On the last night of 1910, with a storm blowing outside, twenty-eight people at the Arbon schoolhouse dropped paper ballots into a box to settle which county they belonged to. Twenty-six chose the new one. It was the second time in two years the valley had voted that way, and it would not be the last.
Until then Arbon was a precinct of Oneida County, run from the county seat at Malad, over the hills to the south. In November 1908 the American Falls Press took up the cause of a new county centered on American Falls, to be called Power County. Getting to Malad from American Falls, the paper complained, meant “having to travel through two states and passing through two other county seats before arriving there.”
Nineteen to two
Arbon’s place in the plan was argued over before the valley had a say. At that year’s Republican county convention, by the Press’s telling, the Malad delegation spoke through T. D. Jones and asked that the Arbon precinct stay in Oneida. The American Falls and Rockland men would not agree, pointing out that Arbon people had already petitioned to come in, and the two sides settled on letting Arbon decide.
Three valley men called a meeting: David Roderick, Bishop Joseph Arbon, and one the digitized page calls only Bert, likely Bert Evans, son of Tom Evans. Nobody came from Malad or from American Falls. Around the middle of December 1908 a letter arrived in American Falls with the outcome: the people had decided “by a vote of 19 to 2” to join the new county.
“A small uprising in Arbon”
The legislature met in January 1909. Representative I. B. Evans of Oneida wrote to “his brother at Arbon,” the Press said, and heard back that the valley meant to come in. The paper did not say which brother; the lawmaker was most likely Isaac B. Evans, whose brothers Tom, Ren and Dave lived in the valley. In February the Power County bill was killed, then revived under the name Shoup County.
Then L. D. Jones and other Malad men arrived in Boise carrying petitions against taking in Arbon. The Press, firmly for the new county, shot back:
It should be borne in mind that not a single resident appeared from Arbon to enter a protest. There were two petitions bearing the names of fifty-three persons, a number less than half the voting population.
It doubted that one of the petitions was genuine, while insisting American Falls did “not want it against the will of the people.” The bill got through the House. On Saturday, March 6, 1909, the Senate killed it by a single vote after three senators who had supported it turned against it. The Press recorded one man’s explanation:
Senator Freehafer changed his vote, he said, because his friend L. D. Jones had told him there was a small uprising in Arbon against the bill. Twice it has fallen to the lot of Senator Freehafer to prevent the creation of a county here.
That version of the petitions comes from a Press editorial written in reply to the Malad Idaho Enterprise. The Malad paper’s own account has not been found.
Ballots, not petitions
When the county question came around again in the winter of 1910–11, the Press said Arbon would decide it by ballot this time, so no late petitions could undo it. The meeting was set for the schoolhouse on Saturday night, December 31, 1910.
The Malad side got there first. Mr. Jones and Mr. Thomas spent two days going among the valley’s people before the meeting. Five men came out from American Falls, three of them riding in Walter Sparks’s automobile, the first the records place in the valley.
The Malad pair were late to the meeting itself. McKown of American Falls had already gone over the 1909 fight and blamed the men behind its eleventh-hour opposition, and when Jones and Thomas walked in, he said it all again to their faces. O. H. Barber followed with tax figures. Jones answered that Malad valley would not stand in the way if Arbon wanted the new county, though in his view Arbon belonged with Malad. Thomas argued that “so many of the people of Arbon had relatives in Malad” that their interests lay there.
Barber then cut the matter down to one point:
At the conclusion of Mr. Thomas’ address, Mr. Barber explained that the only thing at issue was the boundry line. ... There was no opposition so far as the matter of division was concerned. The real question was where the boundry line should be.
American Falls wanted the line drawn along the range between the Arbon and Malad valleys as far as the south line of township 12 south, which would put the valley in the new county. Malad wanted it to run along the Fort Hall Reservation line and the divide between the Arbon and Rockland valleys, which would keep the valley in Oneida.
Jones questioned whether so small a crowd could speak for the whole valley and proposed petitions instead. Barber asked whether Malad would drop its fight if the vote went for the new county. Jones did not answer. Julius Abter moved that the vote be taken as final, Jewell Horton seconded, and the motion “carried without a dissenting vote.” Tom Evans and George Butler served as judges, with Horton as clerk. The count was twenty-six for the new county and two against. The weather was very bad, the paper noted, and kept the turnout down.
