On a Wednesday morning late in February 1924, a big drilling rig stood pounding next to the Central school in Arbon Valley, its bit about 120 feet down. “If Arbon valley doesn’t have a bona fide oil well within the next few months,” the American Falls Press wrote that week, “it will not be for lack of equipment or inability of the drillers. The oil simply won’t be there.”
The drill kept going for five more years. It went down past 900 feet, then 2,000, and by late 1928 a Salt Lake paper was calling it the deepest hole in Idaho. The oil never came.
A dome under the valley
The valley had tried once already. Its first oil well went down on Thomas S. Toyn’s ranch in 1921. In October 1922 Virgil Kirkham, a petroleum geologist for the University of Idaho school of mines and the state bureau of mines and geology, looked at the escarpment of the valley walls and saw the outline of a dome, an upward fold in the rock where oil could collect if there was any below. He also found “much faulting” in nearby areas, which counted against it.
By January 1923 a Pocatello dispatch was listing investors in a new company to drill the valley, among them L. B. Evans, T. B. Evans and Frank W. Swim of Arbon. That November the Salt Lake Tribune reported that Pocatello men had lined up operators for the Arbon Valley dome: S. G. Baker, an oil man from Houston, Texas, and H. C. Harris, a petroleum geologist from Spokane. Together they formed the Gem State Petroleum Company, and many of its backers came off the January list.
The company’s outfit came off the cars at Pocatello on December 5, 1923. The Press reported that it “is said to be the largest oil drilling rig unloaded in the state of Idaho” and weighed it at about 75 tons; the Tribune called it a fifty-ton rig. Harris served as president and Baker as secretary-treasurer. L. B. Evans of Arbon was a member, and the other names likely included valley men as well: E. C. England, Edward H. Davis, T. H. Hill, William Allard and G. A. Brahmstadt. The head driller, W. C. Burt, came with “a record of drilling four deep wells with only one fishing job,” meaning he had needed to fish lost tools out of a hole only once.
Valley children saw it arrive. The Press ran rural school news in the pupils’ own words, and that December the Pauline school wrote that the company was hauling equipment in every day to “sink a well on the Tom Evans place.” A Malad dispatch put the drilling, which began in the second week of January 1924, on the Central school grounds in Section 2, Township 11 South, Range 33 East. In 1925 the District 12 school was described as “next door to the Arbon oil well.” Most likely both point to the same spot, on Evans land beside the school. The site’s pages on Thomas Bowen Evans, Lorenzo Bowen “Ren” Evans and Frank Swim tell more about three of the local investors.
Big days at the big well
The walls of the hole kept caving in at first, which slowed the work until casing arrived. By the end of February it was coming in daily. Valley people, the Press said, were “watching the progress of the well with quiet suspense and are willing to let the drill decide the status of oil.” Baker and Harris were not waiting on the drill. They pictured “acres and acres of tank farms, a big refinery.” A full-page advertisement sold shares at 75 cents, asked Power and Bannock county people to come look at the rig, and announced in capitals: “IT IS A PERFECT ANTICLINAL DOME.”
They did come. In March the school news noted that “Miss Nellie Matthews and Miss Birdie Wacaster went down to see the oil well Sunday,” and the Pauline pupils wrote, “The oil well is running now. They are about 250 feet down in the ground.” The company set aside days for visitors from each town. More than 400 came out from Pocatello on Sunday, April 27. About 100 made the trip with the Malad business organizations on Wednesday, May 21. Decoration Day, Friday, May 30, was to be American Falls day, with a fossil hunt along the escarpment. The notice in the Press, quoting Baker, closed:
This will be a picnic affair and all are invited to go and requested to bring their lunch. Let us make this the big day at the big well.
No report of how that day went has turned up. In June Baker told a group of Pocatello realtors the well was a little past 900 feet and had cost some $14,000, machinery aside.
Eighteen below
The hole stood near 1,440 feet by the end of August. In November J. O. Noggle, who had drilled the first well at Cat Creek, Montana, took over the rig with five men. When the valley hit 18 below zero on Friday, December 19, they kept at it, with about thirty tons of coal on hand and the rig shut inside a housing lined with “thick felt” and heated by “a huge derrick stove.” Work stopped for a time and started again on April 7, 1925, with a fresh crew out of Wyoming.
At about 2,200 feet in March 1926 the bit hit hard black shale. Eleven hours of drilling bought ten inches. That spring Harris wrote an account that the Burley Herald ran and the Mountain Home Republican reprinted:
The well in Arbon valley has reached a depth of 2274 feet. About two weeks ago at a public inspection of the well by spectators, drillers and officers of the company were surprised by the greatest showing of oil and gas so far encountered.
