For a few weeks in the summer of 1969, a hundred-foot derrick rose out of a farm field in Arbon Valley. It stood on Donald Porter’s place, a mile and a half northwest of the Arbon post office, and the dozen men under it were boring for natural gas, or oil if they were lucky. Nobody had yet found either one in paying amounts anywhere in Idaho, and the well had the valley talking. On Sunday, July 6, the Idaho Sunday Journal carried the well on its front page, under the byline of staff writer Paul Smith.
A gas company goes looking
The search was the idea of Intermountain Gas Co. of Boise. The company was only twelve years old, and every bit of the gas it sold across southern Idaho came from someone else, most of it piped up from the San Juan field in the Four Corners country. A field close to home could stretch that supply or even replace it. Gas was the real target, Stan Day, the company’s Pocatello district manager, told the paper, though oil would be welcome too.
Over several years Intermountain had leased the oil and gas rights on about 55,000 acres of Arbon Valley land, a block roughly 12 miles long and six wide. Landowners were to get one-eighth of anything the ground gave up. L. W. “Red” Hawk, the company’s land manager, said that of all the ground in southeastern Idaho the geologists had looked at, this valley seemed the most promising. They had found the same kinds of rock beds there that hold oil just over the line in Utah and Wyoming.
On March 7, 1969, Intermountain made a deal with two Denver firms. States Oil Co. would run the exploration, and it engaged Signal Drilling Co. to do the boring. Whatever turned up would be shared three ways. Nobody oversold it. Allen Cook of States Oil called it a “rank wildcat operation,” with odds of one in a hundred or longer, and Hawk gave usable gas perhaps one chance in ten.
The holes that came before
The valley had seen drillers before. In 1921 the Idaho Research and Development Co. sank the valley’s first oil well on Thomas S. Toyn’s ranch, told in the Toyn ranch well of 1921–1922. From 1924 until at least 1929 the Gem State Petroleum Co. drilled beside the Central school. Neither hole ever produced.
The 1969 article counted one of those old holes as a reason to try again. A well put down some forty years earlier, it said, had struck a little oil, too little to pump. Hawk knew almost nothing else about it beyond calling it an old “cable-tool hole.” The paper placed it a few hundred yards from the Porter rig, on land Lee Newport farmed in 1969. Lee and Gena Newport had bought Tom and Susannah Evans’s farm in 1940, and in December 1923 the Gem State company was hauling in equipment to “sink a well on the Tom Evans place.” The old hole Hawk had in mind was very probably the Gem State well.
Then came the big oil companies. In 1949 and 1950 Standard Oil Company of California took leases in the valley and talked of a seismic survey. A 1956 page on Idaho’s oil hunt in the Idaho State Journal settled whether it happened: Standard’s geologists had “shot” Arbon Valley in 1951, setting off dynamite in drilled holes and reading the blasts on seismographs to map the rock below. Standard had not been back since. The same page listed Phillips Petroleum’s No. 1 Juniper well, some 42 miles southwest of Pocatello, as finished dry on February 9, 1951, probably the Juniper wildcat announced in 1949.
On the Porter farm
The rig came up from Farmington, New Mexico. The caption under the front-page photo had it driven in from Snowville, Utah, perhaps the last stretch of the trip. A single diesel engine both drove it down the highway, its derrick laid flat, and turned the drill once it was set up. It arrived the weekend of June 28 and 29, and the bit was to start turning on the afternoon of Monday, June 30.
The plan was to go down 3,800 feet or deeper. A bit 12½ inches wide would open the first 300 feet, and a slimmer 7⅞-inch bit would carry on below that, with plenty of spares on hand as bits wore down. Bearing down on the bit was the kelly, about 35,000 pounds of steel pipe around the drill shaft. The crew pumped a mud of dirt and water into the hole to hold its walls and lift the cuttings out, drawing the water from a well some 300 yards off.
The cuttings went to James Meinsohn, an independent Denver geologist who hired out his know-how and equipment to exploration outfits. In a trailer at the site he studied them under a microscope and ultraviolet light, while an electronic detector told him whether gas was coming up and what kind. The crew were experienced men who moved from field to field. Audie Jones of Farmington was the pusher, as oil hands call the boss of a drilling crew, and Signal vice president Larry Stone was the engineer in charge.
The companies meant to keep quiet about the results for as long as they could. Other sites had reportedly been picked out, but drilling them depended on what this first one showed. “The drill bit is going to tell the tale,” Hawk said. The men expected to know in a month or so.
A dry hole
The ground fought back. Signal reported on Wednesday, July 9, that after about a week of round-the-clock drilling through hard rock, the hole was past 2,500 feet with no trace of oil or gas.
On Sunday, August 3, the Idaho Sunday Journal reported that the drilling was over. Signal had quit at 3,677 feet, short of its goal. “There was not a show at the depth we went,” Hawk said. He did not count the valley out, nor did he think the test had proved anything either way. The rock was harder than expected, a deeper try would take a bigger rig, and oil companies were holding back while Congress weighed cutting their depletion allowance and money stayed tight. Intermountain was still paying rent on its leases and hoped to drill again, maybe within a year. As of Friday, August 1, Signal’s rig was still sitting in the field.
No later report has turned up. The papers never said whether anyone came back to drill, how long the leases lasted, or what the landowners were paid, and they told nothing of Donald Porter beyond his name and his farm. The last echo came in September 1980, when a Journal correspondent at Malad, writing about seismic crews at work across Oneida County where the Overthrust Belt meets its western margin, recalled old newspaper accounts of a well near Arbon that had once brought up a little oil. Nothing in that report puts the 1980 crews in Arbon Valley itself. More of the valley’s story is in the Arbon area history.
So the valley’s third try at oil ended like the first two, with a hole in a farm field and the rent still being paid on the hope.
Sources
- Idaho Sunday Journal, July 6, 1969, page 1
- Idaho Sunday Journal, July 6, 1969, page A-3
- Idaho State Journal, May 8, 1969, page 1
- Idaho State Journal, June 16, 1969, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, June 24, 1969, page 2
- Idaho State Journal, June 30, 1969, page 6
- Idaho State Journal, July 11, 1969, page 3
- Idaho Sunday Journal, August 3, 1969, page 3
- Idaho State Journal, July 5, 1956, page 20
- Idaho State Journal, September 15, 1980, page B-1
- American Falls Press, December 20, 1923, page 2
- Salt Lake Telegram, November 21, 1949, page 22