A man, a woman and a three-year-old girl walked more than 30 miles across the mountains from Bannock Creek to Inkom in June 1951, with a sheriff’s posse behind them. On the second day of the hunt, ranchers from Arbon Valley rode with it.
By Wednesday morning, June 6, the man was standing before the court at the Power County courthouse in American Falls. He was Elgin Mull of Michigan, and his wife, Imogene, and their daughter had been taken into custody along with him. The Idaho State Journal of Pocatello carried the story on its front page that day, under the byline of its roving reporter, Bill Francois, filing from American Falls.
A letter to mail
The trouble began at the home of Sam Paniogue and his wife on Bannock Creek, on the south side of Highway 30 N. The paper gives nothing more exact. That likely places the house on the lower creek, where the stream runs north across Fort Hall Reservation lands toward the Snake River, downstream from the farms of Pauline; earlier in the century those lower creek lands had been allotted and leased. No date is given for the theft, but since the trackers first went out on Monday, June 4, it most likely happened then.
Mrs. Paniogue had gone out to post a letter. When she came back, a stranger was in the house. Mull dropped the two rifles in his hands and ran for his car, where his wife and daughter sat waiting, and drove off with Sam Paniogue in pursuit.
Believing he had turned onto a road that went nowhere, Mull abandoned the car at the Ray Barnard ranch, five miles east of American Falls. Paniogue arrived in time to see him disappear into the brush, the little girl in his arms. Mrs. Mull was still at the car. Paniogue took the keys and went to call the sheriff’s office. She did not stay. When the sheriff arrived the car stood empty, and she had gone off on foot to find her husband somewhere in the hills.
Footprints and rain
Sheriff Bill Hoehnen raised a posse, with help from John Evans, the sheriff of Oneida County. Nothing is known to tie that sheriff to the Evans family of Arbon. The men followed the family’s tracks for six hours on Monday, until the prints ended at a vacant Indian school building on the Bannock Creek road. The paper does not say which building that was.
Rain soaked the hills before the search went on Tuesday afternoon. By then the posse had grown to include Arbon Valley ranchers, none of them named, and riders from the Damsite riding club.
They never caught the Mulls. The three kept walking over the mountains, by a route no one recorded, all the way to Inkom, where they got on a bus headed for Montana. At 7 o’clock Tuesday evening a radio message from Inkom reached Sheriff Hoehnen: a red-haired man and a red-haired woman had ridden out of town on the bus. Its driver had not liked the look of them and tipped off the Pocatello police, who radioed ahead to Blackfoot. Officers there were waiting at the depot and took the family off the bus. Deputy Sheriff Carlos Lounsbury drove the three back to American Falls.
Hungry, he said
Prosecuting Attorney Gregg Potvin said Mull had owned up to the theft: $70 in cash, two wrist watches and an alarm clock, all the property of the Paniogues. Potvin meant to file a charge of larceny, and the case would move on to the district court. How it ended there is not known, and no later report has turned up. Nothing links the Mulls to any family in the valley.
From his jail cell Mull said he had taken the money to buy food for his daughter. He could find no work, he said, and had already pawned his own watch, along with the heater and radio out of the car, to raise cash. Sitting in the sheriff’s office Wednesday morning, he was too spent from the mountain crossing to answer the officers’ questions with much clarity.
The valley’s share of the story is a single line in the paper, but it shows Arbon Valley ranchers saddling up to help a Power County sheriff when someone ran for the Bannock Creek hills. Earlier chases on the valley’s roads are told in Hy Secrist and the wheat thieves at Pauline, 1917 and St. Patrick’s Day near Pauline, 1921. Three years after this hunt, the valley’s ranchers would form a winter patrol of their own.