Drilling halted while a string of heavy casing was hauled out to the site. The Burley paper presented Harris as “an outsider,” though other papers identify him as the company’s president.
Receivers, gas and snow
On September 9, 1926, a court at Pocatello put receivers in charge of the company and its well. By December the stockholders, some forty of whom had come to a recent meeting, were moving to reorganize. Visitors from Burley in May 1927 found Harris at work, the hole near 2,300 feet and natural gas flowing open; the test, they were told, would wrap up within thirty days. It did not. Late that year the crew drew out roughly 2,200 feet of casing and set about reaming the hole. “There is gas at Arbon,” an oil column in the Salt Lake Tribune announced in May 1928. In November the same paper reported the test “said to be down around 3000 feet, the deepest well in Idaho,” and noted: “Drilling is very slow.”
The final word found comes from February 1929. More than four years in, the company was drilling still, with snow lying “over eight feet deep” and camp supplies hauled by sled for about eight miles of the road in. No paper yet found tells when the drilling ended or where the rig went, and no producing well is on record. The Arbon area history tells more of the community the rig stood in.
The Press had put it plainly in that first winter: if the drill came up dry, the oil simply would not be there.
The original article
American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 1. Transcribed from the page scan.
Casing Arriving Daily for Arbon Well Which Is Down About 125 Feet
Company Taking Every Precaution to Insure Success.
If Arbon valley doesn’t have a bona fide oil well within the next few months it will not be for lack of equipment or inability of the drillers. The oil simply won’t be there. The big National Standard rig of the Gem State Petroleum was pounding away Wednesday morning as contentedly as if it had positive assurances that a big oily pool lay buried beneath it. The hole was going down as straight as a string and every time the bit came up through the 12½ inch casing it brought fresh signs of progress toward its goal.
The initial progress of the outfit during the last few days has been somewhat slower than had been anticipated due to caveins on the side of the hole. These kept the hole [illegible] filled up and prevented headway [illegible] the bit. Casing came a few days after the trouble occurred, however, and Wednesday 80 feet or more of the widest casing had [illegible] Burt finds it necessary to case in his [illegible]
Will Get Right Start.
Drilling operations, according to Burt, will go slow until the hole is properly started. Much depends on getting “the right start” he says. The bit Wednesday, was biting into the earth at a depth approximately 120 feet. It was going down fast but at least half of the time was untilized with the bailer.
About 600 feet of casing of various sizes was on the ground Wednesday [illegible] during the afternoon and more will continue to come until sufficient casing [illegible] the ground to care for the well [illegible] 3000 [illegible] or so a standard derrick will be erected to care for the additional weight of casing. The derrick now used is that ordinarily seen on a [illegible] rig, though the machinery is of Standard rig capacity in every way.
Planning Big Things.
Arbon valley people are watching the progress of the well with quiet suspense and are willing to let the drill decide the status of oil. In the meanwhile Baker and Harris of the Gem State Petroleum Company are planning for big things and waiting on no one. They see acres and acres of tank farms, a big refinery, and hundreds of derricks already in sight. They [illegible] Arbon Oil Dome is one of the very largest in the United States, has complete closure, and will yield quantities of oil up into the hundreds of millions of barrels.
Sources
- Salt Lake Tribune, October 13, 1922, page 18
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 18, 1923, page 14
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 18, 1923, page 60
- American Falls Press, December 6, 1923, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 19, 1923, page 18
- American Falls Press, December 20, 1923, page 2
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 10, 1924, page 12
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 28, 1924, page 8
- American Falls Press, March 6, 1924, page 4
- American Falls Press, March 27, 1924, page 2
- Salt Lake Tribune, April 30, 1924, page 18
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1924, page 1
- American Falls Press, May 22, 1924, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 29, 1924, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, June 23, 1924, page 3
- Idaho County Free Press, August 28, 1924, page 2
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 19, 1924, page 18
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 23, 1924, page 41
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 20, 1924, page 16
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 21, 1924, page 36
- Salt Lake Tribune, April 8, 1925, page 21
- American Falls Press, October 29, 1925, page 1
- Salt Lake Tribune, March 6, 1926, page 16
- Mountain Home Republican, May 28, 1926, page 5
- Salt Lake Tribune, September 10, 1926, page 18
- Salt Lake Tribune, December 30, 1926, page 14
- Salt Lake Telegram, June 3, 1927, page 25
- Salt Lake Tribune, January 1, 1928, page 18
- Salt Lake Tribune, May 27, 1928, page 32
- Salt Lake Tribune, November 14, 1928, page 16
- Utah Statesman, February 28, 1929, page 3
