In 1894 a widow and her daughter, riding the train west toward a new home in California, got off at Pocatello to visit a son and brother who lived there. A telegram was waiting. The other son, a sailor out of San Francisco who was to have taken them in, had died. They went no farther. The daughter, Benedicta Wrensted, became one of Pocatello’s photographers, and the brother they had stopped to see, Peter, ended up with a ranch over the hills near Crystal in Arbon Valley.
That is how Beryl Taylor told it in a short profile of Benedicta for an Idaho State Journal history section called “Idaho’s First 100 Years.” The page carries no date. The Marshall Public Library archive files it under October 30, 2020, but the section’s name and its mention of a Smithsonian book not yet finished point to an earlier printing, most likely near the state’s centennial in 1990.
A puzzle in the studio
People who studied Benedicta’s pictures knew surprisingly little about the woman who took them, Taylor found. Smithsonian researchers preparing a book on American Indians had recently visited the Bannock County Museum looking for more of her photographs and anything about her life, and some members of the Pocatello city council were curious too.
Taylor gave her birth year as 1859. Her father, a ship’s captain from Denmark, had already been lost at sea. For roughly two decades beginning in the 1890s she ran a studio in Pocatello, photographing weddings, funerals and the town’s prominent citizens, and Taylor judged nearly all of that studio work excellent. Her favorite subjects, by Taylor’s account, were the Indian people of Fort Hall. Some 148 of her glass plates of Bannock and Shoshone sitters were said to have gone to the Smithsonian, many of them with no names attached.
Around 1900, when the business could afford it, a studio was built for her on South Main. Later generations in Pocatello called it the Mountain Folk building. It had recently been sold, and the word was that the new owners meant to remodel it, not tear it down.
In 1913 she left for Hollywood, California. According to her niece, Helen Sherwood of Bellflower, California, she never married and never took another picture after the move. Even with help from Mary Lee Lien, who had charge of the museum, Taylor could confirm little about her or her work, and she closed by calling Benedicta a mystery: a woman with her own business at a time when few women held jobs away from home.
Photographs lent by the Idaho Museum of Natural History ran with the piece. They showed Bannock-Shoshone women in front of the Cox Cobbler Shop, an Indian woman in 1900, Frank George and his wife, and Police Chief Peter Wrensted with his deputies in 1910.
The chief and the forest
Taylor said only a little about Peter, who stayed in Idaho long after his sister had gone. By her account he was chief of police in Pocatello in 1910 and afterward went to work for the Forest Service on the Caribou National Forest.
A 1968 history of the Caribou by its ranger, Tom Farr, as the Journal reported it, gives a different order. Farr named Wrensted the first supervisor of the Pocatello Forest Reserve, set up in 1903, placed him over the Portneuf Reserve in 1907 and put him in charge of a tree nursery on Mink Creek in 1908. The Pocatello Tribune caught him at that work on October 18, 1911, at the government nursery at Camp Steely, 13 miles out of Pocatello. A quarter of a million Douglas fir seedlings were going into the Mink Creek watershed that fall, with Ranger Wrensted overseeing the transplanting at the nursery while Supervisor Bruins directed the crews doing the planting. Which of his jobs came first is not settled by anything read so far.
A homestead over the divide
By then he already had a claim on the far side of the hills. The land notices collected for this site show Peter Wrensted, still listing Pocatello as his address, filing on a homestead in September 1909 in Section 34 of Township 8 South, Range 34 East. In July 1911 he published notice that he would prove it up by commutation in September, naming four Crystal neighbors as his witnesses.
Two summers later the papers called him “of Crystal,” and he stood as a witness for Curtis Gabbert, Howard Tate and Ezra Burwell. That August a Pocatello merchant who drove the Mink Creek road over to Arbon reported that the climb from the forest station on Mink Creek up to Wrensted’s ranch was steep, though an ordinary car could make it. A sheriff’s notice in 1919 located the ranch of Peter T. Wrensted four miles south of the Crystal post office. The road itself is the subject of the Mink Creek road, and the settlement around him of Crystal, the hidden settlement up Rattlesnake Creek.
