The mountains that wall in the west side of Arbon Valley, between it and Rockland Valley, had gone without a name of their own for as long as anyone had lived beneath them. In January 1928 two of Power County’s oldest residents, Judge W. T. Oliver and W. H. Philbrick, were handed the job of giving them one.
The news came out of American Falls and ran in the Salt Lake Tribune on January 16. The paper thought the assignment unusual even for two men who had seen a great deal, since they were asked “to correct an oversight and select a name for an orphan mountain range.”
A county survey turns up a gap
The oversight came to light through a national effort to settle place names. Some months before, the “United States geographic board” had ordered a survey across the country, and J. D. Case of Boise was put in charge of the work for Idaho. Collecting the names for Power County fell to Mrs. Cora E. Darling, the county superintendent of schools.
Her county held most of the valley. When Power County was carved out of parts of four counties in 1913, Arbon, Pauline and West Fork, and Crystal went into it from Oneida County, while Summit and Buist stayed behind in Oneida; the timeline tells how that division came about.
Mrs. Darling knew the valley firsthand. In the fall of 1923 she spent two weeks making the rounds of the schools in Arbon Valley and Hawkins Basin, and the American Falls Press noted that November how she got from one to the next. Sometimes it was on a grain rack, and now and then a farmer took her in his car. Every so often she chose to walk two or three miles rather than ask anyone to leave the harvest to drive her.
Going through the names already in use, she found that the mountains east of Arbon Valley were called the Bannock range and those west of Rockland Valley the Black Pine range. The range in between had no name at all. The Tribune guessed why: its highest peak had been named Bannock peak “by General Freemont,” and people had come to treat the whole ridge as part of the Bannock range. In truth, the paper said, the two “have a separate entity.” No source read for this post confirms that Frémont named the peak.
The paper’s reasoning also leaned on Bannock peak being the top of the range, and that was doubtful. In 1917 the Press had printed a passage titled “Progressive Bannock Valley” on the same page as Jennie Logan’s history of the valley, which is among the valley’s firsts. It pictured Bannock peak, at 8,000 feet, standing “like a sentinel guarding the approach to the lower end of the valley,” the country the Pauline and West Fork history covers. Yet the same passage put Bowen’s Peak, on the valley’s west side near its middle, “a little higher than Bannock peak.”
Oliver and Philbrick
With the range found nameless, Mrs. Darling turned to the American Falls chamber of commerce for a suggestion, and the chamber passed the question on to Oliver and Philbrick.
Both men were very likely familiar names in the Press. The judge was most probably the W. T. Oliver whose memories of early American Falls the paper ran in 1915. Philbrick was most probably the Representative Philbrick who, in February 1909, stood before a legislative committee with a large map and traced the lines proposed for a new Power County. That report gave no initials, but a Press story the following month named W. H. Philbrick as American Falls’ spokesman on dividing the county at a Republican convention in Malad. The same story said the Power County bill had died that February. The county did not come into being until 1913.
Rock Creek over Valdes
One proposal before the two men was to honor Guadeloupe Valdes, as the paper spelled his name, whom it called the “Spanish cattleman, who was the first settler of the Rockland valley.” The papers read for this post say nothing else about him. Oliver and Philbrick set that idea aside and settled on Rock Creek range, after the stream that runs through Rockland, a name judged “more representative of the county.” It went forward as their recommendation, and the Tribune announced that the mountains south of American Falls, between Rockland and Arbon valleys, “will be known as the Rock Creek range.”
They are not known that way now. U.S. Geological Survey place data list them as the Deep Creek Mountains, in Power County. A modern climbing guide traces them some thirty miles south from near American Falls toward Holbrook, with Arbon Valley to the east and Rockland Valley to the west. It gives the highest summit as Deep Creek Peak, at 8,748 feet, and puts Bannock Peak, along with the northern end of the range, on the Fort Hall Reservation. Whether Bowen’s Peak and Deep Creek Peak are one mountain, the sources here do not say.
Nor do they say whether the Rock Creek recommendation ever reached the geographic board, or when and how the Deep Creek name took hold. Bannock Peak, at least, kept its name and its place in valley life: the Arbon family history tells of Joe Arbon riding a horse up it for his ninetieth birthday. The orphan range got a name in 1928; it simply was not the one the old-timers picked.
The original article
Salt Lake Tribune, January 16, 1928, page 2. Transcribed from the OCR text of the page scan; the paragraph breaks are not certain.
IDAHO RANGE [illegible] NAME
Power County Men Christen Mountains South of American Falls
AMERICAN FALLS, Idaho, Jan. 15.—[illegible] Power county’s oldest inhabitants, Judge W. T. Oliver and W. H. Philbrick, figured in a christening this week. It was a little out of the ordinary, even for the two old timers, for they were called upon to correct an oversight and select a name for an orphan mountain range.
They rose to the occasion, however, and as a result of their collaboration the mountains lying south of American Falls and separating the Rockland and [illegible] valleys will be known as the Rock Creek range.
Discovery of the fact that these mountains were without a name was made by Mrs. Cora E. Darling, county superintendent of schools. Some months ago officials of the United States geographic board ordered a nation-wide survey to establish proper geographic names. J. D. Case of Boise was appointed to take charge of the survey in Idaho, and Mrs. Darling was entrusted with the task of collecting data relating to Power county.
When she began studying geographic nomenclature she found that the mountains on the east side of the Arbon valley had been named the Bannock range, and those on the west side of the Rockland valley had been christened the Black Pine range. The intervening range was without designation, probably due to the fact that its highest peak was christened Bannock peak by General Freemont, and that the mountains had been generally accepted as part of the Bannock range.
In point of fact they have a separate entity, and when Mrs. Darling discovered that the range was nameless, she asked the American Falls chamber of commerce to suggest a title. That body referred the matter to Judge Oliver and Mr. Philbrick.
A suggestion had been made that the range be named in honor of Guadeloupe Valdes, Spanish cattleman, who was the first settler of the Rockland valley, but this was rejected. The name Rock Creek range was considered more representative of the county, and it has been recommended.
Sources
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 16, 1928, page 2
- American Falls Press, February 6, 1909, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 13, 1909, page 8
- American Falls Press, April 1, 1911, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 25, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, March 29, 1917, page 7
- American Falls Press, November 1, 1923, page 1
- Tom Lopez, Deep Creek Mountains, Idaho: A Climbing Guide, April 27, 2014
- TopoQuest, Deep Creek Mountains, Power County, Idaho (U.S. Geological Survey data)