C. W. Gray came back from Arbon in May 1913 full of praise for what he had seen. He had expected a small valley. Instead he found one six miles wide and thirty long, with “practically no rocks,” good well water at twenty-five to sixty feet, and nine-tenths of its land already filed on by settlers who “were out to a man” for the meeting he had just held there.
Gray and A. R. Dawson, secretary of the Pocatello Commercial Club, got home on May 5. The next day the Pocatello Tribune put their report on its front page under the headline “MARKET MAKERS FOR POCATELLO.” The farmers were taking up subscriptions, the paper said, and the road over the divide by way of Trail Creek “will undoubtedly be finished this summer.” A finished road would mean a farmers’ elevator in Pocatello and thousands of dollars of trade for the town. The valley’s wheat would come to Pocatello rather than going to American Falls or Malad.
That was the hope. The Tribune had been chasing it since the previous September, and it would be stalled by the end of June.
Three hundred thousand bushels
The campaign began on September 10, 1912, when A. A. Affleck of Arbon, “delegated to come to Pocatello,” appeared before the Bannock County commissioners alongside a group of Pocatello merchants. He was almost certainly Adam “Add” Affleck, son-in-law of T. B. Evans. His district, he told the board, would thresh 300,000 bushels of Turkey Red wheat that year. The year before, 150,000 bushels had gone by wagon to Michaud siding, and because the roads to Pocatello were so poor, most of the valley’s trading had been done in American Falls.
The commissioners voted $500 for “immediate repairs to the Trail creek road” and named Lyman Fargo trustee. By September 25 the contractor reported eleven bridges done on “the Arbon road.” Just which road got the money is uncertain. In December L. B. Evans of the Arbon Commercial Club, probably Ren Evans, told Pocatello that the county had promised Trail Creek but spent the $500 on the Michaud Creek road instead, the road that carried the valley’s business to American Falls.
The other way over the mountains was no better. The county road across the Mink Creek divide, put through around 1909, climbed too steeply for heavy loads, and a patch of “muck” at the summit shut it every fall, winter and spring. In November Sam G. Garbett, once a Pocatello councilman and lately a homesteader in the Rattlesnake Creek district, counted three spots on it that were close to impassable. So the grain went the long way, around by Michaud or down to American Falls.
A divided valley
By March 1913 a better line had been surveyed over the Trail Creek divide, the Tribune said, and settlers at Crystal, Pauline, Rattlesnake, Bannock Valley and Arbon were ready to turn out with men and teams to build their own end. The paper often still called the whole valley Bannock Valley. But the valley now belonged to the new Power County, and its commissioners were “not overly anxious” to help. The roads running down the valley already made American Falls, their county seat, the nearest market.
Nor did the valley speak with one voice. On April 3 Affleck was back in Pocatello at the Commercial Club’s dinner as “a committee of one” for the farmers. Those at the lower end of the valley wanted Trail Creek, while most of the settlers on Rattlesnake Creek, around Crystal and Pauline, would sooner have had the Mink Creek road fixed. The club’s highway committee and the Bannock commissioners planned to look over both routes on April 26.
Then came the Arbon meeting. Short talks were given by Dawson, Gray and three valley men the paper called Allard, Afflick and Carvallis. The farmers chose a committee to speak for them at the club’s business lunch on Thursday the 8th, and James Dawson, Henry Daniels and Joseph Evans, named by the paper as “the Commercial club committee,” were to cross the divide, meet the Arbon farmers at Birch Creek and carry the question to the club. A Henry Daniels of the Daniels family took up a homestead on the West Fork, but the article does not make clear whose side those three men represented.
Pocatello was not alone in courting the valley. The American Falls Press reported that an unnamed party from Pocatello was in Arbon the day before Power County’s commissioners got there on May 8, offering to pay part of a $10,000 road over the mountains if the valley found the rest. That visit came too late to have been Dawson and Gray’s.
Pledges and red tape
For a few weeks the money seemed to be coming. By May 15 Pocatello had $1,000 subscribed, the farmers had promised $1,000 in cash and work, and Bannock County would build its own side as far as the Power County line. A week on, the Arbon committee could show only $400 pledged, and its list went back with a request to bring it up to the agreed $1,000; Pocatello’s committee had $900. On June 3 some fifty businessmen counted the town’s pledges at about $1,200 and appointed committees to call on the commissioners and on the Fort Hall agency about a right of way.
