Frank Phelps was 45 and farming in Arbon Valley in 1934 when he was caught out in the weather and froze to death. His only son, Jesse “Bud” Phelps, was 14. The boy quit school and gave all his time to the family farm.
No paper of the day has yet been found that reports the death. Most of what is known comes from two later sources: Bud’s obituary, printed eighty years afterward, and a genealogy posted online. The old papers do catch glimpses of the man in the twenty years before.
A Sunday evening in South Arbon
Phelps first turns up in the summer of 1915, in the South Arbon column of the American Falls Press. That column carried the news of the Highland neighborhood, in the Summit country at the valley’s south end, where a new schoolhouse was about to go up. The school district there belonged to Oneida County, which held on to the lower valley when Power County was formed in 1913.
The August 12 column told of a Sunday evening when Miss Rosie Neal had a few friends in at her sister’s home. Four young men were among the guests: “Messrs. James Nunnelley, Clyde Johnson, Pierce Hardman and Frank Phelps.” Higher up, the same column took stock of the harvest. Frost had hurt the crops again, though less than in 1914. Some farmers were cutting their spring grain for hay, but the fall grain had mostly come through.
That October the Press reported that Phelps had been called to Kansas “on account of the serious illness of his mother.” The name of the town is garbled in the digitized text.
The family he came from
A website, the Paul Bartlett Van Buren Genealogy, fills in more, citing a family genealogy that Felix George Foudray compiled in 1964. Its Frank Phelps was born August 23, 1889, to Jasper W. Phelps and Motie E. Foudray. His mother died on April 19, 1916. He married a woman named Rose and had a younger brother, Ira.
The genealogy names no places, but its details line up with the Arbon man: the mother’s illness and death, the wife called Rose, Bud’s age when his father died, and the brother. An Ira Phelps and his wife were among the guests at an Arbon party on Thanksgiving evening in 1920, the Press reported that December. The genealogy’s Frank Phelps is very likely the same man.
A household at Arbon
Frank and Rose Phelps raised five children at Arbon: a son, Jesse M., called Bud, born there on May 24, 1920, and four daughters, Francis, Thyra, Elaine and Annabel. The Arbon column looked in on them now and then. “Frank Phelps baby was quite sick the past week but is recovering nicely,” it said on July 16, 1920. It gave no name, but Bud would have been about seven weeks old.
In April 1921 the column reported that “Mrs. Wright of Twin Falls visited the past few days with her sister in South Arbon, Mrs. Frank Phelps.” In December 1922 it named Frank Phelps among the neighbors who had gone visiting at Malad, the Oneida County seat.
By 1934 he had a part in the New Deal farm programs. The Arbon family history on this site, telling of the valley’s farm committees in those years, lists him that year with J. N. Arbon and J. L. Payne on the Arbon wheat-allotment committee.
Caught in the weather
The genealogy gives his death as Sunday, November 25, 1934, but does not say where or how he died. Bud’s obituary, printed in the Power County Press in March 2014, says that his father “got caught in the elements and froze to death.”
Snow had reached the region that weekend. On Monday, November 26, the Pocatello Tribune ran a wire story under a headline announcing a blanket of snow over southeastern Idaho. Salt Lake City had its first snowfall of more than a trace that winter and its coldest reading of the season so far, and Pocatello reported an inch. On the same page a dispatch from Ogden told of a blizzard in northern Utah on Sunday night. Whether that storm was the one that caught Frank Phelps is not known.
The Tribune’s front pages of November 26 and 27 say nothing of his death. The Power County Press for that week, where a report would most likely have run, could not be searched. Where he was caught, when he was found and where he was buried have yet to be learned. If your family knows more about Frank Phelps or the day he died, the site would be glad to hear it through the Contribute page.
He was not the only valley man the cold claimed. The site’s Stories pages tell of Frank Kulock, who froze within sight of his home near Pauline in 1922, and of the winter of 1948–49.
