Two men came over from Oregon to Arbon Valley in 1910 and took up land together. One was a bachelor named Paul A. Smith, whom people called Cy. The other was Frank Turner. For the next four decades the papers caught them only now and then, a line in the Arbon news here, a schoolchild’s note there. In 1953 they died within about three months of each other, both in Pocatello hospitals.
Smith’s death came first, in the middle of January. The Deseret News and the Salt Lake Tribune each carried his obituary on January 15, 1953, and nearly everything known of his early years comes from it. He had been ill only briefly. He was a Pennsylvanian, born at Johnstown as best the scans can be read, since the town’s name is blurred in both papers. As a young man he went west, settling first near Medicine Lake, Oregon. In 1910 he moved on to Arbon Valley, where, according to the obituary, he homesteaded with Frank A. Turner.
Out of Oregon
Turner’s own obituary, which ran in the Salt Lake Tribune on April 19, 1953, survives only as a badly jumbled scan, though parts of it can be made out. It seems to give his parents as David and May Turner and to place his early years at Dayton and later at an Oregon lake whose name is broken, most likely Medicine Lake again. His Dayton was probably the one in Washington. The census names Washington as his birthplace, Dayton, Washington, turns up among the survivors in the obituary, and that town sent a good many families into the valley between 1909 and 1916. Some of them are found in the Summit area history, and one, Ben Messinger, in the Stories entry on his death.
On August 31, 1911, the Arbon news in the American Falls Press had Frank Turner home again after working at Blue Lakes, Oregon. The papers never say whether Blue Lakes and Medicine Lake were one and the same.
Arbon belonged to Oneida County when the partners arrived. Power County was carved out in 1913, taking in the Arbon end of the valley and leaving Buist, at the south end, in Oneida; the Buist area history covers that part of the valley.
In the spring of 1914 Smith was among the Arbon men who put their names to a resolution of the United Bannock Valley Booster Association. It backed granting a right of way to a company that meant to carry the valley’s grain to the railroad in cars slung over a single rail set high on a line of posts. The Press of April 9, 1914, reprinted a full account of the meeting, apparently taken from a Pocatello paper. The boosters’ slogan promised a railroad in “the next hundred days instead of the next hundred years.”
Proving up
Turner settled down to farm and raise a family. The 1915 news columns speak of Mrs. Frank Turner and the children. Spring crops failed that year, which made beardless barley hard to come by, and late in 1915 he sold a big lot of it. When Arbon held its Pioneer Day celebration in July 1916, he served on the committee listed as “Brush for Bowery,” which cut the branches that roofed the shade shelter.
The Frank Turner of the news columns was almost surely the Charles F. Turner of the land and census books. The Power County draft list of September 1918 printed him as Charles Franklin Turner of Arbon, and the 1950 census has him as Charles F. Turner. Only Smith’s obituary gives him the middle initial A.
To win title to a homestead, a settler had to live on the claim and farm it for a fixed term before he could “prove up” and get a patent, the government’s deed. The land-office records gathered for this site show that the partners ended up with separate claims. Turner, as Charles F. Turner, was granted 120 acres near Arbon on January 8, 1918. Smith was granted 330 acres several miles south, near Buist, on June 12, 1918.
By then Smith had gone to war. He enlisted during the First World War, and his obituary says he spent two years overseas with an army supply train. In later life he belonged to the American Legion post at Malad, the seat of Oneida County.
The influenza epidemic reached the Turner home that autumn. The Arbon news reported the whole family “seriously ill with influenza, all being down at once,” printing his name as Frank C. Turner, with Mrs. Arbon and Mrs. Davis helping them as they could.
Notes from the schoolhouse
Through the winter of 1923–24 the Press ran news written by pupils in the country schools, Valley View School at Arbon among them. The children kept track of the roads, the sick, the trips to Malad and Frank Turner’s catch of coyotes. Without meaning to, they also kept track of the old partners.
Paul Smith had come to see the Turners on Thanksgiving, the pupils wrote in the issue of January 3, 1924. On February 28 they reported fine roads, three coyotes and two “weazles” to Turner’s credit, and another visit from Smith the week before. In the next issue the visiting ran the other way. Turner had gone to Smith’s place on a Saturday and did not get home until Thursday night, the children wrote on March 6, and on March 13 they mentioned once more that he had been out to see Paul Smith.
Under one roof
The 1950 census found the partners under one roof. It listed Paul A. Smith, 61, Pennsylvania-born, as a lodger with Charles F. Turner and his wife, Ruth, near Arbon. The enumerators also counted him at his own place on the Arbon road in Oneida County, so he appears in the census twice.
Smith never married. When he died in January 1953, he left two half-brothers in Pennsylvania, Melvin Neff of Bethlehem and Edward Neff of Templeton.
Turner outlived him by little more than three months. He died early on Saturday, April 18, 1953, in a Pocatello hospital after a short illness, and the Tribune remembered him as a “pioneer farmer of Arbon Valley.” The readable parts of his obituary say nothing of Smith, and the scan is too damaged to tell whether the rest did. It is Smith’s notice that names the partner he came with in 1910. The school notes and census lines fill in the rest: the two men were still keeping company more than forty years on.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 31, 1911, page 8
- American Falls Press, April 9, 1914, page 1
- American Falls Press, September 2, 1915, page 8
- American Falls Press, December 2, 1915, page 3
- American Falls Press, August 3, 1916, page 4
- American Falls Press, October 18, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 1, 1918, page 5
- American Falls Press, January 3, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 6, 1924, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1924, page 3
- Deseret News, January 15, 1953, page 21
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 15, 1953, page 19
- Salt Lake Tribune, April 19, 1953, page 47
- Homestead patent to Charles F. Turner, January 8, 1918 (IDBL 0007518)
- Homestead patent to Paul A. Smith, June 12, 1918 (IDBL 0013766)
- 1950 U.S. census, Power County, Idaho, enumeration district 39-11
- 1950 U.S. census, Oneida County, Idaho, enumeration district 36-3