At the Power County line in September 1962, D. T. “Sod” Williams stood on crutches and helped fasten a new sign under the “Entering Power County” marker. It offered $250 to anyone whose tip put a burglar or vandal of an Arbon Valley ranch behind bars.
Williams was president of a group the valley’s ranchers had just formed, the Arbon Valley Property Protective Association. The Idaho State Journal carried its story on page 14 on Wednesday, September 26, with a short pointer on page 1 and a photograph of Williams at the sign beside the publicity chairman, Jay Nuckles. The reward was for an informant, and it would be paid only when the information brought an arrest and a conviction for breaking into, stealing from or damaging property the association protected.
A dozen houses in one winter
The ranchers had been losing ground for several years. Every break-in cost them work and money to repair or replace what was gone, and Williams told the paper the trouble grew worse each winter. In the winter of 1961–62 alone, twelve homes had been entered. Thieves carried off or wrecked whatever they found, from bedding and saddles to television sets and kitchen pots. Williams himself was out close to $1,200 in saddles and bridles. One rancher came back in the spring to find farm machinery worth thousands of dollars welded together.
The empty houses were the problem. Few people lived in the valley to begin with, and high mountains walled it off from Pocatello to the north. When the cold came, most families moved to the towns around it, and their ranch homes sat vacant until spring. That was an old habit in the valley. In the homestead years many settlers from Cache Valley went home each fall to Mendon and its neighbors and came back north when the snow melted. Once snow closed the roads, Williams said, the valley took real effort to reach, and an outsider with honest business had little reason to try. Even outside winter the roads could fail; the floods of March 1962 had cut them off that spring.
Thefts from the outlying ranches were nothing new. In November 1950 police recovered four saddles, a bridle, a saddle blanket and several quilts, worth $600 in all, from a cellar near the 700 block of Jefferson. The paper’s headline called it an “Arbon Robbery”, but both ranches it named were at Crystal. Three saddles had gone from Henry DeValcour’s place on the weekend of November 11, and the fourth was thought to have come from the Petersen ranch the same weekend. The chief of detectives, Guy Nelson, announced the recovery, so the cellar was probably in Pocatello. Power County’s sheriff, W. J. Hoehnen, took one of the occupants and two companions to American Falls for questioning. No record of charges has turned up.
In October 1954 twenty ranchers of the Arbon and Crystal valleys had organized under the Power County sheriff as the Arbon and Crystal Valley Vigilantes, planning to take turns patrolling through the winter. Their story is told in A Stolen Pickup, a Death and the Valley Vigilantes. It is not known whether those patrols ever went out.
Watching the roads
The 1962 plan leaned on eyes rather than guns. Warning signs were going up at every road and trail into the valley, the routes over the high passes included, and each ranch home was to get a smaller sign of its own. A few ranchers would stay in the valley through the winter as lookouts, noting the license number and a description of each car that came in. Their lists would go to the sheriffs and police of Bannock, Power and Oneida counties, the three that border the valley. If a ranch was later found robbed or damaged, officers could trace the cars back to their owners.
The paper set that against the old days. In the 1800s, the writer suggested, raids like these would have sent riders out on a long pursuit. The 1962 ranchers meant to do their share and leave the rest to the law.
The men behind the signs
Sod Williams (1922–2001) ran cattle and quarter horses at Arbon with his wife Nelda, of the Ward family, and the papers followed them in the show ring and the arena. The secretary, Claude J. Gibbons, had grown up on a dairy farm at Logan, Utah. His obituary says he and his wife Diane bought an Arbon dry farm in 1962, and by September of that year he was already in the valley and holding office. In 1965 Williams and Gibbons helped lead the drive that brought the valley its first dial telephones.
The association was still going two years later. On November 25, 1964, the Journal reported that the group, which it now called the Arbon Valley Protective Association, had re-elected Williams as president, with Albert Bush as vice president and Gibbons again as secretary. The directors were Louis Estep Jr., Vern Permann, Leland F. Bailey and a man printed only as “Myron”, his surname apparently lost in the typesetting. The $250 reward was still on offer.
Most of those directors can be placed. Leland F. Bailey was very probably Leland Facer Bailey (1906–1995), the Arbon stock raiser of the homesteading Bailey family, whose son Gene was the boy in the 1954–55 search. The paper’s Louis Estep Jr. was probably Luther “Louie” Estep Jr. (1925–2004), who farmed at Arbon from 1947 to 1986 with his wife, Eileen Ward Estep. Vern Permann was probably the man of that name who married Lorita Bolingbroke of the Bolingbroke family in 1956. Albert Bush, Jay Nuckles and the director called Myron have not been identified.
More about the valley’s two settlements is on the Arbon area and Crystal pages. The papers searched so far are silent on whether anyone ever claimed the $250, whether a thief was caught, or how long the association lasted. What they do show is a valley that, in 1962, chose to keep its own watch through the winter rather than leave its empty houses to whoever came over the passes.