Anyone driving out from Pocatello in the fall of 1947 crossed the mountains through Caribou National Forest, and then, as Melba Rae Barnett told it, the valley opened up all at once below the road. From above, its farms looked to her like a “patch-work quilt”: wheat coming up green on the slopes, pale stubble, fresh plowing on the bottom ground and cut hay lying alongside, with white farmhouses and red barns dotted through it all.
Barnett, of Pocatello, was a student in the University of Idaho’s school of journalism. Her portrait of Arbon Valley ran on page 3 of the Pocatello Tribune on November 12, 1947. It covered no single piece of news. She set out instead to describe the whole place, and she happened to find it in a season of change, with electric lines on the way, a better road being staked and wheat bringing good money after the lean years.
By her count some 250 people lived there, every one of them farming, a mix of early homesteaders and families who had come later. She wrote that few outsiders knew how handsome or how prosperous the valley was. She put it 25 miles southeast of Pocatello, though it lies to the southwest. Her headline went further, ranking the valley first in the West for wheat grown in proportion to its size. The article offered no figures for that, and it reads best as a young writer’s enthusiasm.
The first farm on the road in
For the valley’s history Barnett went to one of its oldest settlers, whose farm is the first a visitor reaches coming in. To her his place was the natural starting point, though she never printed his name, and neither he nor his neighbor can be identified from the article.
He and the man on the next claim had both arrived in 1912. They proved up their adjoining land together, sharing the work, and stuck it out through dry years and hard frosts alike. The Depression was what parted them. The neighbor gave up and let 600 acres go for $1,000, and Barnett wrote that many other valley families had sold out in much the same way. She did not say how many, or where they went.
The settler stayed. In 1947 a single 160-acre field of his grew a grain crop worth $9,000, and someone offered him $8,000 cash for that field alone. His old partner had taken roughly $1.67 an acre; this buyer was offering $50.
Lights and a road
The farmer was proud of the year’s changes. Electric appliances were going into the house, and he expected before long to be done with his Delco generating plant and with the lamps he had been filling with gasoline and kerosene. The Tribune’s news columns bear him out. In early September the paper reported that Idaho Power was building an 88-mile line over the Mink Creek divide to serve the Rattlesnake, Arbon and Crystal sections, with C and L Electric of Pocatello as contractor and service expected late that fall. Taken together, the two reports point to 1947 as the year electric power reached this part of the valley, though another account on the site’s Firsts page gives 1945. The new lines turn up in the papers again in 1954, coated in frozen fog.
Barnett also saw white stakes marking the route of an oiled highway, something residents had long been asking for. With roughly six feet of snow in a usual winter, she expected the new road to keep the valley reachable the year around. Which road it was, she did not say. In January a valley delegation had asked Bannock County to fix the Mink Creek road, and the commissioners answered that it belonged to the state. Conrad Kelly, the district highway engineer, had already told the group the state listed it among its planned secondary roads and expected crews to regrade and straighten stretches of it during 1947. The site’s Firsts page dates the first oiled road to August 1948, when bids were called to surface State Highway 37 at the Buist end, though other accounts there disagree.
A good year, with a caution
Barnett called 1947 the sixth good season running, with heavy yields, firm grain prices and thriving stock. She gave the credit to methods the valley’s farmers had worked out through years of trial on their own ground.
The Tribune’s crop reports that summer were less rosy for this corner of the county. Frost had struck Arbon and Crystal harder than anywhere else in Power County, cutting yields by 20 to 30 percent and far more on some farms, and some grain had been mowed for hay. The county as a whole still brought in a bumper crop.
Her last word was for the people who had left. Those who sold out, she wrote, now wished they had not, while the ones who stayed had proved they could “take it” long before good times arrived. Some of the leavers had not forgotten the place. Three months after the feature, on February 14, 1948, present and former residents gathered in Pocatello for a reunion, with about 500 expected. The families scattered by drought and debt in Crystal and Buist were part of that story, and the valley’s farms kept changing hands through the years that followed, as the want ads of 1946 to 1959 record. Twenty years on, the families who had moved away came home again for the 1967 reunion.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, November 12, 1947, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, January 7, 1947, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, July 10, 1947, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, August 6, 1947, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, September 3, 1947, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, September 7, 1947, page 12
- Pocatello Tribune, February 8, 1948, page 18
- Pocatello Tribune, February 15, 1948, page 2