On the morning of Wednesday, December 4, 1912, a man from Crystal stepped up at the Bannock County courthouse in Pocatello to ask for a marriage license, and he was asked whether he was the same Whiting who had taken one out just a few minutes before. He was not. He was that man’s brother, and neither of them, the Pocatello Tribune reported that same day, had known the other was getting married.
The two couples had come down separately from Crystal, the new settlement in the high basin north of Pauline. The first license went to Lorenzo Whiting Jr. and Pearline Fanning, 17, the daughter of Moses Fanning of Crystal, whose consent had been given to the clerk. President W. A. Hyde of the Latter-day Saint church married them before noon. He was very probably the stake president; the Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune appears to give him that title in 1910. The paper does not say where that ceremony took place.
Next in line were Farris Whiting and Margery Butterfield, also of Crystal. She was 17 as well, and her father had likewise consented. Once Deputy Clerk Pomeroy had sorted out the mix-up for them, the pair went off to find someone to perform the ceremony, and Judge Budge married them right there in the courthouse. “Usually one brother knows about the other brother’s business,” the reporter observed, “but in this case neither one knew of the other ones affair.” Why each kept his plans to himself, and whether their families were in on it, the story never says.
The Tribune printed the item under the headline “Double Marriage at Court House.” Three days later, on December 7, the Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune ran it again word for word, minus the subheading.
Neighbors from the start
The paper did not spell the families’ names as they did. The bride’s people wrote theirs Fannin, and “Farris” was Forres Whiting, called Farr at home. In the county marriage register, as indexed in the Western States Marriage Record Index, the two weddings sit on consecutive pages, 421 and 422 of volume 5: Lorenzo S. Whiting Jr. with Pearlina Fannin, then Forres Whiting with Margery Butterfield, his name indexed as “Fones.” The index puts the second marriage on December 3, a day early. Because the paper is plain that both licenses came the same morning, and the entries follow the paper’s order, that date is probably a slip, though only the register itself could settle it.
The Whitings were among the first families to take up land in the Crystal basin. Final-proof notices in the American Falls Press of January 1913 show Lorenzo S. Whiting Jr. and Forres Whiting, both then given as of Robin in Marsh Valley, entering adjoining homesteads at Crystal on one day, June 28, 1909. Their father, Lorenzo S. Whiting Sr., filed on his own claim that December, and the family turn up as witnesses for one another. By November 1911 a land-office notice already called Moses Fannin “of Crystal” when it named him as a witness to a neighbor’s final proof.
Family records gathered for this site give both grooms’ ages as twenty-eight. They also show that Pearline, known as Pearl, lost her mother, Sebra, in 1902, so the “Mrs. Fanning” in the article was her stepmother, Cora. Margery, whose father the article leaves unnamed, was the daughter of C. R. Butterfield, who brought his family up from Rockland to the new settlement in 1910 and 1911.
Bishop and counselor
Both couples stayed and built their lives at Crystal. In May 1915 the first Crystal column to appear in the American Falls Press reported that the small child of “Forest” Whiting had died at the Whiting home on Sunday, April 18, and was buried on the Whiting farm. Forres is very probably meant, and this site counts it as the first recorded burial at Crystal.
Lorenzo Jr., known as Len, followed his father-in-law, Moses Fannin, as bishop of the Crystal Ward from about 1923, according to ward records and family accounts, and Forres served as his first counselor in 1925 and 1926. Pearl taught Sunday school and sat in the Relief Society presidency. The brothers’ younger siblings had their own place in the basin’s story: Ralph and Reese raised wheat there, as told in Crystal, the hidden settlement up Rattlesnake Creek, and the settlement turned out for their sister in All of Crystal plants a widow’s grain. The Whitings, Fannins and Butterfields appear together again in Crystal almost deserted, winter 1923–24.
In the end drought and the Depression drove them out. Family memoirs say that sometime after mid-1931 Len took most of the ward, the Fannins with them, to a ranch near Salmon, a move told in Drought and debt empty Crystal and Buist. The Crystal area history follows the basin further. Margery died at Salmon in September 1933, and Forres died at Idaho Falls in 1938.
Of the morning in 1912 when two brothers surprised a courthouse, the record keeps only the paper’s one explanation: neither knew.
The original article
Pocatello Tribune, December 4, 1912, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan. The article is printed as a single paragraph. At the start of two lines the first letter did not print: “utterfield” is given here as [B]utterfield, which the marriage register confirms, and the word before “the second Whiting” shows only “hen” (When or Then), so it is marked illegible. The broken “kr. ws” is read as “knows.”
DOUBLE MARRIAGE AT COURT HOUSE
Two Brothers From Crystal Apply for Licenses Without the Knowledge of Each Other.
Marriage licenses were issued this morning to Miss Pearline Fanning, age 17 years, and Mr. Lorenzo Whiting Jr., both of Crystal, Idaho. The bride is the daughter of Mr. and Mrs. Moses Fanning of Crystal, and the consent of the father was given to the clerk to procure the license. President W. A. Hyde of the L. D. S. church performed the ceremony, during the forenoon today, Miss Margery [B]utterfield and Mr. Farris Whiting, both of Crystal were also granted a marriage license. This ceremony was performed by Judge Budge in the court house. It was a rare occurrence, in the two cases, usually one brother knows about the other brother’s business, but in this case neither one knew of the other ones affair. [illegible] the second Whiting was asked if he was the same Whiting that had procured a marriage license just a few minutes before. After Deputy Clerk Pomeroy had explained the whole affair to the bride and groom they proceeded to get the necessary party to tie the knot. In this last case the father of the girl gave his consent to the marriage. The girl is only 17.