That was as far as it went. “HALTS PLANS FOR TRAIL CREEK ROAD,” ran the Tribune’s headline on June 26. The road had to cross the Fort Hall reservation, and Fletcher Burrus of the right-of-way committee had heard from the superintendent, Major Evan W. Estep, that Power County’s commissioners would have to make a formal application with a survey and a map. A survey had priced the road and its bridges at $7,500. About $2,200 had been raised or promised. On the same page the paper noted that J. H. Kowalis of Arbon, as it spelled the name, was in town “to push the Trail creek road plan.”
By late August Garbett was complaining again. The Mink Creek road was useless, he said, and the new owners of the McCammon flour mill were working out a road from Rattlesnake to their own town. “Pocatello seems to be soundly sleeping,” he said.
No report has turned up that the Trail Creek road was built in 1913, or that Power County ever applied for the right of way. In 1916 the club appointed another committee to study a wagon road of some forty miles by way of Trail Creek, in the same years that the valley’s hopes for a line were rising and falling, as told in the railroad that never came. The American Falls side of that spring is told in Power County’s own tour of the valley roads. It was 1919 before a state highway from Pocatello to Arbon was designated, six summers after the Tribune had called the road as good as finished.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, May 6, 1913, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
MARKET MAKERS FOR POCATELLO
Proposition to Build Road Form Arbon Valley Heartily Approved by Farmers.
A R. Dawson, secretary of the Commercial club, and C. W. Gray, returned yesterday, from Arbon, Idaho, where they held a farmers’ meeting in regard to the road over the divide by the way of Trail creek. The farmers were interested in the matter and are taking an active part towards getting up subscriptions and the road will undoubtedly be finished this summer, making it possible for the farmers to market their grain in Pocatello.
Arbon Valley is one of the richest valleys in the state and the result of the completion of this road means a farmers’ elevator in Pocatello, and thousands of dollars worth of business to the town. American Falls wants the road, but the farmers in that locality are more favorable to Pocatello, citing that they can get better prices here. If the farmers are in favor of Pocatello the business men should do all in their power to assist them in getting the road.
A committee was appointed among the farmers to represent them at the Commercial Club business meeting and lunch, Thursday, the 8th. James Dawson. Henry Daniels and Joseph Evans, the Commercial club committee, will leave in the morning over the divide, meeting the Arbon farmers at Birch creek, and will look over Pocatello to take the matter up before the club.
Short talks were made at the meeting by A. D. Dawson, C. W. Gray, and Messrs Allard, Afflick and Carvallis.
When seen this morning at his office on North Main street Mr. Gray had the following to say about that splendid farming country and the people over there:
“I was greatly surprised to find such a large valley and more surprised to find that nine-tenths of the land has already been filed upon by bona-fide settlers. They are ready and anxious to do anything which will bring them within closer touch with the people and City of Pocatello. Arbon Valley is about six miles wide by thirty miles long—has 180 square miles or 115,200 acres. There is a strip of this land just the other side of the divide which belongs to the Indians but most of it has been leased by white men. This land is only five miles from Pocatello and the farthest portion of the Arbon coutry is about 30 miles, which means, with the aid of the new road over the divide, that Pocatello will be brought in direct touch with this wonderful fertile valley. The soil is the very finest, it is dark to black sandy loam and there are practically no rocks. The altitude is from 400 to 1000 feet higher than Pocatello which assures us that the dry farms there will yield big returns. A dry farm to be successful must be above a certain altitude and of course not too high, which exactly fits the description of Arbon Valley. The drinking water is as good as we have here in Pocatello. I was surprised to learn that they can get excellent water in wells from twenty-five to sixty feet deep. The people are boosters, they work together and were out to a man when we had our meeting because they are all anxious to do anything which will better their conditions. They are good neighbors and their business is a mighty big thing for Pocatello.”
Sources
- Pocatello Tribune, May 6, 1913, page 1
- Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, May 7, 1913, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, September 11, 1912, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, September 23, 1912, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, September 25, 1912, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, November 26, 1912, page 1
- American Falls Press, December 26, 1912, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, March 22, 1913, page 4
- Pocatello Tribune, April 4, 1913, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, April 14, 1913, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, April 25, 1913, page 1
- American Falls Press, May 15, 1913, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, May 17, 1913, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, May 23, 1913, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, June 4, 1913, page 8
- Pocatello Tribune, June 26, 1913, page 1
- Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, June 28, 1913, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, August 27, 1913, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, October 1, 1916, page 14