109 to 30
Since a stormy-night meeting could not be called the whole valley’s voice, Arbon voted once more on Saturday, January 14, 1911. Malad was asked to send speakers and sent none. The American Falls men chalked a comparison on a blackboard: what the valley’s school districts paid in Oneida taxes, and what they would pay in the new county. Someone called at every house in the valley.
This time the result was 109 to 30 for the new county. The Press reported that “more votes were cast than at the general election” and called the gathering the biggest the valley had ever seen. It printed the result on January 21. The Salt Lake Tribune and Salt Lake Telegram ran it on February 1 in a dispatch from Rockland that put the meeting “this week,” more than two weeks late.
The 1911 bill failed all the same. In March, D. B. Ripley of Arbon told the Press that people in the valley were “much disappointed.” The papers found so far do not say why the bill died.
Power County at last
The new county finally came on January 30, 1913, carved from parts of Oneida, Bingham, Blaine and Cassia counties, with American Falls as its temporary seat. Among the governor’s first appointees the Press named “L. B. Evans, farmer; Arbon,” who was Ren Evans, Tom’s brother. How his appointment turned out is told in the story of Power County’s first probate judge, and the Evans and Arbon family histories and the Arbon area history follow the families who cast those ballots.
Three votes had been about where to draw a line, and in the end, as the site’s family timelines record, the line ran through the valley itself. The Arbon floor, Pauline and West Fork, and Crystal went to Power County. Summit and Buist stayed in Oneida.
The original article
American Falls Press, January 7, 1911, page 1. Transcribed from the digitized text of the page scan; the left edge of the column is damaged, and words lost there are marked [illegible].
[illegible] PEOPLE TO POWER COUNTY
Decision Was Reached by a Vote Last Week.
Meeting Held Last Week [illegible] Two Voted to remain in Oneida County.—The Action [illegible] Considered Final.
[illegible] meeting was held in Arbon valley last Saturday night for the purpose of giving the people of that locality an opportunity of expressing [illegible] choice as to whether they [illegible] to remain in Oneida county [illegible] included within the proposed Power county. The meeting was originally called for one o’clock [illegible], but at the instance of the Malad represenatives it was [illegible] until eight o’clock of the [illegible]. A vote was taken resulting twenty-six in favor of the new county to two against. The night was very stormy and the attendance was smaller than it would have been had good weather prevailed; however, those present came from [illegible] parts of the valley and represented the sentiment of the pople.
Two years ago the establishment [illegible] Oneida [illegible] Power County was one of the [illegible] which contributed to the defeat of the Power county bill owing [illegible] fact that at a late hour [illegible] made by a few residents [illegible] the new county. These protests were largely signed by people who had previously signed a petition asking to be included within the new county. They came at a [illegible] they could not be [illegible]. Having in view this condition [illegible] desire to prevent its recurrence it was decided to hold an election this time instead of relying upon petitions. As previously [illegible] representatives were there and [illegible] to hear what they had to say. American Falls delegates were [illegible] L. McKown and O. H. Barber. [illegible] wishing to disappoint those [illegible] come out for the purpose of [illegible] them the representatives [illegible] upon the merits of the new county and asking the people to come [illegible] on the night of the 31st when representatives from both American Falls and Malad would address them.
