Every harvest, Arbon Valley’s wheat came out the same way: north down Bannock Creek, across the Fort Hall Indian Reservation, and on to the railroad. By the winter of 1930–31 that road was in poor repair, and the people who used it had run out of ways to pay for it. On the afternoon of January 14, 1931, a gathering in Pocatello chose a committee to take the problem to the state highway department in Boise.
A road with no taxpayers along it
The trouble was the land the road crossed. Reservation ground paid no taxes, so the Power County commissioners had little to keep the road up with. The Pocatello Tribune of December 24, 1930, said the Pocatello chamber of commerce had a remedy in mind. An emergency federal highway appropriation under the Colton-Oddie bill could cover the entire cost of federal roads through Indian reservations and untaxed public lands, and the chamber wanted a share of it.
Paul V. Nash, the chamber’s secretary, laid out the valley’s side. By his figures, farmers hauled 300,000 bushels of wheat a year over this farm-to-market road. With no other money to be had, he said, they had formed a highway district, bonded themselves for $50,000 and spent it trying to improve the road. Nash told the paper the district had been formed “last year,” but Highway District No. 3 was voted in on June 12, 1918, and its bonds were approved that fall, as the 1921 road-money post tells from the American Falls Press. A year after that vote the district set to work on the Bannock Creek road, as told in a new road in a dry year. It was not the first fight over the route, either. The Arbon road controversy tells how a new county road was laid across the reservation in 1915.
On December 31 a Washington dispatch reported that Senator Thomas and Congressman Addison T. Smith had pressed the director of public roads to earmark part of the three million dollars on hand under the Colton-Oddie law for the Arbon road over the Indian lands. The bureau’s reply was that it was waiting to hear from Idaho’s commissioner of public works in Boise.
A committee for Boise
So the work turned toward Boise. On January 14 men from Arbon and American Falls joined the chamber’s forum luncheon at the Bannock hotel, and that afternoon the American Falls and Pocatello chambers and the Arbon Valley people sat down together in the Pocatello chamber’s office. All of them wanted federal money put into the Bannock Creek road to Arbon.
They spoke of it as a grain road above all. Each harvest the valley’s growers hauled a large share of their crop into Pocatello for shipping, and where the road ran through the reservation, Indian farmers depended on it as well. The committee called the road a bad one. Its hope was to get enough of the federal aid in the state highway department’s keeping to fix it.
Requests had already gone to the highway department, and the committee’s job was to follow them up. The Tribune expected three men to make the trip: Nash; Roy Lindley of Arbon, who chaired the Power County commissioners; and Irvin Allred, the county surveyor. Nash and Lindley set out for Boise that same night. Lindley appears again on this site in Roy Lindley and the golden eagle. By the Tribune of January 15, some 20 miles of the road lay within the reservation, where Indian and white farmers both relied on it, and the chamber counted it every bit as vital to Arbon Valley’s wheat growers.
Bad news in Boise
In Boise the men saw Governor C. Ben Ross and Alvin Harbour, commissioner of public works, along with Allred and Power County’s state senator, L. L. Evans. The paper names him only as being from Power County. He was probably Lorenzo L. Evans of American Falls (1857–1934), already known as Senator L. L. Evans in 1918, of the American Falls Evans family rather than the Arbon one.
What they heard was discouraging: Idaho had already used up its Colton-Oddie share. The next best course was to have the Bannock Creek road taken into the state highway system, which would make it eligible when the next Colton-Oddie money came along. An earlier highway designation is recorded under the first state highway. In March 1931 the chamber raised the road with the governor once more over breakfast and learned that an amendment pending to the Colton-Oddie law might reach roads like Arbon’s. The chamber’s good-will tour that May was to close with a supper meeting at Arbon on May 8; no account of that evening has turned up.
Before the tribal council
On Friday afternoon, April 22, 1932, Nash and members of the chamber’s road committee drove to the Fort Hall agency. In Superintendent Fred Gross’s office they met the tribal council and a group from Arbon Valley. The Tribune now reckoned the valley’s crop at three-quarters of a million bushels a year, all of it carried 25 miles across the reservation. As the paper understood it, Power County’s highway districts one and three had already spent around $100,000 building and maintaining the road, and the Interior Department had made it a county road in 1918.
The plan looked to three sources: Colton-Oddie funds, an allotment from the Indian department, and a place in the state highway system for the stretch from Michaud to the reservation line. The report leaves out what the council thought.
In August 1932, with big crops about to roll, the chamber urged the governor to act. Late in July 1933 Pocatello heard that the state was finally asking for a real sum. J. H. Stemmer, Idaho’s director of highways, had asked the Interior Department for $150,000 from the public works fund for Indian reservation roads, to repair and resurface the highway across the reservation to Arbon Valley. That November the chamber’s road committee was still planning to seek the money.
The papers read here show none of it spent on the road by the end of 1933. The story goes on in Arbon’s wheat road across the reservation, 1934–1939, starting with the governor’s inspection in 1934. When the Indian Bureau turned the farmers down in 1936, the cost of the work seems to have been put at $150,000, the very figure asked for three years before.
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, January 14, 1931, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, December 24, 1930, page 10
- Pocatello Tribune, December 31, 1930, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, January 9, 1931, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, January 12, 1931, page 2
- Pocatello Tribune, January 14, 1931, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, January 15, 1931, page 12
- Pocatello Tribune, January 20, 1931, page 7
- Pocatello Tribune, March 15, 1931, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, March 23, 1931, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, April 23, 1932, page 3
- Pocatello Tribune, August 5, 1932, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, July 30, 1933, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, November 3, 1933, page 8