The boy who ran the farm
Bud kept the farm going. On June 8, 1944, he married Waunita Hutton of American Falls. In time he left farming to drive truck from coast to coast, and the family spent ten years in Omaha before moving back to American Falls in 1961. He then put in twenty years with Simplot in Pocatello, retiring in 1985. His parents and his sister Annabel had gone before him when he died in American Falls on March 7, 2014, at 93.
It was his obituary, eighty years after the fact, that told how his father died.
The original article
American Falls Press, August 12, 1915, page 4. Transcribed from the page scan.
SOUTH ARBON
S. A. Cram is home again after spending most of the summer in Malad where he has been under the care of a physician. He is somewhat improved but still fears he will loose his sight.
Homer Young was quite sick last week but is able to be at work again.
Miss Amy Johnson was the guest of her sister, Mrs. Lee Van Horn last week.
[illegible] Ralph returned from Rockland last week, with another nice bunch of cattle.
Lavere King of Logan, Utah, is here to spend the summer with his parents Mr. and Mrs. Andrew King.
Pierce Hardman has returned from a two weeks’ visit with his home folks in Mendon, Utah.
The frosts have done considerable damage to crops in this section but not nearly so much as last year. A number of people are cutting their spring grain for hay, but most of the fall grain is good.
Clyde Johnson and Lee Van Horn came out with a new header Tuesday.
W. A. Nunnelley was quite sick the first of last week but is better at this writing.
Mr. and Mrs Jack Folsom have moved back to their ranch.
Mrs. E. O. Lee and children visited at Tom Stott’s and Truey Lee’s the first of last week.
Vernon, the little two year-old son of Mr. and Mrs. Joe Jenson has been quite ill with stomach trouble for the past two weeks.
Pearl Lee, Mr. and Mrs. J. R. Stott and Mamie Nunnelley have just returned from a fishing trip to Sublett Lake. They report a fine time and brought a number of nice salmon trout and young chickens home with them.
Miss Rosie Neal entertained a few of her friends Sunday evening at the home of her sister, Mrs. Judy [illegible], and all report having had a very enjoyable time. Those present were Misses Irene and Thelma Nunnelley and Amy Johnson; Messrs. James Nunnelley, Clyde Johnson, Pierce Hardman and Frank Phelps.
The board of trustees of District No. 12, Oneida county have purchased a three acre lot, joining the church lot, on Mamie Nunnelley’s land and Mr. McIntyre, the contractor intends to start working on the new school building this week. He means to have the house completed to start school in September.
George Davis has been sick for the past week but is improving now.
Albert Swenson has sold his homestead to Mr. [illegible] from Washington.
Miss Bird, of Cache valley is the guest of her sister Mrs. [illegible] Hardman.
The young people of the Highland Sunday school gave a social Saturday evening at the church for the young people of the community. The evening was spent in varius games after which cake and punch were served. All present seemed to enjoy themselves to the fullest extent.
The farmers in this part of the valley begun heading Monday, August 2.
W. H. Smith and family and Rev. Sturges were the guests of Mr. and Mrs. George Bollinger Sunday.
[illegible] Merrill, of the First National Bank of Pocatello, Idaho, came out in his car last Sunday.
Sources
- American Falls Press, August 12, 1915, page 4
- American Falls Press, October 14, 1915, page 6
- American Falls Press, July 16, 1920, page 3
- American Falls Press, December 3, 1920, page 2
- American Falls Press, April 8, 1921, page 2
- American Falls Press, December 7, 1922, page 5
- Pocatello Tribune, November 26, 1934, page 1
- Pocatello Tribune, November 27, 1934, page 1
- Power County Press, March 12, 2014: Jesse (Bud) M. Phelps (archived copy)
- Power County Press, March 26, 2014: Jesse (Bud) M. Phelps, corrected (archived copy)
- Paul Bartlett Van Buren Genealogy: Frank Phelps
- Paul Bartlett Van Buren Genealogy: Jasper W. Phelps and Motie E. Foudray