On Thursday of last week Mr. [illegible] D. Jones and Mr. Thomas, of Malad, arrived in Arbon valley and spent Friday and Saturday in talking to the people. Saturday morning [illegible] B. Greenwood, Walter Sparks and [illegible] L. McKown left in Mr. Spark’s automobile, and Saturday afternoon Frank Moench and O. H. Barber [illegible] by team, both parties arriving too late to mingle with the people at all, prior to the meeting [illegible]. The two later arrived at the meeting place at the school house about eight thirty o’clock. The Malad representatives had not arrived at eight thirty and believing they would not appear the meeting was called to order by Mr. Greenwood, of American Falls, who briefly stated its purpose. He introduced Mr. McKown who told of the efforts to [illegible] a new county two years ago and of the opposition which arose at a late hour, and censured those responsible for the eleventh hour opposition, for things which appeared to him to be not in accordance with the understanding which had been reached concerning division at an earlier date. He had just concluded this part of the talk when the Malad representatives entered the hall. Not wishing to say anything in their absence that he would not have said in their presence, Mr. McKown repeated the assertion which he had just made. He was followed by Mr. Barber, who confined himself to the matter of taxation in the proposed new county, comparing it with that which the people are paying in Oneida county, and submitting figures from the county records and drawing comparisons with other counties having comparatively the same [illegible] valuation and population as the proposed new county, which have a smaller tax rate than Oneida or any other large county in the state. At the conclusion of Mr. Barber’s talk L. D. Jones, of Malad, stated that if the people of the Arbon country expressed a desire to be included within the new county there would be no opposition from the people of Malad valley. He considered that the people of Arbon naturally belonged to Malad valley and would be better served in the old county than in the new, but if they expressed a desire to be included in the new county that would settle the matter with them. He reviewed the efforts of the past two sessions towards securing a division of the county and defended the cause of those who had been criticised Mr. McKown. He stated that he had no figures to give the people inasmuch as Mr. Ralph Harding, the chairman of the board of county commissioners who had expected to be present and had not arrived. He was followed by Mr. Thomas who made a talk along general lines, and who thought that owing to the fact that so many of the people of Arbon had relatives in Malad that their interests were naturally there. He stated, however that if the people of Arbon wished to be included in Power county there would be no opposition.
At the conclusion of Mr. Thomas’ address, Mr. Barber explained that the only thing at issue was the boundry line. The people of American Falls desire to follow the range dividing the Arbon and Malad valleys to the south line of township 12 south, thence directly west to the intersection with the Cassia county line. The Malad people wished the line to follow the reservation line to the crest of the divide between Arbon and Rockland valleys and thence west and along said range to its intersection with the Cassia county line. There was no opposition so far as the matter of division was concerned. The real question was where the boundry line should be.
Ballots had been printed reading, “For New County,” and “Against New County.” Mr. Barber explained that an “X” placed in the circle opposite “For New County” would be a vote to fix the line at the south line of 12 south; that a vote against the new county would be establish the line at the reservation as desired by the people at Malad. Mr. Jones at this point raised the question as to whether the attendance was large enough so that it could be said to reflect the sentiment of the entire people of the valley and asked if it would not be better to circulate petitions rather than [illegible] Barber recalled the experience of two years ago when a large number of the residents of that valley had signed petitions [illegible] of all the people and that if the vote was against coming into the new county, the new county advocates would cease their efforts to have Arbon included, and establish the line at the south line of the reservation. He asked Mr. Jones if the representatives from Malad would be willing to withdraw their opposition in case the vote showed that the people desired to be included in the new county. Mr. Jones made no reply. At this point Julius Abter moved that the vote to be taken be accepted as final, and representative of the sentiment of the people of the valley. This was seconded by Jewel Horton and carried without a dissenting vote.
At the request of the American Falls representatives judges and a clerk were selected to receive the ballots of all who cared to vote. T. B. Evans and Geo. J. Butler were selected as judges and Jewel Horton as clerk. Ballots were distributed and a recess was taken in order to permit a free mingling of the people before their ballots were deposited. After a laps of five or ten minutes the ballots were taken up and the names of the voters enrolled. Twenty-eight votes were cast, twenty-six of which were for the new county and two against it. American Falls representatives thanked the people for the preference shown and for their timerity in facing the inclement weather.
American Falls people have always claimed that three-fourths of the people of that locality desired to be included inn the new county. Two years ago at a meeting called at which neither representatives of Malad or American Falls were present, the people voted nineteen to two in favor of the new county. The result of the ballot taken on the 31st confirms the claim that the people of that section are overwhelmingly in favor of the new county and for this reason no opposition is anticipated so far as the fixing of the boundary of the south line of 12 south is concerned.
Sources
- American Falls Press, November 14, 1908, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1909, page 8
- American Falls Press, January 7, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, January 21, 1911, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, February 1, 1911, page 12
- Salt Lake Telegram, February 1, 1911, page 6
- American Falls Press, March 11, 1911, page 6
- American Falls Press, February 6, 1913, page 1
