in 1915 and 1919–20, bears out the two terms. He left his widow, a son, Charles, and two daughters, Margaret (Mrs. Gardner) and Eleanor. The scanned page garbles Eleanor’s married name, which other records give as Nuckols. The family asked that gifts be sent to the Idaho Youth Ranch.
By the family’s account, Eleanor and her husband, J. D. Nuckols, had farmed the Allard homestead on the Knox Canyon Road since 1951. Their son Dan later wrote in Remembering Arbon that he grew up on the place from 1951 through 1973, the year his grandfather died. The old Allard homestead house burned in 1981. But in the spring William Allard died, sixty years after he proved up on it, his grandson was still growing up on the quarter section.