Come fall, the children of Crystal would have one school to go to instead of two. Martin Hayden, a trustee of School District 14, gave out the news on Monday, May 2, 1932, and his reason was money. He did not say which of the two schools would stay dark.
The district was trimming in other places too. Whoever taught at the Central school that fall would draw $66.50 a month, less than before, and eight people had already put in for the job. The Pocatello Tribune ran the word from Crystal the next day, Tuesday, May 3, in a brief column topped by the cut in wages. In a handful of lines it also carried a new school board, a graduating class of two and a run-in with a bull.
A settlement emptying out
Crystal was the dry-farm settlement up in the high basin where Rattlesnake and Midnight creeks begin, and District 14 had served it for two decades. In 1912 the district put up the Crystal Central School, 28 by 48 feet, at a cost of $1,750. Over the years it also kept small schools going in the outlying neighborhoods. One of them was at Lapland, on the Crystal side of the valley. In the winter of 1923–24 the Crystal schoolchildren wrote up a meeting that shut the Lapland school for a time; their columns that year numbered its district both 18 and 14.
By 1932 dry years and debt were draining the settlement. After the middle of 1931, roughly a dozen Crystal families pulled up and went to a ranch on Kirtley Creek near Salmon, among them Bishop Lorenzo S. “Len” Whiting Jr. and his brothers and their households. The site tells that story in the move to Salmon. A stake report cited in the family research has the bishop, his family and three other families gone by March 30, 1932.
The school election the week before Hayden’s announcement showed the gap. Tom Dickerson, Perry Hatch and a Mr. Hayden were chosen for the Central school board, replacing Len Whiting, John Meyers and Floyd Denning. The Len Whiting who stepped down was almost surely the bishop; on March 9 the Tribune had named “Mr. L. S. Whiting and children” among the guests at a Crystal party. John Meyers was likely John H. Meyers, husband of Mabel Butterfield. Floyd Denning was likely the Crystal farmer married to Rissie Fannin, whose parents’ membership the ward record moved to the Salmon Ward in December 1931. Whether Meyers and Denning were moving away as well, the column does not say.
Martin Hayden was a homesteader born in Sweden, one of the Hayden family, and his wife Margary ran the Crystal post office out of their home from 1923 until 1937. The new board member called Mr. Hayden was probably Martin too, although his brother John had sat on the District 14 board in years past.
Two girls and a teacher from Buhl
Two other schools already had teachers for the coming year. The Lapland school hired Virginia Payne of Buhl, and the Armstrong school hired Ethel Hansen of Pocatello. The Armstrong school was District 6, whose story is told in Eight pupils, three families.
It was Miss Payne who sent in the news from the Whiting school, where she had been teaching. On Friday, April 29, its entire enrollment, two girls named Helen and Florence Whiting, finished the eighth grade. They were probably cousins. Helen was most likely Helen Ruth Whiting, born in 1917 to Ralph and Irene Whiting of Crystal Creek, and Florence most likely Florence A. Whiting, listed as a young daughter of Forres and Margery Whiting in the 1920 census. Back on March 9 a big crowd had gathered at the Ralph Whiting home to surprise Miss Payne and Helen, and they danced and played games through the evening. The paper never said what the occasion was. Nothing in the papers connects Virginia Payne to the Paynes of Arbon.
Ralph Whiting’s family left for the Salmon ranch in October 1932, by the family’s account. The papers checked for this story do not name the school District 14 closed that fall. The Whiting school, with its families going, is a natural guess, but only a guess. A family account also describes a winter school kept in Flora Whiting’s house on the north end beginning in 1925, and whether that was the same school is unknown.
A bull at Lapland
The column closed with George Bradley, a well-known Lapland farmer, who was set upon by a bull in his own farmyard. He came away with bruises and an injured right arm. His hired man, Harold Munk, ran the bull off with a crowbar, and the paper thought Bradley would likely have fared worse had Munk not been there. He was said to be on the mend.
He was almost certainly George Willard Bradley of the Bradley family on upper Rattlesnake Creek, whose land lay near where a family account puts the Lapland neighborhood. He lived five more years and died in 1937.
The valley’s schoolhouses, Crystal’s among them, are gathered in Schools of Arbon Valley. In the spring of 1932, Crystal was learning to make do with fewer of them.