Otto Andrew Andersen, the eldest of the Mendon brothers who broke ground at the head of Bannock Creek, died on Saturday, November 19, 1960, at 85. He had left his Arbon land only eleven years before. The Idaho Sunday Journal carried his obituary the following morning, calling him one of the valley’s early homesteaders.
He was one of three. Andrew and Sophia Andersen of Mendon, Utah, sent their sons north to farm in the 1890s, and several of them took up homesteads in what became Arbon Valley. Magnus went back to Mendon about 1911 to look after his parents and died there in 1947, so by 1920 the brothers left in the valley were Otto, John and Ezra. Over eight years, from 1956 to 1964, the Pocatello paper recorded the close of their lives, and with them the story of the Andersen brothers who stayed.
A golden wedding
John came first in those pages. On Sunday, March 4, 1956, the Idaho Sunday Journal reported that Mr. and Mrs. John C. Andersen would observe fifty years of marriage the next Saturday. Friends were invited to call between 3 and 7:30 p.m. at the Ninth LDS Ward at Hawthorne and Quinn, with a program to follow, and the couple asked that no one bring gifts.
John was born at Mendon on May 22, 1877. The notice said he was 16 when he left home with his brothers to claim land in Arbon, and it placed him among the valley’s earliest settlers, a dry farmer and rancher. His wife, Sena Sorensen, was born at Smithfield, Utah, on August 7, 1883. They were married in the Logan temple in 1906 and moved to Pocatello in 1946, when John gave up farming. Six of their seven children were still living, and there were 22 grandchildren and eight great-grandchildren. Sena died in April 1959, and John followed that August. Both died at Clifton, Idaho.
The eldest son
Otto was born at Mendon to Andrew and Sophia Larsen Andersen and went to school there. The Pocatello obituary set his birth on March 10, 1975, a misprint for 1875. It said he came into Arbon Valley and claimed a homestead in 1893. That was the year he and John raised a log house on his place, which the Andersen family accounts count as the first house in the valley; other early accounts give that honor to David Bowen’s cabin. His homestead entry itself dates from 1901.
He married Retta Hansen in the Logan Temple. The paper said 1901, but the family’s records give 1902. Retta died on November 7, 1931, the date the Pocatello paper printed correctly; the Logan paper had it as 1941. Her death and funeral are told in the post on the brothers’ mother, Sophia Andersen of Mendon.
Otto farmed at Arbon until 1949. Even two years after that, when he called on his sister Catherine Gibbons at Mendon in 1951 with his daughter Clara, Mrs. Roy Grube, the Logan Herald Journal still listed him as Otto Anderson of Arbon, Idaho. In his last years he made his home in Twin Falls.
The two papers placed his death in different towns. The Pocatello obituary said he died at St. Anthony Hospital in Pocatello, where he had come to visit relatives and friends. The Logan Herald Journal of November 21 said he died at his daughter Mrs. Lynn Parker’s home in Twin Falls.
He was a Latter-day Saint. His survivors were four daughters, Mrs. Roy Grube of Poplar, Montana, Mrs. Norma Humphreys of Salt Lake City, Mrs. Lynn Parker of Twin Falls and Mrs. Ivan Hewitt of Pocatello; a son, Harold Andersen of Alameda; two brothers, E. T. Andersen of Pocatello and George L. Andersen in California; a sister, Mrs. Annie Pett of Nyssa, Oregon; 14 grandchildren; and 14 great-grandchildren. When the Pocatello paper went to press no service had been set, and the Downard Funeral Home was to announce the arrangements. The Logan paper gave them: a funeral Tuesday afternoon in the Mendon Ward chapel. He was buried at Mendon.
The last of the three
Ezra, the youngest of the three, lived on more than three years after Otto. As far back as January 1918 the American Falls Press had named E. T. Anderson, almost surely Ezra, “one of the pioneers of Arbon valley,” when 19 stacks of his wheat threshed out at 2,875 bushels of Turkey Red.
He was born at Mendon on March 3, 1882. His obituary had him coming to the valley with his parents at 12, though the 1900 and 1920 censuses show Andrew and Sophia still living at Mendon. As a boy he herded sheep, and for many years he farmed at Arbon. The paper counted 44 years of sheep shearing, work the family page says he did at Dairy Creek alongside John and Magnus. From 1954 to 1958 he lived in the Salmon River country, then retired to Pocatello. The paper recalled a man who loved to hunt and fish.
On April 12, 1946, at American Falls, he had married Florence Breeze. He belonged to Portneuf Lodge No. 20 of the Independent Order of Odd Fellows, a membership the family page does not record.
Ezra died at St. Anthony Hospital on the evening of Monday, February 17, 1964, after what the paper called a long illness. The Idaho State Journal first gave his age as 80, then 81 in the next day’s funeral notice; his birth date bears out 81. Florence survived him, along with his son Harvey Andersen of Arbon, three stepchildren, his brother George L. Andersen of Los Angeles and his sister, Mrs. Anne Pett, of Parma. A son had died before him, the paper said, most likely Nicholas, who drowned at a flooded crossing of Bannock Creek in 1911.
Bishop Leland B. Dial of the Fourteenth Ward was to conduct the funeral in Pocatello on Thursday, February 20, with the Odd Fellows holding their own ritual service. That afternoon Ezra was to be laid to rest in the family’s plot at the Mendon cemetery.
Fuller accounts of the family are on the pages for Andrew “Otto” Andersen, Ezra Taft Andersen and Eva Arbon, Annie Andersen Pett, George L. Andersen and the Andersen family. The brothers had spent their working lives on Bannock Creek, and in the years recalled in Mendon in winter, Arbon in summer they went home to Cache Valley each fall. In the end, Otto and Ezra made that trip home one last time.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, November 20, 1960, page 2
- Idaho Sunday Journal, March 4, 1956, page 24
- Idaho State Journal, February 18, 1964, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, February 19, 1964, page 2
- Logan Herald Journal, November 21, 1960, page 6
- Logan Herald Journal, August 11, 1951, page 10
- American Falls Press, January 8, 1918, page 3