In the winter of 1994, Oneida County decided to go after the rain itself. A short Associated Press item out of Malad, printed by the Logan Herald Journal on January 30, said the county would run its own cloud-seeding program, and that one of its first three generators was bound for Arbon Valley.
For the valley’s dryland farmers, who raise wheat without a drop of irrigation water, it was the right worry. Their crop lives on the year’s rain and snow and on whatever moisture a season of summer fallow has banked in the ground. Over the next quarter century, newspapers and farm reports kept checking in on them, and the same question came up every time: would the water arrive when the wheat needed it?
Seeding the clouds
In 1993 Oneida had gone in with Franklin, Bear Lake and Caribou counties to hire Northern Pacific Corp. to seed storms across the region. Talks among the four broke down the following year, and Oneida’s commissioners chose to carry on by themselves. Commissioner Jerry Bush said Malad would shortly take delivery of three generators, with the kits needed to convert and connect them. They would be set up the next month at Juniper, Curlew Valley and Arbon Valley, and three more would be added each year until a dozen were in place.
A generator, the item was careful to say, cannot create a storm; seeding only wrings more moisture out of one already passing. Bush thought the county could do the job alone, maybe better than before. Too many times the season before, he said, clouds had drifted across Oneida before anyone gave the word to switch the generators on.
Only the south end of Arbon Valley, around Buist, is in Oneida County; the rest has belonged to Power County since 1913. The item gave no site for the generator, and no later report has turned up to say whether it was ever installed or run.
A best-ever harvest, then heat
Good years came too. In September 2005 the farm radio program Idaho Ag Today caught the dryland grower Hans Hayden just finished with harvest south of Pocatello. The rain had given him “a wonderful winter wheat crop,” the best he had ever grown, averaging around 80 bushels an acre, with 100 bushels in places. The report never named Arbon Valley, but this is probably the same Hans Hayden whom later stories call an Arbon Valley dryland farmer. He in turn is very probably a son of Ben Hayden; the Hayden family history says Ben’s sons, Hans and Twain, worked the old Crystal homestead and a great deal more ground besides.
The year 2012 went dry. The Idaho State Journal wrote that season about the valley’s farmer firefighters, working through scant rain and hard winds, and described Hans Hayden as a “lifelong Arbon farmer.” The range fires of those years are gathered among the site’s Stories as the farmer firefighters.
Then came record heat in late June and early July 2013, with Pocatello at 101 degrees on July 1. The Capital Press, a farm weekly out of Salem, Oregon, found eastern Idaho’s dryland growers bracing for a second weak grain year in a row. Ryan Weston, who farms dryland in Arbon Valley, figured heat and drought had already cost him 90 percent of the wheat he might have grown. Only the low pockets still held healthy grain. On the hillsides, he said, there was “nothing that’s even worth running a combine through.” After 2012 he had shifted some fields to safflower, a deep-rooted crop that gets by on less water, and was counting on it. Ken Campbell had gone further still, putting in 1,500 acres of safflower against just 100 of spring wheat. His spring wheat in 2012, he said, had been “almost a total loss.” That article is reprinted on this site.
Too little, then too much
The Capital Press came back three times in 2016. In the spring, Hans Hayden spread humic acid on the snowdrifts that lingered over his fall wheat, melting them to ward off snow mold, and found much less winterkill than he had feared (April 2016). By September no rain had fallen since early June. Ken Campbell, who usually seeded fall wheat in late August or the first days of September, had to hold off until month’s end, when three inches came down in ten days. “It’s the first rains we’ve had since early June,” he said (September 2016).
The harvest that year had been big, and size had its price. Hayden’s yields ran 25 to 50 percent above normal, which spread the nitrogen thinner across each kernel, and his hard red winter wheat came in at just 8 percent protein. He mixed it with strong spring grain to scrape past milling standards. Campbell sold roughly 90 percent of his crop for feed (November 2016).
The following year was wet. On April 28, 2017, a Capital Press reporter found Twain Hayden walking a field of short winter wheat under a skiff of morning snow. The cold spring had kept it dormant, and the wet ground had stopped him from seeding any spring grain apart from a few patches lost to winterkill. Across the past 30 years, he said, their spring planting had started on average on April 19 and wrapped up on May 11. After so many bone-dry seasons he did not mind the problems of plenty: “Dryland farmers just have a really hard time complaining about moisture.” What would matter most, he thought, was being spared long stretches of 100-degree days in June.
The damp brought disease with it. In May the paper reported stripe rust on a weed growing between two irrigated spring wheat fields in the valley (May 2017). By the middle of June, Juliet Marshall, the University of Idaho’s cereals pathologist, had confirmed eyespot in fields reaching from Arbon Valley to around Blackfoot. The root rot weakens wheat at the base of the stem until the plants lodge, or fall over. She looked for losses of 20 to 40 percent, depending on how bad the infection was, and warned that dryland farms could be exposed where short rotations put wheat back on wheat.
Rain in May
The 2020 season opened poorly. Hans Hayden, farming dryland in the Power County part of the valley, told Intermountain Farm and Ranch that winter and snow had battered his late-planted winter wheat. It “looked horrible,” he said, and he reseeded most of it to spring wheat. Hail struck in April and once more early in May. Then roughly five inches of rain fell around his place in the month of May, and when he harvested in August he was “very satisfied” with his spring and winter wheat alike. The price gave less cause for cheer: hard red winter wheat brought $4.25 a bushel on August 14.
These glimpses come from a handful of farms, most of them through one reporter, John O’Connell, and they are no year-by-year record of the valley’s crop. The valley has seen worse, in the drought of 1919 and in the drought and debt that emptied Crystal and Buist. Still, across a quarter century the reports trace the dryland farmer’s lot: a record crop, two lean years, a heavy harvest too low in protein, a spring too wet to plant, and a ruined-looking field brought back by rain in May.
Sources
- Logan Herald Journal, January 30, 1994, page 3
- Idaho Ag Today, September 26, 2005
- Idaho State Journal, 2012, reprinted on ArbonValley.com, October 24, 2012
- Capital Press, July 2013, reprinted on ArbonValley.com, July 16, 2013
- Capital Press, April 20, 2016
- Capital Press, September 28, 2016, reprinted on ArbonValley.com
- Capital Press, November 10, 2016
- Capital Press, May 5, 2017, page 8
- Capital Press, May 2017, reprinted on ArbonValley.com, May 29, 2017
- Capital Press, June 16, 2017, page 8
- Intermountain Farm and Ranch, as posted by the Idaho Farm Bureau, August 19, 2020