A Crystal family
The American Falls Press shows a family fully at home in the neighborhood. In 1915 Mr. Wrensted of Crystal lost a cow to frosted alfalfa inside of two hours, and P. T. Wrensted was among seven Crystal farmers picked to grow an acre of peas next to an acre of wheat for the county agent. Mrs. Peter Wrensted, listed as a patron of the Gabbert school, attended the Farmers’ Institute in Pocatello in 1916.
She did Red Cross work through the war years. In November 1919 Mrs. Anna Wrensted was named one of Crystal’s two district chairmen for the Red Cross roll call, the other being Mrs. A. B. Bryant, part of the story told in the valley’s Red Cross in the First World War. Anna and Peter Wrensted both subscribed to the Fourth Liberty Loan at Crystal in October 1918, and the 1920 census there lists Anna M. Wrensted as the wife of Peter T. Wrensted. County school levy statements for 1920 and 1922 show Peter Wrensted of Crystal serving as a district clerk.
Their son Carl, the Press reported in November 1917, had been born in Pocatello in 1892, had always helped on his parents’ ranch and in 1913 had filed on a homestead of his own two and a half miles north of Crystal. That birth date does not square with Taylor’s statement that Peter had been in America only since 1893. Carl’s departure for the army appears in the draft send-offs of 1917, and his cabin in a valley of log cabins. Another son, Paul, was in Pocatello with his father that same November.
Marie and Helen Wrensted were pupils in the Crystal district in 1918, and Helen completed the eighth grade at the Gabbert school in 1921. In December 1923 Mrs. Wrensted gave a party for Helen, who was heading back to her job at “the Tech” in Pocatello. The papers never named the girls’ parents, but the 1920 census lists Marie L. and Helen P. Wrensted, 16 and 12, as daughters in Peter and Anna’s home. The Wrensted house also hosted a Bible class in 1924, noted in Crystal almost deserted.
The 1950 census found Anna still at Crystal, living with her daughter Helen P. Sherwood. Colleen Hayden Turner’s 1978 history of Crystal lists a Helen Wrensted Sherwood among the people she talked with. The niece Taylor quoted from Bellflower was very likely this same Helen, Peter’s daughter.
The family did not leave. In April 1950 the Journal ran a photograph of Carl Wrensted of Crystal as a Power County commissioner, and Farr’s forest history of 1968 noted that Paul was still ranching near the summit between Mink Creek and Arbon, not far from the steep grade a Pocatello driver had once measured by the Wrensted place.
Sources
- Idaho State Journal, October 30, 2020, page 30
- Idaho State Journal, June 14, 1968, Section D, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, June 14, 1968, Section D, page 6
- Pocatello Tribune, October 18, 1911, page 6
- American Falls Press, July 20, 1911, page 8
- Semi-Weekly Pocatello Tribune, August 9, 1913, page 6
- Pocatello Tribune, August 5, 1913, page 5
- American Falls Press, October 14, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, November 11, 1915, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 10, 1916, page 4
- American Falls Press, November 16, 1917, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 30, 1917, page 2
- American Falls Press, March 5, 1918, page 1
- American Falls Press, June 11, 1918, page 3
- American Falls Press, October 29, 1918, page 6
- American Falls Press, March 21, 1919, page 3
- American Falls Press, November 7, 1919, page 1
- American Falls Press, July 2, 1920, page 4
- American Falls Press, May 27, 1921, page 1
- American Falls Press, February 10, 1922, page 4
- American Falls Press, December 13, 1923, page 7
- Idaho State Journal, April 9, 1950, page 3
- 1920 U.S. census, Crystal precinct, Power County, Idaho (sheet image)
- 1950 U.S. census, Crystal Election Precinct, Power County, Idaho, ED 39-12
- Colleen Hayden Turner, “History of Crystal, Idaho” (typescript, August 1978)